BMW Z4 Review | CarAdvice

Car Advice

BMW Z4 Review

BMW Z4

Pros: Highly capable, ticks all the boxes, great fun

Cons: Great road presence but not stunning to look at

By Anthony Crawford |
FIND DEALS

Price: $86,200 to $129,900

Our Rating:  

Model tested:
BMW Z4 sDrive30i, straight-six 3.0-litre petrol: $98,100 (Manufacturer’s List Price)


Options fitted:
• Sports automatic transmission with gear shift paddles: $3300
• Metallic paint: $1840

It’s quick, this Z4 Beemer. I mean it’s really quick for a non-turbo 3.0-litre roadster and the handling is BMW M3-style sharp.

The definition of a roadster is still listed as “a small open-topped car with a single seat in the front and an additional outside folding seat (rumble seat) in the back”.

Thankfully, the automotive industry has moved on and these days, roadsters are also coupes, due to the recent advent of sophisticated folding hardtops.

BMW has been building roadsters for years, and most of its creations have fallen directly into the ‘most beautiful’ category. It didn’t come any better than the powerful straight-six BMW 315 back in 1934, which you would have to agree, is still a sensational looking motor car, from any angle.

Then came the superb BMW 328; followed by a modern masterpiece that is the spellbinding BMW 507, which might well have been the inspiration for the cutting edge Z8 supercar (0-96km/h in 4.2 secs) and all BMW roadsters since.

Well, almost. I can’t say the original 1996 Z3 pushed all the right buttons, at least not for me. Perhaps it was the slightly effeminate styling that I didn’t warm to. The reprieve came when the M Roadster was released in 1998 with the 3.2-litre S50 motor from the E36 M3 with quad exhausts, and that made it all the more respectable.

The BMW Z4 is what the Z3 should have looked like in the first place. Far more assertive styling than the initial ‘Z’ car, this was the modern day roadster from BMW that also drew inspiration from the styling of the 507.

Our test car is the second generation E85 Z4, which was originally released in 2009, and adopted a slightly more powerful stance than the previous model.

Initially I wasn’t sold on the styling, perhaps not quite as pretty in form as those special drop tops of the past, but after living with the car for a week, it’s grown on me – a lot.

As far as proper old school-style roadsters go, the Z4 is the real deal. Front engine, rear-wheel drive, and an on-the-floor driving position are the hallmarks of the classic drop tops.

I know this sounds out of place, but I can’t help make the comparison with an E-Type Jaguar; this is exactly how it feels behind the wheel of the iconic Jag. The stretched bonnet on the Z4 isn’t quite as exaggerated, but the view from the driver’s seat is practically the same.

It might have that touch of retro about it, but the Z4 is cutting edge modern in every other way, and a proper enthusiast car with power induced rear wheel slip, if you want it.

Don’t think you need to go all the way up to the twin-turbo version for real heart stopping performance either, this straight-six naturally aspirated 3.0-litre has got heaps of ‘go’ on tap.

The six-speed manual can knock over the 0-100km/h sprint in a rapid 5.8 seconds, and the optional six-speed sports auto on board this test car isn’t much slower at 6.1 seconds. Give the Z4 a boot full (something you tend to do quite often) when conditions are good, and progress is mighty rapid. It feels quicker than 6.1, but it’s the in-gear acceleration that will endear the Z4 to you. Keep the throttle pinned, and there’s all 310Nm alive from 2600rpm, and if you have enough road, you’re on your way to 250 km/h.

It’s hard to fault these six-cylinder powerplants from BMW. They always seem to punch well above their weight in the ‘grunt’ department with just the right mix of power and torque.

At a fraction over 1500kg (less with the manual box), the Z4 is relatively light for a roadster in this premium class, and 190kW and 310Nm, provides a measured balance between outright sports car performance, fuel efficiency, and emissions output.

Off-the-line acceleration is strong even in auto mode, but I tended to light up the ‘Sport’ and ‘Sport+’ buttons more often than not, especially whenever some clear road presented itself and the paddle shifters became the preferred choice. Gearshifts are more spontaneous with very little torque slip, and the throttle blip on downshifts when braking hard is something that you never tire of.

With the recent advent of folding roofs replacing old school manual soft tops, it’s easy to forget you’re driving a roadster in a car like the Z4, as the NVH (Noise, Vibration and Harshness) management is so good that you need to remind yourself that open-air motoring is just a touch of a button away.

All those wonderful mechanical noises of the Z4 paddle-shifting through the gears are amplified ten-fold with the roof lowered, an operation that takes all of 19 seconds, as the car morphs from stylish coupe to performance roadster.

Not only does the Z4 go hard when shoved, there’s tremendous grip for a front engine car with these proportions. It doesn’t seem to matter how hard you care to push in a corner, the rear wheels refuse to break traction unless you purposely invite slip.

Front engine sports cars tend to understeer when pushed hard in corners, but that’s not the case with the Z4, as if you look closely the engine is set to an almost front/mid position in the car which helps to balance this chassis.

It’s not just the prodigious grip that wins me over either, it’s the way the Z4 responds to driver input that I find irresistible, particularly among twisty roads. The steering is wonderfully direct and fast-acting for an electric power steering unit, which are notoriously difficult to tune properly, and the whole car feels razor sharp through corners. Point to point this is a proper fast car.

Of course, it’s not all about speed with the Z4, it’s as much about dropping the roof down on a balmy Sunday afternoon for a relaxed drive up or down the coast. For that, you’ll want to select the ‘Normal’ drive mode where it’s all about smooth gearshifts and minimal engine revs.

If you’re worried about your hair getting messed up on the freeway with the roof down, don’t be – that’s been tried and tested by yours truly. Even at 110km/h you won’t need one of those silly baseball caps on your head, as there’s little if any turbulence inside the Z4’s cabin.

It doesn’t seem to matter which BMW I am testing, the suspension gurus in Germany manage to get the ride/handling balance right. It’s the same deal with the Z4, no body roll when hard into corners, great stability on poor roads, and an utterly compliant ride that’s neither too firm, nor too harsh.

You can option larger 18- or 19-inch ‘Light alloys’, but I can’t fault the standard fit 17’s with a split tyre width set up for that perfect ride and handling balance, that I mentioned earlier.

It’s also hardly worth mentioning braking ability when reviewing a BMW, because they seem to ‘get it’ sorted better than any other carmaker in its space. Surefooted and progressive pedal feel are what you can expect of BMW brakes, and that’s exactly what you get with the Z4. There’s no brake fade either, but again, that’s just par for the course for this marque.

As a $98,000 car, you have every right to expect a certain level of luxury kit on board, and the Z4 doesn’t disappoint in this regard, despite the extensive BMW options list.

For starters, the leather sports seats are ludicrously comfortable, while offering race car-like bolster support; I mean, your torso doesn’t budge a centimetre, even when you’re driving like you stole it. They’re also treated with SunReflective technology for reduced heat absorption, along with the steering wheel trim.

Bi-Xenon headlamps are part of the standard features package as is the 8.8-inch colour screen with the Professional Navigation System, Bluetooth mobile and USB audio input, 11-speaker hi-fi system, auto climate control, anti-dazzle rear view mirror, auto headlight on and rain sensing wipers, park distance control (front and rear), heated glass rear window and a stack load of others.

You may or may not have heard of iDrive, the central controller fitted to many BMW models, which controls the media and communications features in this Z4. The bottom line is that it’s a cinch to use and very intuitive compared with earlier editions.

Safety on board the Z4 is well catered for too, with a full suite of airbags and every active and passive safety feature that is currently available has been loaded into this car. That’s ABS, Cornering Brake Control (CBC), cruise control with brake function, DSC with extended functions, Dynamic Traction Control (DTC), Rollover Safety System and Run Flat indicator (for the run flat tyres).

While Audi tends to go for the ‘bling’ approach when it comes to interiors, and as nice as they are, I prefer the minimalist styling of BMW, which allows for more focus on the driving. That said, inside the Z4 is 100 percent premium, with soft touch material everywhere, along with the perfect mix of metallic switchgear and wood trim, at least in this spec.

Practicality isn’t exactly a true roadster’s forte, but the Z4 makes a reasonable go of it. There’s plenty of room in the boot for several soft bags provided the roof is up, but you’ll need to travel light in the roof down mode, with just 180 litres of available luggage space.

As far as a modern rendition of a proper old school roadster goes, BMW’s Z4 is the real deal. I only wish the E-Type handled this well.


 

Owner reviews of the BMW Z4

Write a review for the BMW Z4

Do you own this car? Share your opinion and add your own review below.
Add a New Review

  • Harry

    can’t decide if i like the look or not. on one hand it looks stylish but on the other it looks pretty ugly.

  • Ethan

    That steering wheel looks pretty chunky… Too chunky in fact to get a comfortable hold…

    • http://www.caradvice.com.au Anthony Crawford

      It might look that way, but like all performance based Beemers, their steering wheels are some of the best in the business. They are remarkably grippy and have a nice tactile feel about them.

      • AW

        Agreed. I’ve driven a 520d with M Sport Kit, and it is a brilliant steering wheel (the car’s not a bad drive either haha). Wish I had one like it in my car….

        • Al Juraj

          BMW steering wheels are among the best to hold. Try them out before commenting.

  • Hector

    Anthony Crawford have you driven the Porsche Boxster S?

    would you go a 2-3 year old Boxster S over the 3.0 Z4 (looking at the complete package of the two)?

  • Eloeu

    Your right Audi interiors are overrated.. The premium segmant interiors goes in this order fromn best to worst

    1.Lexus
    2.BMW
    3.Mercedes
    4.Audi

    There is no denying Lexus makes the best interiors across the range even their bottom of the line IS has a very premium interior..

    • Jimmy

      Don’t know about your first choice there… as much as I like garish wood grain and crappy digital clock displays, I think I’ll forgo Lexus and put BMW as my number one.

    • Andrew Juma

      I think the recent Mercedes cars can match Audi for interior quality. BMW is still a cut below and I just cannot mention Lexus in the same breath. The crappy digital clocks (how, in this day and age can a premium car have such trash), abominable fake wood and suspect leather just do not do it for me.

    • nickdl

      I’d go BMW, Audi, Merc and Lexus actually. Lexus’ interiors are too similar to Toyota and the horrible woodgrain they use only makes it worse. Merc don’t use the same quality materials as Audi and BMW do and BMW manage to make theirs look the best as well.

    • MF

      I wonder how many people here actually have driven a Lexus? They are probably too snobby to even give it a try.

    • mitch

      No denying ? Well I deny it..Merc & Audi are nicer inside than Lexus.Makes me wonder if you’ve sat in them all or just comparing photos..

      • Eloeu

        Yes I have sat in C-class, E-class and I have sat on Lexus IS, GS and RX.. In have also sat in BMW 7 series, 5 series and 3 series and Audi A4..

        Mercedes interiors look to edgy and swarthy, the C-class has too many hard plastic bits which makes the car very cheap. 3 series and 5 series interiors are too sporty to be considered luxury and A4 interior is too flat, the centre console ruins it..

        Lexus interiors put great emphasis on luxury, they usually have wood on steering, doors and on the centre console where the gear is etc.. And soft touches everywhere, the entire interior.. I just can’t explain it, you have to go in a Lexus to understand what I mean.. And play around and touch the interior..

  • http://www.caradvice.com.au Anthony Crawford

    Hector, good question. I have driven the Boxster and the Techart version of the Cayman, but not the Boxster S. While I rate both Porsche cars for a brilliant chassis – The Z4 is more fun and arguably better finished. Spec-for-spec you would need to compare the Z4 sDrive 335i to the Boxster S and the Z4 is quicker and more potent than the Porsche. You also get a smaller screen in the Porsche (6.6″ vs 8.8″).

    • David

      I’m no car journo, but I have driven auto versions of both the Z4 sdrive23i as well as the base model Boxster. Z4 was much more exciting to drive and felt more polished. The Boxster S manual would be a hoot though.

  • David

    Aguably one of the best looking current BMW’s in my view. A big improvement over the previous Z4.

  • nickdl

    Great review Anthony. Is your hair really long enough to get ruined by the wind?? :)

    The new Z4 is a great looking car IMO, shame about the unfortunate colour of this one, looks much better in dark blue. BMW’s engines are just fantastic, they can’t be faulted. The hard decision is if you want a $100k Beemer, this or a 1 Series M Coupe…

    • http://www.caradvice.com.au Anthony Crawford

      Nick, unlike many of the over 40 crew, I still have a full head of hair and things can definitely go wrong in the wind.

    • DDH

      I actually think the colour is cool – it is called Orion. Bit like a Ferrari 612 scag in beige or as they call it Grigio Ingrid

  • Carrara

    At Lexus haters, Lexus is all about interior, it’s one of heir main sale point, Lexus places big emphasis on interior refinement, comfort, quality and innovation.. It’s the small touches that make Lexus amazing like how the light all dim if it’s nght or day, how the I terior cluster lights up when door is open and other little touches, door compartment lighting etc

    Lexus interiors also give you a cuddly feel with the high grade quality leather (unlike the fake leather you get in BMW’s) and Lexus I teriors are generally well padded..

    Next time actually go sit on a Lexus before you start talking trash about it

    • K20A

      Can you substantiate your statement that BMW uses fake leather? I am quite knowledgeable with their products and can confirm that they do not and in my memory (1990 onwards) have not used fake leather. Even the backing & headrests are upholstered in genuine leather (some manufacturers cut cost by using different material for non-seating surfaces).

      Have you had personal experience with ‘fake leather’ in BMW?

      Lexus interior are very nice indeed albeit in a very different way. Lexus interior does not feel European, never will be and am sure they’re not trying to be one either.

      All the things you’ve mentioned (auto dimming, ‘entry’ lighting, door compartment lighting) are also featured in BMW/Mercs/Audi in varying degree. European cars also the very first to offer ambient lighting (two small LEDs that project down into the gear lever area). BMWs have had this since the early 90s.. same with Audi I’m pretty sure. Japanese have only caught up with this in the last 5 years or so.

      Regarding ‘padding’, it is intentional. Have you driven Merc/Audi/BMW/Lexus (all of them) if you have, you’ll realise that it’s not only just the padding of the seats, but the whole feel of the car is also consistent (i.e., Lexus’ and Merc’s controls, switches, steering, transmission, pedals, doors, etc. will feel lighter and take less effort to operate than BMW. Audi is somewhere in between. These intangible qualities embody the brand and something that is carefully thought out. There’s no right or wrong and they’re just personal preferences. BMW and Audi seats (and VW) are always firm.. always have been and I don’t think it’s going to change anytime soon.. that’s just how they pad their seats. On the opposite, sitting in a Merc / Lexus with their perforated leather is a joy to behold after a long hard day at work.. the leather feels buttery soft and the overall impression is more luxurious. Again, this doesn’t mean BMW’s or Audi’s are of less quality..

      I also remember reading Lexus brochure in the early 00s that says the leather they use comes from animals that roam in a wire-fence free environment (hence fence marks on leather is minimised).

      Just my two cents.

    • Devil’s Advocate

      Most of the interior of a Lexus I agree does have a premium look/feel, however they still continue to use the cheap looking green/blue digital display for the clock/climate control temperature display that has been used in cars for decades ie virtually identical to the clock in the 1983 Sigma my wife had when I first met her as well as the late 80s model Cressida. I have even seen this type of display used in the latest LS and is such a contrast from the look of the “optitron” dashboard! IMHO it really detracts from the overall ambience of the cabin.

      WRT to the BMW fake leather, many manufacturers use “fake leather” on things like seat backs etc and they even mention it, as they should, on their websites/specificatino lists etc. I wouldn’t be surprised if even Lexus do this on some less visible surfaces.

      • K20A

        You would be glad to know that Lexus has finally get rid of the HH:MM:SS buttons! :)

        Therefore the time is now sync’d with the GPS.. and displayed through the advanced fluorescent display presentation.

        I have also commented before.. about the tape deck Lexus insist on keeping.. up until few years ago. My cousin’s RX330 bought in 2004 still had one.. and I’m pretty sure GS450h still had one too! I just have to find that UB40 cassette I bought in primary school with saved-up lunch money..

        Cressida eh? those were nice cars.. I can still remember the softness of those moth-brown velour seats..

  • Spellcheck

    I want to like Lexus, but they just look and feel so much like Toyota. For the money I’d stick with Audi and BMW, Mercs are great….if you’re retired.

    • K20A

      Spot on. Lexus are great cars but for a car enthusiast like me, I can spot too many shared parts with Toyota :( The infamous green digital clock is one of them!

      Thank goodness they’ve get rid of the dreaded HH:MM:SS button recently!!! they still had it up until few years ago.

      BMW and Audi for me (now), Mercs or Jags when I hit my 50s and 60s.

  • Dennis

    CA,

    Do you know if BMW have sorted the diff issues they had with the First Z4?

  • zzz4

    what i like about it is there isn’t that many around unlike the boxster…..and best of both world boxster and cayman all into one. I known the cayman is much better on the road.

  • ddd

    Love the interior!!

    the exterior is H I D E O U S!!!

    • ddd

      hang on a sec…. i looked at the previous models pix.

      that was FUGLY!

      the new one, however…. big leap forward in ext design!

  • Al Juraj

    Not stunning to look at? Man you should drive the car to OPSM.

  • categeorgia@bigpond.com

    well i guess it is ok