Car Advice

2008 Holden Astra TDCi Wagon Review

By Matt Brogan |

2008 Holden Astra TDCi Wagon Review & Road Test

astra_tdci_008.jpg

Astra TDCi Wagon looks great in the drive-way

Model Tested:

  • 2008 Holden AH Astra TDCi Wagon 1.9-litre, turbo diesel, six-speed automatic – $32,490 (RRP)

Options:

  • Metallic Paint $360 (Fitted)

plus.jpg Strong Engine, Elegant Looks, Well Kitted, Great Brakes
minus.jpg Average Transmission, Rear Leg Room, Stereo Controls

CarAdvice Rating: rating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gifrating_half.GIF

- by Matt Brogan

In retaining the Astra wagon, Holden has placed itself in the unique position of being the only car company in the country to offer the body shape on this size of car. Furthermore the added incentive of a frugal diesel under the bonnet should be enough to send most family buyers into a spin.

From the outset Astra looks terrific, it has for some years now, and perhaps that’s part of the problem. For as handsome as it is, we’ve all seen it, and maybe it’s time for a little nip and tuck. Still with 16-inch alloy wheels, front and rear fog lamps, adjustable halogen headlamps, chrome accents and roof rails, as well as that imposing angular front end, Astra is still a great looking car in spite of its age.

astra_tdci_004.jpg

The cabin space too is enjoyable and youthful without being so bold as to date quickly, and for the most part is usable and ergonomic with good all round visibility. Some plastics are a little on the cheap side, namely atop the dashboard, but they don’t detract from the appearance too markedly.

Seating for five is both generous in proportion and rather on the supportive side of comfortable, but around town where Astra spends the majority of its time, this is off little consequence.

astra_tdci_011.jpg

If you have older kids or lanky teenagers, the rear leg room may be a touch on the tight side for longer trips, especially if the front seat passengers are reasonably tall. For a young family with kinder or primary school kids it’s more than ample.

The 454-litre cargo area offers a large usable space and the addition of a retractable cargo blind to keep your belongings safe, or your groceries out of the sun, is a bonus. Better still, the weekend trip to the nursery or hardware store needn’t be a bother with the overall area able to be expanded to 1549 litres using 60:40 split fold rear seats.

astra_tdci_005.jpg

There’s a good list of standard features in here too with cruise control, power windows and mirrors, flip key remote central locking, semi-automatic climate control, single MP3 compatible CD tuner (with auxiliary input and steering wheel controls), adjustable steering column, full function trip computer and finally electronic indicator switches that are this time located on the right-hand side of the steering wheel.

The cloth trim has a pleasant feel to it and is seemingly durable – great for those with kids and dogs – while the leather steering wheel is very nice under hand, especially on long trips when urethane ones seem to give you sweaty palms.

astra_tdci_010.jpg

If I was to fail the Astra’s interior on one thing along it would be the stereo control buttons of the centre fascia. They are far too plentiful, fiddly and distracting, and as the stack is set at 90 degrees to the floor, you do have to pull back in your seat a little to see exactly what you are pressing.

I found it’s best to think of this whole cluster as ‘set and forget’ when you’re on the move and stick to using the steering wheel controls until you have a chance to stop. Get the whole thing as you want it in your garage before setting off, it’s not only safer, but far less frustrating.

astra_tdci_007.jpg

The orange centre screen whilst informative, can be a little hard to read when you’re on the go thanks to its smaller lettering, and is difficult to see in daylight hours, especially if you’re wearing polarised sunglasses.

It does however offer a wide array of information which is beneficial to the driver including audio settings, trip computer stats, fuel usage and ambient temperature, but again, perhaps save reading these until stopped at the lights or the servo.

astra_tdci_006.jpg

Up front the Astra is motivated by a rather antiquated 1.9-litre turbo-diesel featuring a single overhead cam with two valves per cylinder. The engine is turbocharged and uses a common rail injection set up which affords the little oiler 88kW at 3500rpm and a rather strong 280Nm of torque from just 2000rpm.

Noise levels at idle are however rather intrusive but these do calm down once you’re moving. There’s also a substantial amount of turbo lag off the line which buyers more familiar with the instant response of a petrol engine may take some time in getting used to.

astra_tdci_002.jpg

The six-speed automatic too is a little off the mark and can be overly eager to kick down a gear, even under very slight acceleration. It is also reluctant to select sixth gear until well above 90km/h which does little to improve what should be an economic driving experience around town. I find it is best to override the gearbox by using manual mode for this reason and select top gear yourself. For the record our urban average was 8.2 litres per 100km.

Once you’re out of stop-start traffic though, the Astra livens up and becomes a very different car. With long legs and remarkable pull from north of 80km/h, highway cruising is effortless and the engine seems to barely have to work at all, even with four adults on board. Overtaking is brief and rewarding especially when utilising the dash-mounted ‘Sport’ button to further sharpen response.

astra_tdci_003.jpg

Astra uses electro-hydraulic power steering which has a nice enough feel to it under most circumstances, and let’s face it, most buyers won’t exactly be throwing the little wagon around too hard. Should you wish to though, you may find a little inconsistency in the level of feedback offered and a substantial amount of rack chatter through the wheel on mid-corner bumps.

Though the Astra feels a little on the stiffer side, the strut front/torsion beam rear suspension setup remains uniform and very predictable with reassuring levels of settled handling despite the load carried. Coupled to standard ESP and Traction Control you’re left with a car that feels sure footed on the road, and who doesn’t appreciate that?

astra_tdci_001.jpg

Strong brakes and a superb pedal feel seemingly offer shorter stopping distances thanks to Astra’s standard Cornering Brake Contol, Electronic Brake Assist and Brake Force Distribution (all part of the four-wheel disc brake ABS system), features more often seen on more expensive prestige brands.

With dual front and side airbags rounding out the safety list it is easy to see how Astra offers such safe family motoring, even managing a maximum five-star EuroNCAP rating.

astra_tdci_009.jpg

So if you’re after a safe, reliable and torquey little European styled wagon that’s reasonably good on fuel, the Astra may be worth a serious look. It’s a pleasant drive has a solid feel about it and above all else, looks great in the drive way.

CarAdvice Overall Rating: rating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gifrating_half.GIF
How does it Drive: rating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gifrating_half.GIF
How does it Look: rating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gif
How does it Go: rating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gif

Specifications:

  • Engine: 1910cc OHC four-cylinder (8-valve)
  • Power: 88kW @ 3500rpm
  • Torque: 280Nm @ 2000rpm
  • Induction: Common Rail & Turbo
  • Transmission: Six-speed Automatic
  • Driven Wheels: Front
  • Brakes: Disc with ABS, CBC, EBA & EBD
  • Top Speed: 194km/h
  • 0-100km/h: 9.8 seconds
  • 0-400m: Not Tested
  • CO2 Output: 192g/km
  • Fuel Consumption: 7.1 litres/100km
  • Fuel Tank Capacity: 52 litres
  • Fuel Type: Diesel
  • EuroNCAP Rating: Five Star
  • Safety: Front & Side Airbags, ESP & TCS
  • Spare Wheel: Full Size Steel
  • Tow Capacity: 1250kg (Braked)
  • Turning Circle: 10.85 metres
  • Warranty: 3 year/100,000km
  • Weight: 1350kg (Tare)
  • Wheels: 16 x 6.5-inch Alloy

Road Test the Rivals:

  • Astra TDCi Wagon currently has no direct competitors.

 
  • Motorhead

    Not a bad little car apart from being scary slow (as is the petrol version) & dull looks but it handles well & brakes are great if a touch grabby. Agree with the buttons but found it not just the stereo but the whole lot is a bit of an ergonomic nightmare, it’s as if they threw all of the buttons at the dash & decided that would do. It will be interesting to see how the i30 wagon compares as I think it will be better in the areas the Astra is poor but will probably miss where the Astra excels ie handling & brakes.

  • alphabeta777

    I like the car, but I don’t like its price. I think it’s too expensive for what it is?

  • Davo

    Peugeot 308 Touring Wagon might be an alternative.

  • Tom

    I really like Astra’s, particularly the turbo variants, but i can never get over how horrible that interior looks.

  • Frosty

    Any faults will be rectified in the all new model due in the next couple of years (I have actually heard next year) May not see full compliment of models initially but as with this current model we will see a gradual introduction of all models. In the meantime we will see if the improvements ie. dash area, sluginess come through for us. I have no doubt the expected improvements will make it the class leader. With the all new Viva replacement due soon also I can see other manufacturers being envious of Holdens small car range.

  • Myke

    I know $32,490 maybe a lot to pay, but considering the Astra in built in Europe, it most likely undercuts most (if not all) of its Europe rivals by thousand of dollars.

  • Wheelnut

    I’d opt for either the Peugeot or the Mondeo wagon as they are better looking more powerful engines better features

  • Sam

    Hmmm seems like an ok car but for 32k? Id rather a Suzuki Vitara or something a bit more versatile for that money. In fact there is probably a whole raft of soft/off roaders that would get my money before a low slung FWD wagon

  • Reckless1

    “Road Test the Rivals:

    Astra TDCi Wagon currently has no direct competitors. ”

    Skoda.

  • http://www.littlepixiegifts.com.au Gift-Ed

    It’s been a very good small car for a long time now, but it is getting overdue for an update now IMO.

  • Matt

    Reckless1 –

    The Skoda (by which I assume you are referring to the Octavia) is considerably bigger, as too is the Mondeo wagon. Octavia is Mazda6, Accord, Mondeo size.

    The Astra would be closer in match to Corolla, Focus, Mazda3, Lancer, etc… all of which do not offer a diesel variant wagon.

    As noted, the only real competitor to this segment will be the Hyundai i30 CW (Cross Wagon) when it is released here soon.

    Matt.

  • http://deleted Alex

    Im gonna have to pick this up again I’m afraid. The Octavia IS in competition with the Astra, Focus, 208, Golf, Leon, Corolla, Megane etc. so actually, Reckless1 is right. The Mondeo, 6, Accord, Passat, Laguna, Vectra etc. are all in competition with the Skoda Superb which I don’t believe Australia has yet. The reason why the Octavia hatch is bigger than the Golf, Corolla, Focus etc. is because in Europe at least, Skoda is meant to equal value for money, more for you’re money and good quality and there fore, is bigger than usual. To sum up, the Astra is in competition with the Octavia and The Octavia is not in competition with the Mondeo.

  • Dlr1

    The 308 Touring is the most obvious competitor for the Astra wagon. Yes the 2.0HDi Auto id three and a half thousand more, but its also fresh to the market, and possibly better value.

  • timmy201

    how about the captiva manual diesel?
    2wd one is only $33,990 for a much bigger car…

  • http://www.caradvice.com.au Matt

    Alex, Reckless1 etc. Might I suggest you check the VFACTS website. Cheers.

  • Genie

    My work got a few of these recently as company cars and so I drove one the other day. Overall its not a bad car, quite practical but the thing that freaked me out was the total disconnect between the steering and the front wheels, it honestly felt like they weren’t connected. Just couldn’t get used to it. And I could never work out that the sport button did, other than make the steering feel slightly worse, might as well labelled it the hyperspace button, would be just as truthful.

    Maybe the work Astra wagons have broken steering, as you didn’t seem to have an issue with it.

  • Staggers

    besides being almost two classes bigger (in terms of size), the mondeo wagon isnt on sale in Oz yet so its not really an option. the Astra wagon is offered as an alternative to soft roaders, for people who dont want a soft roader. so most are missing the point of the Astra wagon, maybe thats why its not a big seller and the only other small wagon in the segment is the 308.

  • http://deleted Alex

    Matt, may I suggest that you tell me what the Skoda Superbs for if not a competitior for the Mondeo, 6, Passat, Laguna, Vectra, Avensis…

  • O

    Because the superb is massive,much bigger than a passat with huge amounts of rear legroom we are talking caprice amounts back there.

  • http://www.caradvice.com.au Matt

    Alex I am not going to argue with you. You obviously think you’re right and I can’t better that. In Australia, as per VFACTS accreditation, the Astra and Octavia DO NOT compete on the same level. You’re most welcome to investigate this for yourself. I will not enter in to any further debate.

  • http://caradvice.com.au OSU811

    why no 6 speed manual version with the more powerful, twin cam diesel engine?? Now that would be a nice wagon with a decent set of 17 or 18 inch wheels would look good too..

  • http://faster DanMan

    ‘Holden has placed itself in the unique position of being the only car company in the country to offer the body shape on this size of car.’

    Gee wonder why that is…? Really most hatchbacks from ANY japanese manafacurer blow this thing away on looks and practicality. And those torque and power stats may have been good in 2002 but it’s 2008. Should be at least 110kw and 350 nm @ 2000rpm.

    Is this thing from GM, Opel or Holden?…. just saying..

  • http://www.remotestaff.com.au Johnny Coates

    I believe the Astra is made for small families. Its typical design is for long -drive-sight-seeing travels. But obviously it could get destroyed easily on off-road.lol

  • Reckless1

    I don’t really care that VFACTS considers the Skoda and Astra are not competitors.

    When I want a FWD auto diesel wagon, and I am happy to pay $32490 for the Astra, I am without doubt going to compare it directly to the Skoda Ambiente 1.9TDI with DSG for $1800 more.

    When I drive both and discover that one is roomier, drives better, looks like a 2008 car not a 2002 car, has better safety, I’m taking no notice of VFACTS.

  • http://Proton LH

    Car Advice should do a survey to decide what is the most boring/dullest/uninspiring car currently on the market. I have a feeling this would be in with a shot at that title.

  • ScottyB

    Matt, I don’t understand you opening line?
    Stating that the Astra diesel does not have competitors? You guys even wrote stuff about the 308 wagon “The 308 Touring is available with a range of two petrol and two diesel engines”
    I’m pretty sure 308 Touring is a competitor, check specs and price.

  • Wheelnut

    Danman – sometimes its not such a bad idea for a car company to offer a \”niche\” vehicle such as this.

    Because there are a few people out there who are looking for a wagon yet don’t want to go for a full-size wagon such as the Holden Commodore Sportwagon. [another example of being the only one in its class and just like the Astra wagon quite popular]

    People know how reliable the Opel built Astra is and can therefore be relatively confident that a Astra wagon would be just as good.

    Whilst your comment about wagons from the Japanese manufacturers blowing the Astra way in terms of looks practicality power handling and features etc may be true..
    I believe the Peugeot 207/307 Touring beats the Japanese [particularly in relation to fuel efficiency as they offer a diesel option]as the Avensis is essentially an over-blown Corolla and the Mazda6 looks wrong

  • Fenno

    havent we seen this article already?

  • Wheelnut

    Quote [LH]: Car Advice should do a survey to decide what is the most boring/dullest/uninspiring car currently on the market. I have a feeling this would be in with a shot at that title.

    Aahh I think you’ll find at the end of the survey there will probably be a number of Toyota’s in front of the Astra including: Prius.. Yaris YR Hatchback.. Yaris YRS Hatchback.. Yaris YRX Hatchback.. Yaris “Rush” Hatchback.. Yaris YR-S Sedan.. Yaris YR-X Sedan.. Corolla Ascent Hatchback.. Corolla Ascent Sedan.. Corolla Conquest Hatchback.. Corolla Conquest Sedan.. Corolla Levin Hatchback.. Corolla Ultima Sedan.. Avensis.. Camry Altise.. Camry Ateva.. Camry Sportivo.. Tarago.. Aurion AT-X.. Aurion Sportivo SX-6.. Aurion Touring.. Aurion Prodigy..as well as both the TRD and Hilux Range

  • http://Proton LH

    Wheelnut, I doubt they would bother to hold such a survey, and you’ve just demonstrated exactly why. It comes down to personal opinion – one mans trash is another mans treasure. I actually don’t mind the look of the current Corolla, it’s a massive improvement on the past few models. But I understand that others may hate it.

    I was just saying that I find this Astra extraordinarily dull, as are a lot of other cars on the market. I am craving for a car that ticks all of the boxes in terms of design, style, interior quality, creature comforts and does it all for under $50K. In my honest opinion the only one in my mind that comes close is the Mazda 6 Luxury Sports, and even that isn’t perfect (needs more power, terrible looking rear spoiler). I mean, how hard can it be to produce an awesome looking, well performing car?

  • Wheelnut

    Too true LH; surveys are based purely on personal opinion.
    which is why I and a number of others on this site don’t really take any notice of the results.
    Because it depends on when where and how the survey is conducted; how the questions are worded; how the questions and the answers are interpreted etc..

    Besides most surveys are manipulated or adjusted inorder to achieve a pre-determined outcome due toi the fact that theyre usually done on behalf of someone with a vested interest.

    However; having said that.. a survey that is conducted by either a car magazine or an automotive website such as this would have a lot more “credibility” than one held on the street.

    I mean the majority of participants to the “Car Advice” survey are likely to be real car enthusiasts and know considerably more about cars – makes models engines specifications/features performance price etc than Mr Joe Average just walking out of the local supermarket.

  • JEYKL & HYDE

    danman,buy the astra MANUAL diesel hatch-110kw,320nm.it will blow the doors off your “rolla”hatch.interior is a bit boring…like any toyota.panel strengh and fit and finish rival any euro(opel made).

  • http://faster DanMan

    OH i’m sorry i thought we talking about the wagon… OK
    yes that engine is good, I always drive in a 750 rpm powerband.. mmmm smell the lag.

    Sorry i dont drive a Corolla hatch, Tens of thousands of Aussie’s who bought them this year do, but.

    Oh look i give up, going to dynamite some fish in a barrel for a real challenge..

    23% market share? Must be very boring cars indeed.

  • JEYKL & HYDE

    danman,or you could try selling some more echo’s at 18.5k “plus”(now there’s a challenge).”boring” has resale,doesn’t it

  • http://skyline The Salesman

    Oh my god, another Toyota bash, most here can not see past a Holden badge.
    Well done Holden you took a five year old car (plus) and wacked on old oil burner in it. Now who is going to finance one for your customers? I hope they are cashed up.
    Have you called Esanda yet?

  • JEYKL & HYDE

    giday mr salesman,

    the ah model started in 06.if you can’t see too well mate,put your binoculars on,and point in the general direction of europe(there quite a few over there…understatement!!!)

    i think your a bit shortsighted to think all gm,nissan,toyota,whatever, dealers are all under the same finance company.interesting that g.e. money ain’t doing car finance anymore(karma’s got em)

  • http://faster DanMan

    Yes Karma, payback for all the Nuclear weapons the parent company made in the sixties.. (GE that is)

    No Toyota use Toyota Financial Services.. Their own Bank even. Those Japanese with their total control… will they ever learn?

  • http://faster DanMan

    Echo Finished in 05/06. Oh you were being asinine.. I’ll wait while you look up what means..

    Actually 15-16k will get into one.. Not you of course per say, but heaps of happy first new car buyers…

    High risk buyer= low risk cars…? Oh sorry boring in your words..

  • http://skyline The Salesman

    How’s it going Mr.JEYKL & HYDE,
    Oh i see now, or should i say AH i see now, get it? AH like the model. So they revised the grill/headlights and taillights, anything else?.
    Not all that inspiring.
    Allot of dealers are with GE and GMAC, unless they can convince another financier to pick up the floor plan (not easy when cars are not being sold), and they have the revenue to pay it out, well, time to close the doors.
    Thank god we are with Esanda.

  • JEYKL & HYDE

    sorry mr salesman,

    it was 05.and it was a WHOLE new model(no more sedan).good car but.your right about scary times with finance companys,one dealership (3rd generation)just bit the dust vic way…however it won’t just a holden,and it wont just be the car game…

  • Tony M

    Try the volvo v50 for competition. Admitedly more expense but much better wagon.

  • http://faster DanMan

    GM dealers in the states get paid a bonus if they DONT Finance with GMAC, get this, FROM GMAC!
    Never heard of anything like that, ever.

    Strange days indeed..

  • http://skyline The Salesman

    JEYKL & HYDE,
    How long ago was 2005?. Let’s see, 05, 06, 07, 08. That’s 1,2,3,4. I guessed it was five years old, pretty close.
    Anyway there are not many wagons around now due to a huge lack of interest so it will be interesting if Holden can flog a dead horse and get it to run again. On the plus side i just spoke to a fresh import from the UK who is retiring on the coast and he tells me nearly 80% of the cars abroad are now diesel, will Australians follow this same trend?

  • Phillip

    I drove an Astra a couple of years ago and hated every moment of it for one simple reason; the electronic indicators. Why on earth Opel decided to not let the stalk stay in place when the indicator is activated is anyones guess, but I found it to be stupid and dangerous, as it’s necessary to look at the instrument panel to check to see if the indicator is on or off. A piece of terrible design!

  • Cupid Stunt aka No Name

    Tony M – Try the Focus estate if you can and save yourself thousands in buying the same car in different clothes.
    Yeh the Astras a good motor. That Donk aint too bad least you geta decent 6 speed auto, but stick with the manual and go for the 110Kw engine and you’ll have a car that does 0-60 in nines and gets 5.’s per litre. Everyones a winner in a diesel.

  • Cupid Stunt aka No Name

    What you will see in the next astra is a similar looking car with the Insignia look dash, better build quality and far more dynamic to drive. Fuzzy images have already been leaked by Vauxhall in the UK.

  • Eddy The Expert

    A bit of a Dyslexic moment from Car Advice Its the Astra CDTi, not the TDCi as you have posted.

    Anyway I enjoyed your article.

    Oh and if you couldn’t read the screen u can reverse the colours so the background is black with orange writing. Much much easier to read.

  • http://www.freemycloud.com.au Free My Cloud

    I just love how spacious the compartment is for a little car and 7.1 litres/100km DIESEL is not bad. I’m still not buying. XD