Car Advice

Are Electric Cars Silent Killers?

By Garreth Miers |

Electric cars; Are these smooth, green, efficient vehicles also silent killers?

In developing the petrol engine, manufacturers have always strived to make engines smoother and more importantly quiet. Electric powered vehicles have this perfected, making almost no audible sound at low speeds, though it is this fact that is now raising concerns for pedestrian safety.

A study by the US Highway Traffic Safety Administration has found that hybrid vehicles (running on electric power) are twice as likely to be involved in traffic collisions involving a pedestrian, simply due to the silent approach of these vehicles.

US governments are taking this concern seriously with approving an Auto safety bill calling for all future electric and hybrid vehicles to be fitted with an audible alert system to make pedestrians aware of their presence. The bill is expected to reach the Full House where a decision will be made later this year.

In the build up to the launch of mass market electric cars, the US government has been very proactive in recognising this potential problem. The fear is that if pedestrians do not hear the approach of an electric vehicle they may accidently step into its path, causing injury.

Auto makers are not fond of the new bill, believing that it will hinder the driving experience of their vehicles if they are to emit an electronic alert sound. Nonetheless Japanese manufacturer Nissan is already experimenting with chimes and other electronic alerts on their upcoming Leaf model.

While the safety concern is quite valid, the question rises as to how these systems will work? Are we looking at a future where cities will be filled with the drone and ping of electric cars ‘warning pedestrians’?  Even so, we look forward to seeing what system Nissan is developing for the new Leaf.


 
  • Fenno

    That’ll blow the whole “stop, look & listen” campaign
    back to just “stop ‘n look”.

  • Oosh

    Clearly the only sensible option is ‘La Cucaracha’ and maybe ‘Greensleeves’ for the older set.

    • Paul

      …or for the retro lovers, the sound of horses hooves approaching?

      • DGS

        Star Wars fans might want their EV to play a Tie Fighter or Racing Pod sound effect.

        There could be many hidious sounds to make a silent car noisy. Legislation will be required to spare us from that damn Crazy Frog Ringtone being used as a engine sound subsitute.

  • Electron

    I work at a dealership that sells electric vehicles. We have had a couple of Yardman hit by Hybrid cars that run only electric power at low speeds so lack any audible recognition of approach. After conducting risk assessment and an OHS plan we now need to beep the horn twice when seeting off and driving around the yard. So i can see what the fuss is all about but we’ll adapt and cars will get better at pedestrian avoidence and protection – They all ready are…

  • Toxic_Horse

    How about a star wars TIE Fighter sound

    • My Cars Called T-Rex

      Why don’t they make it so you can download any sound you want via USB,.I’d go for M1 Abrams tank.

    • Minnow

      I’d want the Captain Planet theme song…. “Captain planet, hes our hero, gonna take you down to zero!” Oh yeh rock on dude…

  • http://www.lukehimself.net Luke

    I think they need an artificial Jetsons space-car sound.

    • Steve-Poyza

      Easily by FAR the best suggestion so far! :D

    • ADLover

      I like sound of from movie “Jaws”….
      Da Da, Da Da, Da Da Da Da…Da da da da~~n !!!

  • greenroom

    they’d fix this problem so easily by dropping in a V8 427 big block chevy engine no worries, straight thru exhaust…problem solved, audible.. simple.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sammo.8191 Sam Moss

    I’m not looking forward to the future at all..
    I love the sound of car engines too much. :(

  • svd

    Toy cars used to have a toothed wheel somewhere which rotated and a piece of flat spring against it to generate a sound, some even had sparks from a flint which shot out the front. Maybe this will work?

    • Radbloke

      Why not just stick a basketball card to the brake caliper, BMX styles?

  • Peter Stone

    Hasn’t this subject been done to the death… Pardon the pun.

    Stoney!

  • Paul

    “audible alert system” Yeah, it’s called a HORN!

    Absolutely no question oil/coal backed interests are behind this stupid law.

    Kids in primary school are taught to look both ways before crossing and Electric Cars certainly won’t be driving done footpaths, so the only way to get bowled over is if a careless pedestrian walks into the path of a motor vehicle. Might teach them to LOOK next time!

    Lets get the guys with flags out again to march down the road ahead of every EV sold…

  • JEKYL & HYDE

    i think i’ll start a company manufactoring human friendly poly “enviro” bars.perfect for low speed impacts into old biddies who cannot turn their necks,young kids with ipods,and of course,and last night drunken,drugged out party goers.should be a sensation…

  • http://www.caradvice.com.au Jim Goose

    How about if pedestrians simply use their eyes before crossing? I was taught that at school and I’m still here 35 years later. We shouldn’t go backwards by making cars noisy again. Don’t rely on your ears,your eyes are far more reliable-so use them.

  • MatthewM

    If this is instituted, electric car’s must be made to sound like:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QdWswvLPdE0

  • Minnow

    Yes… because they had Prius’ driving around in 1985. Back in your day they had 351′s and fully sick VL’s driving around making all kinds of racket.

    And give some kind consideration to blind people. Hey blind people no offence ;)

  • ox

    How bout the sound of an F1 car

    • DGS

      … or an old Steam Train if you want to be really retro.

  • Flying High

    “In developing the petrol engine, manufacturers have always strived to make engines smoother and more importantly quiet.”

    Look I am not sure which cars you might be talking about, but the most desirable of cars have always had an engine note that made it MORE noticeable. It is in part what makes the car what it is. Seriously, can you imagine a V8 that was dead quiet so as to not offend pedestrians? Or a boxer motor that sounds like a whispering breeze?

    You want the engine sound, and the saddest thing about electric cars is the fact they will not have any auditory character about them at all, other than the possibility of some lame soundtrack. Like a Priarse pumping out a thumping v8 burble so that it can be heard…