Nissan LEAF to lead the charge with noisemaker tech in Australia; Toyota says no for now | CarAdvice

Car Advice

Nissan LEAF to lead the charge with noisemaker tech in Australia; Toyota says no for now

By Tim Beissmann |
FIND DEALS

Toyota has released a video detailing its latest Vehicle Proximity Notification System (VPNS) – a system designed to improve the safety of pedestrians and other road users around near-silent hybrid and electric vehicles by emitting audible warnings – but don’t expect our Prius to get the technology any time soon.

VPNS broadcasts a range of low- and high-pitched noises when travelling below 15mph (24km/h). The pitch of the tone increases and decreases depending on the vehicle’s speed (a function called ‘pitch-shifting’).

Toyota engineers in the US say the system will improve road safety for cyclists, or pedestrians who may be distracted by mobile phones, and insists it will be especially important to the independence of blind pedestrians who rely on audible warnings from vehicles.

Toyota describes the sound as “automotive in nature, but still futuristic to match the advanced powertrain of our hybrid vehicle”, and says it has been developed to remain effective around other ambient noises and parked cars.

Although no one has established specific guidelines for manufacturers, the US and Japanese governments and the European Commission are all working on a set of standards for minimum noise levels for hybrids, EVs and other near-silent vehicles.

Like the rest of the world, there is no minimum noise standard for vehicles in Australia, and as a result, Toyota Australia’s Mike Breen said there were no plans to introduce the technology to Prius vehicles imported to Australia.

“There is no current plan as, importantly, there are no Australian regulations developed to which we can build it,” Mr Breen said.

Despite its near-silent low-speed operating mode, Mr Breen said concerns over pedestrian safety “isn’t an issue for our current Prius”. Toyota will expand its hybrid offering in the first half of next year with the launch of the ‘Prius family‘, including the Prius c, Prius facelift, and Prius MPV.

Nissan Australia plans to take a different approach with its LEAF EV, however, with the local brand requesting of head office in Japan that the innovative Approaching Vehicle Sound for Pedestrians (AVSP) system is fitted as standard to our cars.

If approved, the Nissan LEAF would become the first mass-produced vehicle sold in Australia to incorporate noisemaker technology when it arrives in April 2012.

Nissan Australia’s Jeff Fisher said it would not be confirmed until closer to the end of the year, but said he expected every Nissan LEAF in Australia to come with AVSP as standard.

Like Toyota’s VPNS, Nissan’s audio alert system emits high- and low-frequency tones at speeds from 0-30km/h, and switches back on once the vehicle’s speed drops below 25km/h. It also beeps when reversing, similar to a commercial vehicle.

AVSP can be switched off, but automatically defaults back to ‘on’ each time the car is turned on.

Do you think noisemaker technology is an important feature for all hybrid, electric and near-silent vehicles? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below.


 

  • Mr Gaspo

    Yes, noise making technology is a must for pedestrian and cyclist safety with EVs and Hybrids. I can also see potential for hacking so instead of beeps a bloke mode could be enabled that emits loud fart and burp noises.., whereas those into meditation could have the sound of crashing waves… The possibilities are endless.

  • R32 Boy

    When are we getting LEAF here?

    • Phil

      Article says April next year…

      Doesn’t mean you actually be able to buy it though – the classic EV method of either “no supply”, “lease only”, “trial only” etc might ensue. Or it might be prohibitively expensive.

      • Alexander

        It’s here on trial currently, with public sales availability Q2 next year & according to Nissan OZ it will be priced thesame as a top spec Lexus CT200h (50k).

        • Phil

          Whats the point of trialing them here after it’s already been done for years in other countrys?
          Plus overseas, they’ve been on sale for almost a year now with about 15,000 delivered.

          Still $50K not too bad a price, much better value than Mitsubishi Imiev.

  • Image

    I vote Green sleeves to be played constantly!

  • Boyracer

    Awww.. The total silence of Prius Hybrids is what was cool about them..

    • Jimsim

      Nothing is cool about a Prius.

  • Alexander

    I think the issue of the silentness of hybrids/EVs is over played. I have never experienced near misses or any issues with pedestrians while driving one or as a pedestrian my self. You can hear them coming, they have a very faint electrical noise/whine that’s enough to notice them, above 10km/h they begin to make enough noise to be relatively relatively easily heard. I’ve also seen/heard many non-hybrid/EVs with engines similarly as quiet at low speed in carparks which don’t require hideous fake spaceship noises? Although that said, if someone could hack a Prius to have a V8 idle sound i’d be very interested!

  • http://CarAdvice The Salesman

    There is another device that might be useful. Its call a ‘horn’ this is used to warn those in danger and make people aware of any possible danger.

  • al

    The noise is awful, hurts my ears. The car is downright ugly too.

  • Exchange Student

    I can imagine that a blind person not “in the know” about these new sounds might get the shock of their lives when they hear a “spaceship” whiz by…

    Why bother with “hideous fake spaceship noises” (thanks Alexander)? Why not just have something that sounds like a car?

  • Zen

    How about the noisemaker BMW is Connecting to the stereo of the new M5? :-)

  • Eric

    Some fully sick woofers, cranked up would work just as well.

  • Peanut

    It should make the sound of a V8 Supercar at full throttle.

  • Bangel

    The delightfull sound of a nissan 120y as it powers on out of an uphill corner .

  • Bob

    That sounds like a pain in the arse!

  • AndyGF

    Sounds like a Bat mobile?

  • http://climate-change-theory.com Doug Cotton

    I don’t know how easy it will be to switch on and off, but it seems logical to have a steering wheel mounted button, perhaps near the horn, that could be easily activated only when pedestrians are seen or anticipated.

    PS I’ve said elsewhere that (as my website indicates) there is no empirical evidence that carbon dioxide caused the global warming late last century (which is now turning to global cooling) but I will buy a LEAF because it will be cheaper both for fuel and engine maintenance and better for public health and even noise pollution. I also believe oil prices will rise more than electricity.

  • Marcus K

    Its a shame to start adding noise pollution now that we have ways of finally making the streets quieter.

    I guess if there has to be a sound the Toyota one seems to at least found a tone that isn’t too irritating, and appears relatively quiet.
    The Nissan leaf is a great car – which i would consider buying – but shizen, if they release that car with that awful loud whirr and REVERSE BEEPING there is going to be some cranky drivers (if they bye the car without a test drive) and local residents. What a way to spunk up the EV image – beeping, honestly!

  • Prosperity

    What nonsense!  Many cars can be close to silent.  What about pushbikes?  What about the seriously deaf? What about the scooters some people use that career around on the footpath? What about the responsibility of drivers and pedestrians to look out for one another?

    The only safe course of action is a man walking in front of these electric/hybrid vehicles waving a red flag.

  • Sherwin

    Maybe,  we should just make louder exhausts…  or something the BMW M5 has done, record sounds and play it through the speaker…