BMW X5 Review | CarAdvice

Car Advice

BMW X5 Review

BMW X5

Pros: Great to drive with best-in-class steering; much-needed improvement in value; standard reverse-view camera; spacious and practical cabin; optional third row

Cons: Relatively high entry cost; little innovation in seating/cargo arrangement; ride comfort suffers with bigger wheels; all-new model expected in 2013

By Jez Spinks |
FIND DEALS

Price: $81,070 to $93,170

Our Rating:  

The BMW X5 is a seemingly unstoppable force in luxury-SUV sales.

More than 1.1 million have been sold since the German car maker’s first ‘soft-roader’ went on sale in 1999, and its movement out of showrooms in Australia reflects its global popularity.

It’s currently still the best-selling luxury SUV locally, and the BMW X5 still out-sells its smaller and more affordable siblings – the BMW X3 and BMW X1.

A third-generation BMW X5 is due in 2013, however, and the current model (released in 2006 but updated in 2010) faces a major new threat from the brand-spanking-new Mercedes-Benz ML that launched in April.

And the German brand from Stuttgart has continued an aggressive pricing strategy for its models that has placed pressure on its compatriot brand from Munich.

With the Mercedes-Benz ML starting at $81,400 – a whopping $10,700 less than an entry-level X5 – BMW Australia has been forced to respond.

That counter-attack comes in the form of an Innovations Package that was previously a $9000 option – and worth $16,000, according to BMW – but is now standard.

It’s more of an Aladdin’s crevice than cave in terms of treasures, but most of the eight extra features for the BMW X5 xDrive30d we tested are highly desirable.

There’s a tailgate that opens and closes at the touch of a button, a head-up display that projects a digital speedo onto the windscreen, full (rather than partial) electric driver’s seat adjustment, satellite navigation and reverse-view camera with ‘Top View’, which provides a handy birds-eye surround view of the vehicle.

Other additions include bi-xenon headlights, anti-dazzle side mirrors and high-beam assist.

Driveaway pricing still breaks the $100,000 barrier, though, and it’s disappointing buyers still have to pay another $2000 for metallic paint.

Notable standard features for the base BMW X5 – the biggest seller in the range –  include dual-zone automatic climate control, rain-sensing wipers, multi-function steering wheel, leather seats, electrically adjustable and heated side mirrors, cruise control with braking function, parking guidance, 18-inch alloy wheels, Bluetooth connectivity, 6.5-inch colour information display, dual front airbags, side and head airbags up front and head airbags for the rear seats.

Vehicle stability control is joined by hill descent control and traction control among other electronic safety features.

The BMW X5 30d engine bay is filled with a 3.0-litre six-cylinder that offers maximum power of 180kW at 4000rpm and peak torque of 540Nm between 1750 and 3000rpm.

An eight-speed automatic gearbox provides plenty of ratios for ensuring the diesel stays in its operational sweet spot.

Those shifts are both quick and smooth, complementing an engine that is responsive from down low and with a sufficiently broad spread of power.

While Germans might prefer the noticeably quicker BMW X5 40d for their speed-unlimited autobahns, the 30d’s performance will be ample for most Australians.

A BMW-quoted 7.6 seconds for the 0-100km/h sprint is none-too-shabby for a vehicle that weighs 2075kg.

It feels unusual nowadays, though, to jump into a high-end German car that doesn’t feature engine stop-start technology.

In terms of official combined fuel consumption, however, the BMW X5 30d is only a fraction behind the comparable (new) Mercedes-Benz ML350 CDI – 7.4L/100km v 7.3L/100km – and ahead of the Audi Q7 3.0TDI’s 7.8/100km.

Lexus doesn’t offer a diesel version of its RX SUV, but it’s hybrid RX450h model sets the efficiency benchmark in the segment with 6.3L/100km.

High-riding SUVs that can be described as great to drive are in an elite group, but the BMW X5 remains a major member.

The steering weighting is perfectly judged and linear from lock to lock, and turning the wheel in corners is a rewarding experience for the driver as the X5 impresses with its poise.

The grip of the standard 18-inch tyres do have earlier limits than bigger tyres, though they also provide a quieter, more comfortable ride.

A slightly longer seat cushion and some extra bolstering wouldn’t go amiss up front, though otherwise the X5 offers comfortable pews.

Rear-seat passengers will have few complaints, too. Whether you’re looking for room for knees, heads or feet, space is generous. The floor is also virtually flat and there’s decent width to the cabin, so it is feasible to fit three adults up back, even if they’ll be rubbing shoulders.

Central vents ensure a decent amount of air is pumped to the rear, and deep door pockets and seatback map pockets provide storage options.

Drop the rear seats – manually alas as no electric release levers – and the 620-litre boot space expands into a 1750-litre overall capacity, and the floor isn’t as flat as it could be. The rear seats don’t slide fore/aft, either, so owners can choose whether they want more boot space or more legroom.

Thanks to that aforementioned equipment upgrade, the tailgate of the BMW X5 30d now opens and closes automatically at the press of a button (either on the dash, key fob or tailgate itself). It was a $1300 option previously.

It’s also split into two sections, with the bottom half presenting a pseudo bench/table a la Range Rover.

The boot is wide and deep even when the rear seats are in use, and there are cargo rails with tie-downs, elastic straps either side for holding items, a 12V socket, and there’s a cargo blind to keep boot contents secretive.

The boot floor lifts up hydraulically to reveal a temporary size spare wheel and an extra plastic built-in tub that would be handy for storing wet items.

Alternatively, buyers can opt for third-row seating that lifts out of the boot floor – giving the BMW X5 a passenger-capacity advantage over the rival Mercedes-Benz ML and Lexus RX.

Storage isn’t a BMW forte though there are no issues in the X5. There’s a good-sized, split-lid console bin, a deep glovebox (also accessed by a split opening), large door bins, and double cupholders.

And although the current BMW X5 is in the twilight of its current lifecycle, the interior overall has aged well in terms of materials quality and presentation thanks to the 2010 update. It’s certainly looking fresher than the rival Audi Q7 that is also due for replacement in the not-too-distant future, though Audi remains the king of cabins among the German luxury-brand triumvirate.

The BMW X5 remains a large luxury SUV to strongly consider, though the Mercedes-Benz ML has also never been a tougher adversary in terms of pricing, performance and the way it drives as it is with the latest generation. And if you’re more serious about off-roading, a Land Rover Discovery 4 is a better option.

Click to read a review of the BMW X5 40d.

Click to read a review of the BMW X5 M.


 

Owner reviews of the BMW X5 Add a New Review

  • MisterZed

    Never understood X5s popularity in Australia.  It’s not that big of a seller in the USA, which is surprising considering it’s made there.

    • FanBoi

      Every car review on this site gets 4 stars! What The F?????

      //

  • Guest1

    No thanks…..

  • Tyy

    Boring car for people who worship badge..

    Lexus RX also sets power bench mark.,

    • Phil

      You’ve got it the wrong way around.

      The BMW X5 M has 408KW of power and runs to 100kmh in 4.7 secs.

      The Toyota Klugar in a suit running on premium fuel puts out 204KW in the RX350 and runs to 100kmh in 8.0 secs.
      Lexus doesn’t provide a true power figure for the RX450 Hybrid however the petrol engine in it only produces 183KW and runs to 0-100kmh in 7.9 secs which is slower than the bottom of the range diesel X5.

  • Roundedbrick

    Get the Disco 4. More versatile and cheaper…..

    ….queue historic tails of LR unreliability. Seriously it is the better buy.

    • sam123

       I think I agree with you.  For the money, a Disco 3 would be the go.  PLus its a prper 4×4, take it anywhere.  They are so nice these days, like a pseudo RangeRover.

  • http://twitter.com/mapguy83 Nicholas Flett

    So it’s okay against it’s German rivals. What about versus the Volvo or top grade of the middle-class SUVs? Is it really $30k better built than a Territory Titanium or just has more gadgets to go wrong? Servicing intervals, costs, insurance comparison?

    • sam123

       I think you will find, most people wont cross shop a Ford with a BMW on most occasions.  Your question that goes to the 30k price gap is a subjective one.  Some people will tell you the BMW steers and handles much better, which it probably does,  and to them that might be worth the premium, but to you perhaps, not so much.  So it comes down to where you see value.  Others will tell you that after 5 years of ownership, the ford and the BMW might have cost you the same amount due to depreciation disparity.   It comes down to where YOU see value in a motor car and what you put emphasis on as being important, such as those you mentioned.  I would reiterate though, that the most expensive part of owning a new vehicle is almost always depreciation.  The longer you hang onto and look after a car, the better value it becomes, IMHO.

      • Smart US

         most ppl simply dont want to been seen with poor aussie boyfriend

  • Phil

    So the good points include “spacious and practical cabin” and “optional third row”, yet a bad point is “little innovation in cargo/seating arrangment”.
    So the cabin is spacious and practical but at the same time, lacks innovation in terms of it’s spaciousness and practicality?

    Very confusing as per usual with CA reviews.

  • Daniel

    I think it’s a good car. It certainly handles well for it’s size and I think it’s only just starting to look dated. And if you compare it to a 5 Series Touring, it’s actually really good value too (even though I would rather have the Touring). The thing is that, if you want a car like this, even the new ML doesn’t handle as well as the X5 (going on everything I’ve read) and the Porsche Cayenne is great, but expensive with the most expensive options on the market. I would take a Sport or a Discovery 4, though. 

  • BeemerLover

    The interior on all X series is el cheapo and the X5 wallows like a 2 ton SUV.  The X5 ride is about the same as a Ford Territory and the total costs of ownership per km will give you nightmares. In terms of fuel the wife gets 6 down to 5 km/litre in inner city driving from the the diesel. That is up near the 20 litres per 100km. The X5 fuel use is very similar to my 500 kg lighter 7 series V8 around town. 

    On the freeway though the X5 can use as little 6.5 litres per 100 km compared to the V8 about 8.5 l/100km. The cost to service them at the BMW dealer is up to $200 per hour. The parts are cheap in Europe but we are being overcharged, by as much as a factor of 3.  Before you buy any new BMW take a heart pill then ask the price of a new engine or a gearbox. Never buy any German car without a buyers contract with agreed replacement costs at European prices plus freight for all components for a minimum 10 years of ownership. Make sure the contract includes providing an loan car of equivalent value while the car is being repaired. No buyers contract no sale. Always buy your diesel from the one supplier and keep the receipts. Crook diesel can cause expensive repairs that are not covered by warranty.

  • BeemerLover

    The interior on all X series is el cheapo and the X5 wallows like a 2 ton SUV.  The X5 ride is about the same as a Ford Territory and the total costs of ownership per km will give you nightmares. In terms of fuel the wife gets 6 down to 5 km/litre in inner city driving from the the diesel. That is up near the 20 litres per 100km. The X5 fuel use is very similar to my 500 kg lighter 7 series V8 around town. 

    On the freeway though the X5 can use as little 6.5 litres per 100 km compared to the V8 about 8.5 l/100km. The cost to service them at the BMW dealer is up to $200 per hour. The parts are cheap in Europe but we are being overcharged, by as much as a factor of 3.  Before you buy any new BMW take a heart pill then ask the price of a new engine or a gearbox. Never buy any German car without a buyers contract with agreed replacement costs at European prices plus freight for all components for a minimum 10 years of ownership. Make sure the contract includes providing an loan car of equivalent value while the car is being repaired. No buyers contract no sale. Always buy your diesel from the one supplier and keep the receipts. Crook diesel can cause expensive repairs that are not covered by warranty.

  • BeemerLover

    The interior on all X series is el cheapo and the X5 wallows like a 2 ton SUV.  The X5 ride is about the same as a Ford Territory and the total costs of ownership per km will give you nightmares. In terms of fuel the wife gets 6 down to 5 km/litre in inner city driving from the the diesel. That is up near the 20 litres per 100km. The X5 fuel use is very similar to my 500 kg lighter 7 series V8 around town. 

    On the freeway though the X5 can use as little 6.5 litres per 100 km compared to the V8 about 8.5 l/100km. The cost to service them at the BMW dealer is up to $200 per hour. The parts are cheap in Europe but we are being overcharged, by as much as a factor of 3.  Before you buy any new BMW take a heart pill then ask the price of a new engine or a gearbox. Never buy any German car without a buyers contract with agreed replacement costs at European prices plus freight for all components for a minimum 10 years of ownership. Make sure the contract includes providing an loan car of equivalent value while the car is being repaired. No buyers contract no sale. Always buy your diesel from the one supplier and keep the receipts. Crook diesel can cause expensive repairs that are not covered by warranty.

    • Smart US

       great input… it must be coming from experience… again great comment

    • SM

      I’ve been in quite a few X5′s from a quite basic 3.0d all the way to a 2011 X5M and I must say that “wallows” is certainly not a word that I would use for any of them when it comes to handling.

      If your wife is only getting 5-6km/litre in a diesel then there is either a hole in your fuel tank or some one comes along at night and siphens the fuel because even the 5M was getting better than that. I agree that servicing can be expensive but what’s cheap these days, a 2008 Kluger that I used to own was costing me on average $700-$800 a year for servicing once the capped service expired and most of the time that was just for fluids.

    • Legnab

      YEP you keep driving your bucket of bolts ford terrican , hows your front end .

      • Don Quay

        Oh dear, I think you must mean “Yes, you keep driving your bucket of bolts Ford Terrican. How’s your front end?” 
        Actually, I believe the Terracan was a Hyundai, not a Ford. You obviously are confused with the the names Territory and Terracan.

        Please, there is no need to thank me for helping you, I am happy to assist someone obviously in such need.

    • Sydlocal

      All fair comments BeemerLover. However you forgot to mention that although a single service is not cheap, you don’t have to service them as often as many other cars, which claws back some of the difference in servicing costs. In fact, over 3 years/60,000km when serviced by the book, a BMW X5 is cheaper to service than a Hyundai Santa Fe. As you said though, some parts costs (not all, BMW engine coolant for example is WAY cheaper than what Holden charge for a Commodore) when outside the warranty period can give you a heart attack!
      Also, either your wife must be one hell of a lead foot, rests her other foot on the brake pedal or spends A LOT of time idling without moving because there would be no other way to get fuel economy that bad in the diesel without there being an engine problem. As a general rule, the difference between city and country cycle of a diesel is closer than a petrol due to the way power/torque is delivered lower down and not having to rev it as much etc. Unless of course anytime you applied the accelerator (from the lights etc) it was flat to the floor, or the driver is one of those annoying people who can’t hold a constant throttle setting and are constantly on and off the throttle, even when trying to keep a steady speed! That kills fuel economy big time. 
      To make that comparison with your V8 7 series a more reliable, how does the fuel economy your wife gets driving it in the same conditions vary to yours? I know for a fact that with our car and the same driving/traffic conditions (4cyl medium sized car), I get around 2L/100km better economy around town than my wife does. I also know that in the same car (VS Commodore) my sister goes through 5-6L/100km more fuel than my brother in law driving around Melbourne. Yes, she is a lead foot! A lot of it has to do with driving style and adjusting your driving style is one of the easiest and most dramatic methods you can use to improve fuel economy, or increase it!!!

      • Guest12

        Fair comments?
        The fuel consumption figures he gave are pure bulls**t.

    • F1

      Yeah BMW’s fuel consumption figures are too optimistic..

    • Ramcfadden

      You are wrong the x5 does not use anywhere near 20 liters per 100kms worst is about 9 in heavy city driving

    • Claude_defraud

      So why do you call yourself BeemerLover?

  • nugsdad

    Just took the 20″ wheels off mine it rode like a billy cart with them – back to stock 19′s seems much better.

  • nugsdad

    Just took the 20″ wheels off mine it rode like a billy cart with them – back to stock 19′s seems much better.

  • nugsdad

    Just took the 20″ wheels off mine it rode like a billy cart with them – back to stock 19′s seems much better.

  • Kyri

    X5′s certainly don’t wallow but they are still too expensive even with the extra “value”. You could get one fully loaded for $60K in the states. Stop start is a waste of an invention but I am sure it will be there in the future (for sometyhing to turn off). Car is very roomy and comfortable and I like the firm ride – wouldn’t have it any other way. Anyone running 20″ Dunlop Sport Max should change to Bridgestones – significantly better. Fuel economy on my 30D is equivalent to 2.5L petrol 3 series (same journey, same driver). Has aged externaly versus the Q7 but the Q7′s marine proportions don’t do much for driving. Interior is high quality but could do with some added touches. Thankfully new ML’s Ssanyong styling wont pose too much of a threat. Have driven BM’s continuosly for 6 years now and not one fault to report of. Makes trips to dealerships boring. Only gripe is rip off price. Only buyers strike can rectify. Look at price battle on 3 series.

  • Gwwe

    Sorry but shouldn’t diesels need no more then 2 gears??

    Since they produce all their power within a very limited range 1000-3000rpm ..why would you need 8 gears??

    Just for bragging rights?

    • Bones

      Have you ever heard of fuel economy ?  Duh !!!

    • Sydlocal

      Huh? That doesn’t make ANY sense at all Gwwe. In reality the opposite is actually true.
      Having such a narrow torque band is the reason WHY you have so many gears. Just think about it, why do so many trucks have over 10 gears with their even narrower torque range?(hint, it is not for bragging rights) Going by your logic those trucks should only have one gear. We all know that would never work… Those multiple gears allow you to keep the engine within that narrow torque/power range more often hence improving performance over a greater speed range. If you only had 2 gears then there would only be 2 very narrow speed bands that are wide apart where the engine is giving it’s best performance, with 8 speeds there are 8 speed bands much closer together meaning the performance is more accessible more of the time. 

      Now if it was one of these new generation turbo petrol engines that have their maximum torque from around 1800rpm all the way to 4500/5000rpm then you would have a more than valid point and one that I would have wholeheartedly agreed with you.

  • D987

    BMW is really going to struggle selling these against the new ML. BMW should have slashed the price rather than specing it up as a lot people won’t be able to afford the extra dollars for the X5.

    • Cherylrozen

      Can anyone please guess what the household income of the average BMW X5 driver is.
      My income is $330,000.00 per annum and I cannot afford one.

      • Claude_defraud

        You need to learn how to budget.

  • Don Quay

    So, it seems that you can have an X5 with 5 seats and a temporary spare or a seven seater and no spare tyre. If BMW are so clever, then why can’t they make a car with 7 seats and a full size spare like Ford and Land Rover do with the Territory or Disco? I hate temporary spares, they might be OK in Germany, but not in this country.