Car Advice

Land Rover Freelander 2 Review & Road Test

LAND ROVER FREELANDER 2

Pros: Brilliant fuel economy; quiet stop/start; price; features

Cons: Weight; only available in manual

By Paul Maric |
Add to shortlist

Price: $35,640 to $55,320

Our Rating:  

2010 Land Rover Freelander2 TD4.e Review and Road Test

Welcome to Australia’s most efficient SUV.

Model Tested:

  • 2010 Land Rover Freelander2 TD4.e; 2.2-litre, four-cylinder, turbo-diesel; six-speed manual; wagon – $45,590*

Options:

  • Full length sunroof  $3,300; Style package $1,900

CarAdvice Rating: rating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gif

By Paul Maric

While this Freelander2 may look like any other Freelander2 on the road, there are some inherent differences – most of which lie under the skin.

The TD4.e is Land Rover’s attempt at being green. Its gone against the grain of hybrid technology and stuck with diesel, opting for a manual gearbox and stop/start technology.

I wasn’t convinced though, so when Land Rover offered CarAdvice the first road test in Australia, I jumped at the chance to give it a shot.

Well, first thing’s first. Aside from the Defender, Land Rover doesn’t offer a manual gearbox in Australia on any of its vehicles. I then had the impression that the gearbox might be a bit ordinary, considering its lack of ‘experience’ in the field of passenger vehicle gearboxes.

Land Rover Freelander2 TD4.e

Jumping out of our long term Proton Jumbuck, which requires half a foot of clutch travel, and into the Freelander2 TD4.e is a shock to the senses. The clutch has a very short uptake and is as sharp as a tack when it grabs.

Once you get used to the clutch though, you get a chance to experience the tight gearbox. If you weren’t in an SUV, you’d think you were in a sports car, such is the fluency and accuracy of the gear shifts.

So let’s quickly run through the technical aspects of the system. In a nutshell, the car will switch the engine off when yu stop and come back on when you set off again. I can already hear you screaming about the starter motor, Land Rover has that part sorted.

Land Rover Freelander2 TD4.e

An up-rated starter motor has been fitted to the TD4.e, with the grease seals enhanced and a new hard wearing copper-tungsten contact material to increase wear resistance with the starter solenoid.

In addition to the revised starter motor, Land Rover has introduced a dual mass flywheel friction plate, which is meant to increase refinement at start, stop and at low speeds.

The first time the engine switches off at the lights, it gives you a bit of a start as you can feel it switch off and it kind of feels wrong to be sitting there with the engine off.

Land Rover Freelander2 TD4.e

After a week of driving though, you start to question why all cars don’t do this. Aside from auxiliary functions like the alternator and air-conditioning, there’s no reason the car should remain running while stationary in traffic.

Can you imagine how much of a difference this type of technology alone would make to the planet if all cars were equipped with it?

Anyway, I’ll get off my eco-horse and move right along.

People do look at you strangely when it switches off next to them with their window open. They think you’ve stalled, or you’re being a massive tight wad. It’s also a bit annoying when the car switches off and seconds later you need to move off again, it just seems like unnecessary stress on the engine’s components.

Land Rover Freelander2 TD4.e

Land Rover claims a 20 per cent saving on fuel and carbon emissions with the stop/start technology.

Here are my findings: 878km from 56 litres of fuel, and by my calculations, that’s about 6.37-litres per 100km. The regular TD4 Freelander2 achieves a combined 8.5L/100km, making our achievement a 25 per cent fuel efficiency gain.

To me, that’s a remarkable figure, especially when you consider that producing this technology has a negligible impact on the environment in comparison to a conventional hybrid, which may make up for emissions by running on batteries, but seldom makes up for the carbon cost of producing and destroying batteries.

Land Rover Freelander2 TD4.e

At the core of the system is Land Rover’s 2.2-litre, four-cylinder, turbo-diesel engine. It produces 118kW and a staggering 400Nm of torque. While it pulls very well in any gear, the Freelander2’s weight of 1775kg is the entire package’s only limiting factor.

The Freelander2’s suspension overcomes the harshness of its off-road tyres and soaks up everything the road has to offer. Although it won’t corner like a sports car, the suspension’s compliance makes the body roll controllable and a non-issue.

While the Freelander2 is great on-road, you can only call it remarkable off-road. You may recall our three stage report on Land Rover’s cross Australia journey. The stand out car was the Freelander2 which was able to single-handedly traverse each and every sand dune thrown at it.

Land Rover Freelander2 TD4.eLand Rover Freelander2 TD4.e

The Freelander2’s more than capable four-wheel-drive system has a Terrain Response knob that allows on the fly selection of various 4WD modes, these in turn tailor the 4WD system for the type of terrain the vehicle is traversing.

The vehicle’s 210mm ground clearance and 500mm wading depth make it a model SUV for mild off-road driving.

The TD4.e is placed as an entry level model in Land Rover’s range, priced from $45,590, but entry level pricing doesn’t mean entry level equipment levels though.

Standard fitment includes: dual zone climate control; electric windows; electric mirrors; folding mirrors; rear parking sensors; automatic windscreen wipers; automatic headlights; front and rear fog lights; 17-inch alloy wheels; full-size spare wheel; cruise control and CD player with six-speakers and MP3 capability (with AUX jack).

Land Rover Freelander2 TD4.e

Inside the cabin, a spacious interior allows enough room to carry five passengers in relative comfort, while catering for 1670-litres worth of storage space with the rear seats folded down.

The Freelander2 is a premium SUV that drives and feels like a road-going sedan. It’s capable at climbing almost any hill thrown at it and has enough interior room to cart passengers and cargo.

Better still, Land Rover has now produced its most fuel efficient vehicle, while steering clear of hybrid technology, which, let’s face it, won’t stand the test of time if battery technology doesn’t improve.

Land Rover Freelander2 TD4.e

At just under $46,000, Land Rover has a real gem on their hands and it’s a car that I can’t recommend highly enough. It was hard to pick a fault with the Freelander2

An automatic variant of the stop/start technology will follow in the months to come, but until then users are stuck with a six-speed manual gearbox, not such a bad thing considering how smooth the gearbox is.

Land Rover Freelander2 TD4.eLand Rover Freelander2 TD4.e

If you’re in the market for a super frugal, sub $50k SUV, look no further. The Freelander2 TD4.e is your only choice.

Ratings:

CarAdvice Overall Rating: rating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gif

How does it Drive: rating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gifrating_half.GIF

How does it Look: rating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gif

How does it Go: rating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gif



     

    Reader reviews of the LAND ROVER FREELANDER 2

    <

    Write a review for the LAND ROVER FREELANDER 2

    Do you own this car? Share your opinion and add your own review below.

    Add a New Review
    >
    • TomR

      Officially my favourite SUV.
      I did like the Tiguan better… but it seems a bit tinny and not very european.
      This just reeks of quality and beautiful styling and ruggedness and well, EVERYTHING.
      Shame its a bloody Land Rover… which means it’ll fall to bits.
      Well, here’s hoping Land Rover’s finally learnt to build their cars right, because I REALLY hope this beast is a success.

      I wonder though, how much of that fuel economy gain is attributed to the manual gearbox? Can we get some oversea’s comparison’s where it might be offered with a manual without the stop-start system?

    • DipStiK

      Agreed, given the shocking reliability of Land Rovers from the past, I would not trust a starter motor from these guys that works 20-40 times a day compared to 2-4 for normal cars. Manual would be my choice, when the starter packs-up you can push start it. I wonder if the warranty covers the starter motor unconditionally or is there a clause that says if used in stop start conditions the warranty is not valid ??

    • 4:20 All Day

      I also agree.
      Even with a better starter motor, there is no way the actual unit will last as long as a standard starter if it is being used, on average, 10 times as much. Especialy if it is produced by Land Rover.
      But, apart from that, this seems like a decent vehicle.

    • Hagar

      I wonder how much a copper-tungsten starter would cost to replace, does not sound cheep. Also starter motors use 60-100+Amps each time. Imagine a hot WA day, say typical 40C stuck on the freeway in peak hour, how hot would the starter get in stop start traffic. Surely there must be a limit.

    • Model T

      I have always believed that diesels are the way to go rather than the environmentally ambiguous hybrids. I like what Land Rover have done – although it’s not all that dissimilar to established practice in many European countries (switching engines off at the lights, in bumper-to bumper-traffic, etc). But the doubts about long-term reliability cannot be ignored, even if Freelander 2 seems to be way ahead of its predecessor. It looks like we have finally turned the corner in our attitudes to cars and their environmental impact. The Freelander 2 TD4e simply enhances that argument. And that can only be a good thing.

    • JimJam

      What a fantastic car! That fuel consumption is unreal. Probably the perfect family/holiday car.

    • Jimmy James

      Mr Maric, can you confirm whether or not the stop/start function is switchable, as per some other vehicles such as the BMW Mini.

      Thanks
      JJ

    • Reckless1

      Well, judging by the big ECO button on the dash, I’d say it’s switchable.

      But the fuel savings from stopping it at the lights are likely to be eaten up by the fuel used for the frequent tow truck trips the car will need……..

      6.3l/100 is only average for a 1700kg car, it’s not state of the art. The shape of it is a brick, which would work against ultimate economy.

      But I quite like this vehicle, albeit it’s a bit small behind the rear seats.

    • http://skyline The Salesman

      Paul,

      Did you experience heavy traffic with constant every few seconds stop start movement? You know, you get up to 3kph the stop and almost immediately start again. I would be interested to know how it went.

    • Rob

      The engine will only stop when the car is in Neutral and the clutch released so heavy traffic would unlikely be an issue.

    • http://skyline The Salesman

      Thanks Rob. Makes sense now :)

    • http://Caradvice.com.au Baddass

      Lovely car, and finally shows that 4WD’s don’t have to be gas-guzzling stereotypes. And it is cheaper than the normal Freelander!

    • Ethan

      i hate that green lcd… reminds me of late 1980′s, apart from that i like this baby rover… not sure about the stop/start system as like many others here i think reliability will be an issue…

    • arlester

      My question is. How does the starter motor work. Does it crank like when you would normally start a car or does it work in the same the Honda Hybrid works and just start the motor without any need for cranking?

    • John of Perth

      Like many others I think the stop/start sequence is somewhat gimmicky & maybe prone to failure/wear – pity though they could not filter the manual gearbox to the HSE.

      As a comparision, my manual Xtrail TL DCi with the Renault 2l 127kW/360nm motor after 33000kms, has returned an average of 7.2l/100km.

    • Lil Red Rooster

      So does the air con turn off when the engine stops ? I would have to assume this to be the case, can’t imagine that would be much fun in summer, nor this mild ( hot ) winter some of us are having.
      This vehicle seems fantastic, and if built well could last you a lifetime, so its’ reasonable price could be money well spent, compared to much of the asian fare on offer.

    • Alex

      TomR, I’m pretty sure that there’s about 7MPG difference between a regular manual Freelander 2 and the e version.

      I trust Land Rover completely, but I can’t say I’m keen on stop start systems from any brand. They work well, but will they still work well in ten years? Besides, wait another two years and you’ll get this economy without having to use stop start at all. I wouldn’t be surprised if the Freelander gets new engines when the facelift comes. They’ll probably be making new engines for the next X Type so it would make sense.

    • Alex

      Just to add, I think this car is well priced and looks great. I like how unpretentious it is too. No more than a little “e” badge to let people know how economical it is. Toyota could learn a great deal from Land Rover.

    • http://www.carazoo.com/ Carazoo.com India

      Nice review with great pics. :-)

    • Robin Graves

      What about the turbo? Hot day, accelerating on the freeway, come to a busy merge lane where all the idiots stop instead of merging, engine shuts off with a cranked up turbo? Surely they must have an electric oil pump too to keep the turbo oiled up until it spools down?

    • Carfanatic

      I wonder if they have sorted the reliability issues yet? The Rental car company I used to work for made loads of money out of Freelanders. Rented Land Rover so many courtesy cars it wasn’t funny.

    • Roca Nera

      ‘At just under $46,000, Land Rover has a real gem on their hands and it’s a car that I can’t recommend highly enough’
      Sounds to good to be true and a bit of realty check is necessary. Land Rover Freelander 2 Diesel standard could be moved from the dealer on the roads for ‘just’ 58 K. You want an HSE you must push more chips on the table let’s say 5- 10 K.
      It is a good car, but how will stay the test of time for reability, service costs etc?
      If that statement is true Land Rover will beat Subaru, Toyota, Nissan etc as leader in SUV sales.
      Cheers,
      RocaNera

      • Jim

        This article is about the TD4.e which can be driven away for less than 50K. No reality check is necessary. Regarding service costs: note that LR has a corporate program. This means there is a good chance that you get three years of free service if you work for a large employer.

    • Roca Nera

      Great site and day to day drivers and car enthusiasts imput is crucial for your success!
      Cheers,
      RocaNera

    • Andrew

      Well just completed another road trip with my FL2 (non _e), about 4000km over 2 weeks. This was a work trip so involved loading all the gear for the family (glad I could take them) and then while there carrying 350kg in gear around all day. Had the weekend free so off I went to check out the national park and drive along some forest trails. By the end of it though I just wanted to get home, cruise control on, changing the radio with the wheel controls and effortlessly overtaking cars with the 400Nm of torque. 650Km later and still 1/4 tank left. The FL2 is a great all round vehicle, next weekend it will get loaded again and taken camping but not before it pulls a trailer around full of gravel so I can get my retaining wall built!

      • Anne

        Andrew, it makes a change to hear some positive feedback on the FL2!! We are looking at buying one, but, all the negativity is very daunting. How long have you had your car for, & which model is it?

    • Peter B

      I have just purchased the LR Freelander TD4_e after driving a BMW X3.

      I like the Freelander much more and hope that it does well in the Australian car market; I tend to think that the Beemers as good aas they are, are a little over rated and therefore over priced. The X3 can’t do what the Freelander can regarding off road and fuel efficiency. If Land Rover were using the X3 as the bench mark for the Freelander, I think they have surpassed the X3 at least in the short term.

      At this point in time I have nothing to complain about regarding this vehicle and the kids love it as well.

    • http://www.kahndesign.com Mike Brodie

      Good morning to you,

      I was wondering if there would be an opportunity for you to promote my NEW 20” wheel which will be available
      For Freelander2 and Range Rover models in January?

      It might not be the breaking news of the century but for those guys who don’t want oversized wheels they still want something
      With a bit of style!

      Would it be appropriate for me to send you some images?

      Any coverage you could give me for this would be greatly appreciated plus if there is any interest from you on Kahn projects
      At the moment then just let me know.

    • wxthree

      I’m betting that after one or two trips into town, that eco button gets left in the off position.
      Still, can’t complain about an entry level F2 with a manual gearbox that I’m sure some diehards just prefer over auto’s no matter what. All good really.

    • Bill

      I drove a TD4 2.2 (previous model without the off switch) and was very pleasantly surprised at the solidity, classy handling, brilliant ride and of course the very good dirt and off-raod capabilities of this car. Also amazed at how much luggage you could fit into it. The one I drove had the glass roof with perforated screen and which was a nice change from the usual opaque blinds. Will definitely get one when I have readies for it. Have driven a few various makes and this one so far is the most compfortable. And the pricing is really competitive.