Mini Cooper S Clubman Review | CarAdvice

Car Advice

Mini Cooper S Clubman Review

MINI COOPER

Pros: Ride & Handling, Looks, Customisability, Engine, Interior

Cons: "Clubdoor" on the wrong side, not as fun as standard Cooper S

By Alborz Fallah
FIND DEALS

Price: $24,200 to $29,920

Our Rating:  

The Mini Clubman is definitely  not the car for everyone, but when it comes to standing out it certainly ticks all the right boxes.

Who buys a MINI Clubman? It’s hard to say. Assumably someone that really wants a Mini Cooper but must have practical rear seats and more room.

One way to find out is to spend a week with a Mini Clubman S. First impressions may be dismissive as the Clubman is really engineered for left-hand drive markets – the third door is on the driver’s side meaning it faces traffic if parked on the street. How enjoyable it will be to get passengers (especially kids) in and out of the illogical side of the car is an interesting question.

No doubt the car’s door design wasn’t meant for our market (ironically, also neglecting Mini’s home country of Britain) hence the door is actually meant to be on the passenger side, which makes significantly more sense for getting people in and out of a car.

Alas, if you can excuse the Clubman for that rather obvious design ‘feature’, it’s a very enjoyable little thing to punt around. It measures 240mm longer than the standard Cooper, 77mm of which has gone into rear legroom. This Mini is made to be a little more practical.

Much like any other Mini with an S badge in the lineup, the Clubman accelerates with a ferocity uncharacteristic to a 1.6-litre turbocharged engine. The BMW-Peugeot developed engine delivers 135 kW and 240Nm (260Nm on overboost) of torque in this application, which results in a 0-100km/h time of 7.5 seconds – roughly half a second slower than the standard Cooper S.

From the outside the Mini Cooper S Clubman (as it’s officially known) is a good looking thing. The new and updated 2011 model is now 99mm longer than before and Mini has added numerous changes to modernise the look of all Mini Coopers.

The front is traditional Mini with air intakes on the bonnet and front apron. The rear gains LED tail lights (first time) with Brake Force Display (brake lights increase in intensity if the car is braking hard). Looking at the Clubman’s right side, you can spot the infamous little “Clubdoor” that opens backwards. There is a handle inside that easily unlatches the miniature-door but it only works when the driver’s door is already open.

There is a whole lot of character to the Clubman’s interior. From the traditionally gigantic speedometer located right in the centre, to the blue (customisable) interior LED lights that elegantly light up the cabin. Soft touch plastics on the dash and a beautifully crafted steering wheel do a lot to justify the Clubman S’s $43,800 starting price.

Although the stereo does have Bluetooth phone support it doesn’t have audio streaming, which is rather annoying given a $13,900 Hyundai Getz comes standard with it. Nonetheless it will play natively from your iPhone/Pod with the right adapter.

The speakers have great bass and clarity with little distortion even at deafening volumes. If you want to pay a little more, the Chilli variants get a Harman Kardon audio system.

The interesting thing about the third door on the driver’s side is that it provides no easier access to the rear seats than from the other side (having put the passenger seat down). One, because you still have to open the driver’s door to get out (nearly defeating the purpose of a third door), so it’s not like it’s more convenient for the driver. Two, because of the way the rear door works it’s still a bit of a pain if you’re 160cm or taller and the driver’s seat is fully upright.

The split-doors to the boot open up like barn doors allowing for easy access to store bulky stuff. Once you fold the rear-seats flat you have 930L of cargo capacity, which will make IKEA your new favourite destination. There is even a button on the Mini key remote that will automatically open one of the doors for your. Which makes putting in shopping bags a breeze. You must close the left door before the right one will close.

If all you care about is the driver’s enjoyment, then the Clubmas S is, for lack of better words, simply awesome. Despite the occasional torque steer (generally on a straight line under full acceleration) the actual driving dynamics are very rewarding. You can still power out of corners like you would in an all-wheel drive and taking corners at maximum velocity becomes rather addictive.

The best feature is feedback through the steering wheel. Unlike say, a Lexus, the Mini talks to you through the steering wheel, letting you know how much you’re already pushing and how much further you can push. It’s an engaging driving experience that I suspect most people ever take full advantage of.

Speaking of people, the Mini Cooper Clubman found a mere 184 buyers last year, of which 82 went for the “S” model. So if you’re looking at buying a Clubman, you’ll be joining a very exclusive club – which is apart of the car’s appeal.

The other and perhaps Mini’s biggest appeal has always been about customer customisation. The idea of being able to get your car in the exact way that you want it with all the right colours and features is by no means cheap, but if uniqueness-factor is built into your personality than it’s hard to resist. If you’re wondering, safety is also top notch with ABS, Electronic Stability Control and six airbags as standard.

Overall, the updates to the engine, exterior and interior of the 2011 Mini Cooper Clubman S has enhanced an already enjoyable package. If you can look past the third door being on the wrong side, this little Mini brings practicality and fun together for the first time.

Owner reviews of the MINI COOPER Add a New Review

WE RECOMMEND YOU ALSO CONSIDER...

  • Nick K

    How stupid of Mini to have the door design only work for left hand drive markets… The Countyman can’t come soon enough. This car will disappear from the new car price lists very soon in my opinion.

  • bangel

    You know i have never seen a mini on the move with more than 2 up , makes the rear doors a non issue , most are bought by single chics or dudes .

    The clubman is not that attractive , but no doubt it drives well .

  • Shak

    This car doesn’t seem to have had very much thought put into it. The door being on the wrong side is a mistake than can be forgiven, but the fact that its design requires the drivers door to be open is just plain stupid. And also the way the left barn door must be closed for the right to close is just a really big pain.

    • Daniel

      The drivers door probably has to be opened first because of the safety – the doors lock in to make a B (??) pillar – similar to the Mazda RX8, the front door must be open before the rear (suicide) door can be opened and the rear door must be shut first so that the doors lock together to form a B pillar

  • Scott

    Beautiful car.

  • schultzy

    To all those whinging about which side the 3rd door should be on – Try loading a wheelchair from the drivers side without the extra width of the 3rd door.

    gOOD LUCK WITH THAT! lol

    • kennyboye

      Get a different car then….jeez.

  • billy batson

    I have owned a Clubman for 3 years (in the UK), in fact have just ordered another one. I can tell you that the club-door on the RH side is a non-issue, in fact it’s very convenient because as the driver you can so easily put things on the back seat rather than walk round the car. On the rare occasion when someone is in the back, you simply park where it does not matter. It is amazing how this one feature of what is an excellent car, gets so much bad press, usually from people who never owned one.

    • http://www.caradvice.com.au/ Alborz Fallah

      Billy, as I said in the review, it’s the only thing that is worth noting as the car itself is very good. More importantly, you can get in from the passenger side rather easily anyway.

  • Octavian

    Quite a cool car, for smaller people and singles I suppose.

  • Ian

    I am a fat bast@rd and I own 2 Minis and space or comfort isn’t an issue. One of the Mini’s is a Clubman S and I also like the door arrangement.

  • SC

    I love the look of minis, but I could never bring myself to own one because they are just too girly for my taste. I cop enough girl car jokes driving a Golf GTI so would hate to think of the comments I’d cop for rocking up in one of these…

  • lil man 101

    THIS MINI IS SO GAY ITS SO RETARTED

  • Flanderz

    Well I just bought one, due to pick it up in a few days. So I’ll let you know if the 3rd door is such an issue. Sure it’d be good to have the door on the left hand side, but in reality for me, on the rare occasion I would use the back seat for a 3rd or 4th passenger. They would usually be loaded up in a driveway, and unloaded at a parking lot. So the whole oncoming traffic problem is no issue for me. And besides all that, I’ve always LOVED the little panelvan look.