BMW Z4 sDrive35is Review | Car Advice

Car Advice

BMW Z4 sDrive35is Review

BMW Z4

Pros: Enormous power, launch control, looks, driving feel, raw-edginess, likes to be driven hard

Cons: Steering-wheel mounted paddle-shifters, uninspiring interior, having to give it back

By Alborz Fallah |
Add to shortlist

Price: $54,810 to $84,000

Our Rating:  

The BMW Z4 sDrive35is is the ultimate convertible sportscar under $150,000.

Model Tested:

  • 2010 BMW Z4 sDrive35is; 3.0 litre, six cylinder, twin-turbo petrol; seven speed dual-clutch  transmission; two door sportscar: $129,900

CarAdvice Rating:rating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gifrating11.gif

It’s not often that one would consider working on their birthday, but I made an exception when it came to picking up the ultimate Z4. Perhaps it was a birthday present in disguise.

You see, the BMW Z4 has been fighting hard against the Audi TT, Porsche Boxster and to a lesser extent, even the Nissan 370Z. In September this year BMW Australia sold just 16 Z4s. In total the German company is unlikely to sell over 300 units over the course of the whole year. In fact, the number of BMW Z4 sDrive35is convertibles heading to Australia are limited to say the least.

This is a good thing because if you’ve got about $130,000 to spend on a über-unique convertible sports car, put this right up the top of your list.

BMW has brought out the sDrive35is as a way of combating the Audi TT-RS and Porsche’s Boxster S. It’s hard to understand why the M badge hasn’t been applied because the sDrive35is has 250kW and 500Nm of torque (almost the same power as the previous Z4M and more torque). That means a 0-100km/h time of just 4.8 seconds (same as the manual M3).

Purists may be slightly disappointed knowing that it’s not available with a manual gearbox, but then again the seven-speed sports automatic transmission with double clutch operation is perhaps one of the best gearboxes in the business (used in the BMW M3), so there is little to be concerned about.

The press car was red, which is ideal for a convertible, although the Z4 does look good in pretty much any colour (even if the mirrors are a little odd). The paperwork was signed, the key was handed over and it was time to see what all the fuss was about.

Unlike some Australian motoring journalist that are simply far too old to enjoy roof-down sports convertible driving, I hesitated for about half-a-second before turning the Z4 sDrive35is into a proper convertible (via a button on the console). The roof operation takes 20 seconds.

If you’ve never sat in a Z4, you will quickly notice that the cabin is a little bit like the rest of the BMW model range, from the iDrive controls to the LCD screen and cd player, the Z4′s interior may be adequate for the standard models but the sDrive35is really does beg for a little more character, even if it’s just some colour coded stitching.

Don’t get me wrong, BMW has added aluminum carbon interior trim finisher as well as an M leather steering wheel but it can do with more personality.

Press the start button and the Z4 sDrive35is comes to life with a little growl. You’ll be happy to know this is the most powerful factory implementation of BMW’s outgoing twin-turbo 3.0-litre six-cylinder engine (which has won numerous engine of the year awards). The engine is being replaced by a single-turbo twin-scroll setup (already seen in the 5 Series) in the near future.

You can either just put the car in D or attempt to use the counter-intuitive steering-wheel paddles. It’s such a shame that BMW hasn’t updated the Z4 sDrive35is’ steering wheel paddles to match the ones found in the new M3.

As it stands now, the paddles on both sides are able to change up and down, making gearshifts just that little bit more confusing. Traditionally the left paddle is down and the right paddle is up (as with the new M3). It may seem like a big deal at first, but give it a few days and you get pretty used to it and by week’s end it’s a nonissue (preferably though, the left-down right-up setup is still more logical).

With the roof stored away, the Z4 sDrive35is is just like any other Z4 around town. Leave it in D with ‘Normal’ mode selected and it can sleep all day in traffic, the gear changes are extra-smooth and despite its performance credentials you can easily drive it to work everyday in peak-hour traffic without feeling uncomfortable.

The real fun, however, starts when you engage Sports + mode and launch control. It works a little like this: once the engine has warmed up you simply pick Sports +, put the gearshift into manual mode, put your left foot on the brake pedal and your right foot on the accelerator. All of a sudden a checkered-flag will show up in the instrument cluster display and the engine will hold its revs at about 4,000rpm, ready to launch you in to space.

The millisecond you let go of the brake pedal the Z4′s 250kW and 500Nm of torque will physically smack you back into your seat as it begins tearing up the tarmac on its way to 100km/h in under five seconds. Having tried this… oh, I don’t know, a ‘few’ times, I can tell you that launch control is actually rather violent (read: extremely fun), which makes it stupidly addictive. The Z4 does tend to want to slide a little when launched, it needs some guidance otherwise you may end up in the bushes.

More importantly the local constabulary wouldn’t be all that happy with you trying this at a set of lights, so a race track should be frequented if you plan on buying this beast. Nonetheless, if ever you do happen to come next to a Porsche Boxster S at a set of lights you will have no issues beating it to 100km/h by a good 0.5 of a second. It’s fair to point out that the Audi TT-RS is 0.2 seconds quicker to 100km/h.

Around tight corners the Z4 is a little twitchy. Having driven the BMW 335i Convertible the week before, the Z4 felt a little more nervous which in some people’s books is another word for fun. In normal mode it’s too soft for sporty driving but in Sport and Sport + mode the adaptive M suspension can literally lower the Z4 by up to 10millimetres, which means a hard, firm and sporty ride.

The steering can do with a little more feedback as it does feel a little over-assisted. Furthermore the steering to wheel movement ratio is so damn precise that you can make yourself sick with the car’s rapid cornering ability.

BMW says the damper stiffness is managed by a system that is capable of adjusting on the fly. For example the second the front wheels drive over a bad patch of road (hole, bump) the rear dampers have already adjusted in anticipation.

Take it up a twisty mountain range and the Z4 sDrive35is really shines. Accelerate hard towards a corner, heavy on the brakes upon approach, attempt to gear down, realise that you actually went a gear up instead, curse BMW’s steering-wheel mounted paddles, gear down twice, point the front wheels in the right direction, plant your right foot flat to the floor, engage hyper drive – smile uncontrollably. It’s hard to get bored of this.

The rear-wheels are not as well planted as an M3 and the Z4 does try to kill you once in a while, but then again that’s why it’s the ideal convertible sportscar. It’s fun! And in this day and age, fun and powerful cars are far and few in between.

Driving it around town, the performance-orientated Z4 certainly turns heads. Even parked on the side of a busy road the sDrive35is is beautiful in its own way (you can argue otherwise, I am sure). It’s distinguishable from the lesser Z4s by its standard 18” light alloy wheels in “Star-Spoke” styling, M sports kit and sDrive35is badging. BMW has also redesigned the car’s exhaust system for a unique and glorious sound.

As with all BMW cars, safety is top-notch and the Z4 gets driver and passenger front and side airbags as well as a whole bunch of active safety features (that I shall not bore you with).

Overall, for $129,900 you can either buy this or a Porsche Boxster S (or spend a little more on the TT-RS). The Boxster has less power, is slower and getting replaced soon, however the Audi TT-RS does represent a worthy competitor.

If it was my $129,900, I would stick with the Z4 sDrive35is simply because I can’t get over how much engagement is required to get the best out of it. For me, having to actually ‘drive’ the Z4 to go really fast easily outweighs its few negatives.

For more information and specifications: BMW Z4 Range.


 

Reader reviews of the BMW Z4

<

Write a review for the BMW Z4

Do you own this car? Share your opinion and add your own review below.

Add a New Review
>

The competition

  Variant Body Style Price From
BMW Z4 sDRIVE 20i
  • 2.0L TURBO MPFI
  • 6 SP MANUAL
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D ROADSTER $76,900*
BMW Z4 sDRIVE 20i
  • 2.0L TURBO MPFI
  • 8 SP AUTOMATIC
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D ROADSTER $80,400*
BMW Z4 sDRIVE 28i
  • 2.0L TURBO MPFI
  • 6 SP MANUAL
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D ROADSTER $89,400*
BMW Z4 sDRIVE 28i
  • 2.0L TURBO MPFI
  • 8 SP AUTOMATIC
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D ROADSTER $92,900*
BMW Z4 sDRIVE 35is
  • 3.0L TURBO MPFI
  • 7 SP AUTO DIRECT SHIFT
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D ROADSTER $120,500*
powered by
  VEHICLE PRICE
2003 BMW Z4 OTHER E85
  • 146,291 Kms
  • Deep Blue
  • Roadster
  • Auto
  • Other
  • NSW
$25,888*
Enquire Now
2010 BMW Z4 SDRIVE35ID-CT E89 MY10
  • 4,041 Kms
  • Sapphire Black
  • Roadster
  • Auto
  • Petrol
  • NSW
$103,000*
Enquire Now
Showrooms > Bmw > Z4

BMW Z4 sDrive35is Review
Bmw
Z4
The BMW Z4 sDrive35is is the ultimate convertible sportscar under $150,000.
K3710A
http://www.caradvice.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/BMW-Z4-sDrive35is-Review-41-625x466.jpg

BMW Z4 sDrive35is Review
The BMW Z4 sDrive35is is the ultimate convertible sportscar under $150,000.
4 stars
  • Wayne Kerr

    This is one fast, but odd little rocket.

    The performance suits guys but not the styling. Girls will love the styling but won’t exploit the full performance nor will they appreciate the firm ride.

    • Shak

      Actually saw one in black today and the stying is really good, until it sees direct sunlight when the weird rear end shows its face.

      • DDH

        The hero deep sea blue is what you would have to get the 35is in.

  • DDH

    I think the base 23d or whatever is a good buy – but I’d spend $130k elsewhere – 2nd hand 911 anyone?

    • Mythfrances

      Some ppl may not like the idea of buying a second hand (cos you dont know what the previous owner had done in the car =)). worth considering though.

  • http://caradvice Try Again

    Definitely they are a bit of a head turner and have a luxurious interior and options and I a hoot to drive.

    Really nice engine with such nice power.Love the roof down etc.

    But the reviewer must have driven different cars as I have driven both the Z435 and the i.s. and the handling is somewhat dysfunctional.

    The front has no real relationship with the back when you start to push both these models.

    You are waiting for the message to arrive between ends to coordinate a combined response but it doesn’t happen.

    I was really hopeful after driving the first Z4 35 that a M would appear or that the in between i.s would fix this as I possibly would have bought one.

    A real shame with a car that has so much going for it to handle so average,but never the less a fun car to drive and own as long as you are not looking for a fine handling machine.

    • http://www.caradvice.com.au/ Alborz Fallah

      as I said, the handling is not as planted as say an M3, but that’s what makes the Z4 so much fun. It’s twitchy and always on edge. So many cars these days make use of computers to keep you planted, the Z4, to me, felt very pure.

      • TomJ

        Interested to hear what you think of early model S2000′s… it sounds alot of commentators ‘negatives’ are positives for you.

  • http://CarAdvice Try Again

    Thanks Alborz for your comments.

    I think we both agree that its a fun car to drive and I take your point that it requires COMMITMENT at the pointy end..

    Reminds me of the old Porsche Turbo that looked for the opportunity to catch you out and kill you.

    Buts that’s probably a exaggeration for a overall fine car.

  • Steve

    Nice looking car, seen one in white the other day that looked very good.

    But I would probably go with the Audi first.

  • ethan

    i just cant get used to the look of this… i saw one on the road the other day with the lights on and it reminded me of a startled owl staring at you…

  • Krish

    If this is a great drive, then imagine the 1 series M, which will more than likely have the same engine :) Bring it on!

  • Grammar Nazi

    Thanks Alborz for not boring us with the exhaustive safety specifications! It’s pretty safe to assume that anything new coming out of Germany (or greater Europe for that matter) will have every 3-letter safety acronym under the sun.

    Great review, sounds like a hoot to drive.

  • MB

    Good car the Z but the model life has been short.

    Perhaps the updated SLK with more of a focus on the driver will be the way to go especially with the new engines Mercedes are releasing.

  • Hung Low

    Great drive train, pity about the ugly styling and rather ordinary interior for $130k.

  • Joe P

    Will it be 3 months or 5000kms when it will need the first of many fuel pumps replaced???

    No thanks…..

    • Frank

      Too right – it is annoying though when every motoring journo is quick to proclaim the “engine of the year” status of this motor, omitting any mention of widely known file pump problems that BMW refuses to acknowledge or do anything about.

      That is obviously how BMW is able to keep peddling a product that is not yet fully sorted, when the motoring media do their part in perpetuating the ultimate driving machine stuff.

      Perhaps they are, especially when you haven’t had to plonk down your own hundred grand, only to then find your car is not dependable, and spends more time than your neighbor’s Camry at the dealership getting repaired.

      • Devil’s Advocate

        Not acknoledging a fault is not just isolated to BMW. The majority of car manufacturers deny anything is wrong with their vehciles for as long as possible as a recall will cost the manufacturer a lot of money. A couple of examples of manufacturers ‘dragging the chain’ on faults are the Ford Territory’s ball joints, Mazda’s Gen1 Mazda3 and it’s engine mounts and the VE Commodores with their flat batteries etc. Personally I would rather have a fuel pump stop working or provide limited pressure than a fire in the engine bay due to an unsuitable hose clamp or an engine mount/ball joint collapsing. But that is just me…
        :-)

        • Frank

          If one holds BMW to the same standard as Ford or Holden, then that is correct.

          The problem is that companies such as BMW regularly and loudly proclaim themselves to be better – ultimate driving machine?

          So why shouldn’t their standards be higher, because that’s what they’re charging for…

          However, if the consumer is prepared to lower their expectations in terms of reliability, then that explains how and why manufacturers of such “prestige” cars are able to continue to sell their wares at such high profit margins – without feeling any sense of obligation that a customer who pays more is entitled to expect more…

  • http://www.pokiesplayonline.com.au Pokie lover

    Awesome car. I am thinking of buying a new car and I so wish I could buy this one! Way above my budget though :(

    • Fenno

      maybe pump a couple of more bucks into a pokie machine…?

  • Adrian

    Its boardering on criminal what we pay for cars here. In the UK the same car is 43k pounds which converts to about AUD70k. It cant cost 60k in taxes and shipping can it ?

  • LukasUtopia

    If people say they don’t like the interior, what are their reasons?

    I’m in professional design and can tell you that both BMW and Audi interiors are the best designed on this planet (with the exception of now Jaguar and of course Rolls Royce and Bently), from both a aesthetical and ergonomic perspective. Ever heard of the Bauhaus? It’s where the best design students from around the world graduate from and to aspire to then go work for BMW, Audi and to a lessor extent Mercedes-Benz.

    No I’m not pro-German – I love some of the Peugeot and Citroen designs, less serious and more fun than German.

  • Overquill

    To the author: For a car that seems to hold the experience of the drive as the most important aspect, would the gearbox paddle arrangement be a deal breaker for a purist? You state that you got used to it, but should a car that is about the drive be trying to forge new ideas by tinker with well established (and not really broken) norms?

    • http://www.caradvice.com.au/ Alborz Fallah

      It’s hard to say if it’s a deal breaker, personally for me it wouldn’t be as I would just adapt to the design. However I can see how it can be a deterrent. BMW tried this paddle-shift design on the previous 3 Series as well, so it’s nothing new. Having heard all the complaints it did swap back.