Jeep Grand Cherokee passes another rollover test | CarAdvice

Car Advice

Jeep Grand Cherokee passes another rollover test

JEEP GRAND CHEROKEE
By Tim Beissmann
FIND DEALS

The Jeep Grand Cherokee has passed another independent ‘moose test’, dispelling speculation that the big US-built SUV is a rollover safety risk.

Questions of the Grand Cherokee’s safety were sparked earlier this month when Swedish magazine Teknikens Varld (Technology World) almost flipped a Swedish-spec version of the SUV in a lane-change manoeuvre test and consequently called for Jeep to stop selling the vehicle.

Jeep’s parent company Chrysler Group responded to the criticism, claiming that the Grand Cherokee in question was tested in an “overloaded condition”. A subsequent evaluation was conducted by the magazine in the presence of Chrysler Group engineers, and despite testing three vehicles over 11 runs the original two-wheel-lift-off result could not be reproduced.

German publication Auto Motor und Sport has now conducted its own independent moose test, which was performed at a test site sanctioned by the Europe’s largest automobile club, ADAC, with the course dimensions and layout in accordance with those set by the International Standards Organisation.

At the completion of the test, Auto Motor und Sport concluded the Jeep Grand Cherokee remained safely on the road at all times.

“Whether loaded with two people on board or with the maximum permissible total weight, all four wheels maintained contact with the ground to the greatest possible extent,” the magazine reports.

“The tested Jeep did not demonstrate one-sided uplift or, let alone, tipping. This confirms the theory that the Cherokee in Sweden was overloaded.”

In a statement, the Chrysler Group said “the result reaffirms the Grand Cherokee’s place among the safest vehicles on the road today”.

The Grand Cherokee was awarded a Top Safety Pick by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety in the US and was awarded a four-star safety rating by Euro NCAP in November and ANCAP in December.

Meanwhile, the US Government’s National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) is currently investigating the 2012 Jeep Grand Cherokee over a potential defect with the vehicle’s power steering hose that may lead to an engine fire.

The NHTSA’s Office of Defects Investigation has received one complaint of a power steering hose failure as well as two reports from the past month alleging engine compartment fires while driving that led to total vehicle loss.

One of the complaints reported fluid dripping beneath the vehicle during the incident.

No recall has been called at this stage as the NHTSA’s investigation continues.


 

  • GuardFlares

    If you buy this car, I’m assuming you would want more than 2 people onboard.
    The Swedish test was reasonable.
    5 people with luggage, a very likely scenario with this type of car.

    • read the lot

      obviously did not read the full story as it states that whether only two people OR maximum permissable weight, all 4 wheels stayed on the ground, concluding the swedish car was overloaded. The swedish test unreasonable

      • GuardFlares

        Read the article the first time!!
        That statement reads like a cop out to me.
        If a car full of passengers and luggage exceeds the maximum permissible weight that is a failure imo.

        This is not about whether the Swedes can produce a test to make the car fail or Chrysler to produce a test to make it pass.

        Its about a likely scenario that can occur on the road (ie. Car full of passengers and luggage having to do an evasive maneuver to avoid a object). The Grand Cherokee fails in those circumstances.

        more details on the swedish test
        http://www dot teknikensvarld dot se/jeepmoosetest-part4/

    • Smart US

       i bet you driving faster with more audience in your car… isnt it just normal to slow down with 5ppl on board??? not to mention that Swedes just manipulated test to prove they are w@nkers

  • Basil Exposition

    The elk gave the Jeep a tap to stop it falling over.

  • Basil Exposition

    The elk gave the Jeep a tap to stop it falling over.

  • Amlohac

    Wonder how much those guys originally had loaded into their jeep when they nearly rolled it?  Interesting that they haven’t made a statement since as to what exactly they did have in the car in terms or weight.

    • Smart US

       yeah that company is like your best mate – farts in the room and then goes for walk… id sue them if i were Jeep and punish them in Swedish wilderness to drive Saab for rest of their life w no spare parts!!! however Meshuggah rules and all the swedish death metal!!!

    • GuardFlares

       Details of the tests and loads
      http://www dot teknikensvarld dot se/jeepmoosetest-part4/

  • Force-15

    Here’s a thought. Could the Grand Cherokee used in the Swedish moose test have had a suspension fault? Maybe that could explain the near-rollover.

    • Hemi hammered

       The story is of the first test, is that the driver admitted to Chrysler officials that the jeep was deliberately overloaded. I can’t tell you that it is true but that is the word of it.

      • GuardFlares

        Details of the tests and loads
         http://www dot teknikensvarld dot se/jeepmoosetest-part4/

        • Force-15

          Thanks for the link GuardFlares (and for showing me how to post links whilst bypassing moderator approval!). I will admit that the issue of suspension faults in the particular car tested (along the lines of, say, a damaged arm as opposed to geometry errors) was more of a ‘what if’ then a response to what’s been mentioned in related articles so far.

        • zanzi

          how many times are you gonna post that article?

          fact is the swedes were bullsh|tting since all these other tests confirmed it wont roll over

          get over it 

  • pixxxels

    the GC could just drive over the unfortunate animal

  • SSV

    Looking at the picture, that is obviously the 2WD version.

    • tiddy

      No it isnt…the original one was an Overland & there are 4WD only

      • SSV

        Sorry, I was referring to only 2 wheels on the ground.
        Also, should be “they’re” not “there”.

  • Save It For The Track

    Any vehicle packed with passengers and overloaded would be a risk of a rollover if driven by a tool.