2012 Mahindra Pik-Up Review | CarAdvice

Car Advice

2012 Mahindra Pik-Up Review

MAHINDRA PIK-UP

Pros: Generous payload area; excellent visibility; good standard equipment levels for price

Cons: Safety rating; performance when laden; cabin odour; turning circle; fit and finish

By Matt Brogan |
FIND DEALS

Price: $19,470 to $24,640

Our Rating:  

The Mahindra Pik Up is India’s alternative to the more well established utes on sale in Australia.

There’s no shortage of styles, with single-cab chassis, single-cab ute, dual-cab chassis and dual-cab ute all offered, with the range covered by a single turbo diesel – a 2.2-litre unit.

Prices kick off from as low as $20,999, for a 4×2 single-cab chassis, up to $30,499 for a 4×4 dual-cab.

As one of India’s top ten manufacturers, Mahindra has over 60 years experience building commercial vehicles and farm machinery, the group now selling utes, tractors and farm equipment to every continent on earth – except Antartica.

So when it decided to launch its Pik-Up range of single- and dual-cab utes into the Australian market back in 2007, we were assured the sub-continent’s proven industrialist would at least come with a bit of know-how in tackling the extremes of land down under.

With that in mind, we put the Pik-Up to task with a little trade work this week to see just how well it stacks up. The basic single-cab 4×4 utility a relative unknown, Pik-Up was certain to stand out at the local timber yard, drawing its fair share of interest from passing tradesmen.

Measuring in at 1880mm (H) x 1770m (W) x 5098mm (L), the Pik-Up is a sizeable beast, feeling similar in proportion to that of an early series LandCruiser. The large alloy tray offers a generous cargo area and, according to the owner’s manual, is good for 1060kg of payload. The trouble is that as big as the Pik-Up is, cabin space is a little tight in terms of legroom, with storage behind the seats and in the centre console also rather limited.

When it comes to features, the Pik-Up is a little light-on compared to some full-fruit Japanese rivals, but it’s not as skint as you might think considering the price.

The standard kit list includes a single-CD tuner with steering wheel-mounted remote controls and auxiliary audio input(s), air conditioning, a rear demister, follow-me home headlamps, power windows and mirrors, remote central locking, engine immobiliser, 12-volt power outlet and height adjustable headlamps. A tilt-adjustable steering column is also included as standard (no reach adjustment).

As serviceable as the cabin equipment is, the odour from the cabin plastics is rather overwhelming – and it’s not just “new car smell”. Our test vehicle this week had some 27,000kms on the odometre, surely enough time to dissipate any residual manufacturing odours. But seemigly not. The smell so strong in fact we resorted to driving with the windows down all week.

The other thing noticed about Pik-Up’s cabin is the clip-together assembly of its various components. The fit and finish is, as a result, rather average. Its decor too a little dated when compared to most other rivals, the carbon fibre centre stack seeming very out of place.

But when you’re paying $24,000 for a ute, I guess a few compromises are to be expected, and as near as we could tell these were relatively minor in the scheme of things.

As far as pulling its weight the Pik-Up did a fair job considering its rather meager 79kW power output. Unladen the Mahindra performs quite well, and although it’s no bullet in the 0-100km/h sprint, managing a casual 18.3 seconds, it will keep with traffic if you keep it on the boil.

Developing 247Nm of torque between 1800 and 2200rpm, the Pik-Up’s 2.5-litre common-rail, four-cylinder turbo-diesel engine, produced in conjunction with AVL Austria, is a little low-tech compared to market rivals, and presents noticeable turbo lag when getting off the line. The lack of pulling power is evident too when carrying weight, our 400-odd kilograms of timber enough to slow the single-cab ute at the slightest incline.

Keeping on top of the gearshifts can also be a little challenging, the gearstick position a sloppy in third and fourth gear. The clutch however is rather meaty with a tactile feel suitable for the vehicle’s orientation. 4×4 selection is managed by a Borg Warner electric servo that can be selected on-the-fly at low speeds (see instruction decal in image gallery below). For convenience, the Mahindra Pik-Up also features auto-locking front hubs. At kerb weight, the Pik-Up offers 210mm of ground clearance.

Brake pedal feel is also a little vestigial with quite a bit of travel present before any ‘bite’ is felt. Upon engaging, the pedal is quite firm and the amount of available regulation brief, meaning that were it not for the ABS system, locking of the wheels under moderate to heavy braking would be rather commonplace, especially in the wet. The Mahinda Pik-Up features disc brakes up front and drums on the rear.

Joining the anti-lock brakes, the Pik-Up includes such safety features as a crash protection crumple zone (front), side intrusion beams, fire retardant interior fabrics, dual front SRS airbags and three-point inertia reel seatbelts with load limiters and pyrotechnic pretensioners. The Mahindra Pik-Up scores a two-star ANCAP safety rating (from a possible five-stars). Side airbags, ESP and Traction Control are not available.

Tthe Mahindra Pik-Up range is nothing if not cheap, and it’s this fact above most others that see the Pik-Up score an extra half-a-wheel. If you’re after a farm ute, it’s certainly worth considering.

When compared to the best-sellers in its class, Mahindra Pik-Up is nearly $8500 cheaper than the Nissan Navara (based on DX diesel 4×4) and almost $14,000 cheaper than a similarly spec’ed Toyota HiLux (based on SR diesel 4×4). Sure, the pedigree may not be as well recognised in our local market, but the mutt from Mumbai certainly delivers an honest dollar-for-dollar advantage.




 

Owner reviews of the MAHINDRA PIK-UP

Write a review for the MAHINDRA PIK-UP

Do you own this car? Share your opinion and add your own review below.
Add a New Review

  • http://www.lukehimself.net Luke

    Looks like it was built in the 80s

  • Toyota Guru

    Is that a “third” brake light or a rear fog lamp next to the number plate? Looks to have moisture in it. Good build quality there…

    • http://www.caradvice.com.au Matt Brogan

      That’s a rear foglamp TG.

      • Toyota Guru

        Thanks Matt. In that case, I hope Mahindra have put in a nice big warning light to tell drivers that their rear fog lamp is on.

        • Keepleft

          Naturally, the rear fog lamp setup on Mahindra have both the tell-tale pilot lamp AND ISO symbol on the switch. No mistaking the function here.

          When one is to use an aftermarket tradie tray, ensure the installer refits the rear fog.

          Mahindra also have a Euro/UN spec warning triangle.

  • PN

    Any new car with a ANCAP safety rating less than 4 stars should not be allowed on the road.

    • Coz

      Couldn’t agree more – thats just completely unacceptable, when Hilux/Triton are nudging 5 stars. An employer could be liable for some kind of negligence action supplying these cheap pieces of crap to their workers.

      • Tom22

        I agree completely, well, atleast a 3 star anyway the problem is im not sure most customers research or care into crash safety enough for cars of this price point

        than again, i cringe to think what my 10 year old ss would score in a current test.

        • Bang

          Just remember your 10 year old SS, is exactly that. Built prior to the current standard and expected safety features. 2 stars is not acceptable in 2010. In reality, the more packed with safety features, the more likely you will be around to tell the tale after a major accident. 2 stars almost equates to motorbike safety.

    • smokin’r32

      ANCAPs already solved that issue, they’ve lowered the standards so even a Great Wall can get 4 stars!!

      • PickUp

        Side airbags etc to score a 5 star safety rating aernt much use on a farm. Just more features that aernt needed but can break.

  • PoisonEagle

    ANCAP is crap, how can a seatbelt warning light be the difference between 4 stars and 5? Or why do cars have to EARN a side impact test? Its rubbish, and doesnt take into account size differneces in collisions (i.e. Nissan Patrol will kill occupants of 5 star Fiesta every time) ,ESP isnt properly tested; the whole system needs a serious overhaul, safety ratings are too easy to attain. Also why does the interior smell, perhaps the workers bathe in the ganges for smoko?

  • Tony

    one must wonder about their engine with the 1.6 CRDi in the Hyundai i30 has more power AND torque!

    but i admit the curve would be different

    • whitbomb07

      You beat me to it.

      More torque over a wider band, 1800-2200 v 1900-2750.

      No way can this be taken seriously when it has nearly 1lt more capacity but less performance.

      Regards

      Whitbomb07

  • Tom22

    I still think you are far better of buying a used Japanese rival.

    • Stoney!

      not to mention the beaut new VW Amarok when it arrives soon!

      Stoney!

      • freddo

        You missed the point Stonehead….. Toyota’s are relaiable….unlike Volkswagens.

        • Stoney!

          Yeah real reliable, love the spate of problems they have been having lately, not to mention our 4.0 dual cab hilux at work recieving a new motor after constant pinging and sluggish performance, tried different fuel grades to no avail. Also recieved new rotors an pads but the thing still won’t brake properly, new motor has a lot of power but brakes far from up to the task, keep booting the anchors an they lock up! No in between.

          We’ll wait and see the verdict of the Amarok’s reliability I think. Not to mention it’s far superior diesel engines.

          Stoney!

          • David

            Well said Stoney! How can someone seriously say that Toyotas are better than VW’s given the braking, acceleration, and ESP problems that the Toyotas have been having of late…. If they were Ford or Holden cars with all of these issues, the CA website would be full of Aussie-Car bashing know-it-all’s, but the Toyota issue has been vERY quiet…

    • The Oracle

      Yes, I agree. If you need a truck like this and your budget is limited and can’t stretch to a new Japanese ute, then I think a 2nd hand Hilux, Rodeo, Navara etc is a much better idea than a new Mahindra or Great Wall. Apart from the reliability, quality and safety, there are many more service and parts options available too.

  • Able

    What the heck is a Tata Xenon?

  • Prius Lover

    “i cringe to think what my 10 year old ss would score in a current test.”

    VT and VX Commodore models (1997–2002) score a three-star ANCAP rating.

    VY and VZ Commodores (2002–2006, or 2007 for the wagon) score a four-star ANCAP rating.

    • Tom22

      Oh, thats not so bad.

      Thats funny that the VZ and VY score the same, ditto the VT to VX

      over the life span of the VT-VX traction control became available, so was duel airbags

      over the VY to VZ duel airbags evolved into curtain

      • Shak

        Remeber te\he all wise guru’s at ANCAP dont take these things into account. So by their records the VT was just a safe as the VX, and vice cersa, and the VY was just as safe as the VZ. Stupid i know.

    • Jack

      A family member had a head-on in a VY going at 60 or so on an arterial road when some banana pulled out directly in front of them. All OK, safe but shaken. Interesting the VY gets a 4 star rating, well done the VY!

      :)

  • Fat Tony

    ahhhh… at last, a tru-blu Aussie car.

  • Handsome_Al

    Why can’t Mahindra built a Car for its purpose.. Who needs a Carbon Fibre Interior in a work car?? “Ohh look mate, my Dash has a Carbon Fibre in it..” “Ohh marry me darling, coz your car has a carbon fibre in it..” Not Likely to happen and not necessary as well.. Why can’t they just focus on producing a reliable and powerful engine first.. I am not saying that their engine is not reliable or anything, but with that kind of power, you need more of carbon fibre than just in the dash, perhpas the whole body, chassis, and tray.. And now they can stick to whatever engine they already have and it will be powerful enough to tow 1 tonne..

  • Bezza

    Throw in a year’s supply of Vindaloo and I’m in.

    :-)

  • Torque

    Ten Grand too much IMO. Those weird grease/ hubcaps that protrude about 80mm from the rims would not last long at all. It should have rear diff lock standard.
    The combination of an unknown make, unusual styling, pidgin english name, poor safety rating; poor performance when laden; cabin odour(WTF?); turning circle; fit and finish should reflect a drive away price of about $15,000.

  • jinsei

    I just can’t believe Mahindra have ’60 years’ experience in producing motor vehicles… What the hell have they been doing for 6 DECADES? They still are only producing third-world quality poor cars that just manage to go forward. No safety, no reliabilty, no fuel economy, no technology… down right cheap.

    By contrast, Hyundai-Kia are only 43 years old but have already become the world’s 4th largest. Mahindra, though 17 years older, are hardly comparable with the Korean giant in all possible factors…(If you’re not sure, then compare the i-Max with this Mahindra)

    What can make such a dramatic difference?

    • stopwinging

      I think if you look into the history of the companies you mentioned, Mahinda has for most of its history focused on farm/light industrial/light commercial/transport vehicles. Where as the Koreans have focused on cars.

      If you’ve been to the Subcontinent, the roads are quite attrocious, it is stop start traffic every where, and therefore, the engine reliablity and durability for sub continent manufacturers would be fairly strong. Many cars there have high milage, the moto is service service service and run for as long as possible!

  • V8

    A Mahindra dealer in Sydney told me that a year’s supply of CURRY CHICKEN & CHAPATIS is included when buying a new Mahindra. Anyone interested?????

    • rocket_v6

      yup it should be home delivered

  • binladen

    no other car will match an indian driver better than this!
    It smells indian, looks indian. why bother with air-con if u have to drive with windows down to get rid of the “new car smell”. Great wall is much much better than this crap!

  • jinsei

    This car makes Great Wall quite a decent car… Considering GW have received 4-star ANCAP rating, if anybody is after a cheap ute, the Chinese is a far better choice than this bowl of dodgey curry.

    I’m not a big fan of GW either but still they are putting a lot more effort in ensuring the safety/quality of their vehicles.

  • Ricky

    The trip meter button(s) look very cheap – the plastic is just drilled through with no seal around the button itself (from what I can see) – which means dust particles could potentially get through into the speedometer area. Not a huge concern for a normal car, but a work ute in dirty/dusty conditions… I can see that instrument cluster becoming quite dirty in the long term.

  • Ricky

    The USA is getting this truck later this year but their version looks better. It has a proper painted pickup bed, rather than an ugly steel tray. It also comes standard with a 6 speed automatic (Americans won’t even consider manual, especially with trucks). Their version also has a 2.2L diesel, while ours is 2.5L?

  • PoisonEagle

    Oh my goodness gracious me! I hope the Tata Nano ends up here, I love that little thing. It can leave it’s scent behind but.

    • The Oracle

      Tata Nano! Keep the fire extinguisher handy.

      • Sandy

        Oh Shut up .. every car has had some issues..With your mindset every time you sit in Toyota one should order a coffin as well, same is the case with ford and VW so on and so forth…

        Drive a mahindra and you will know how strong this thing is. How can one even compare chinese crap to Mahindra . Put them where they actually belong ( outback ) and lets see who comes out smiling…It will be interesting to see stats on deaths in 3 star and 5 star rated cars…

  • mike

    the 2 star safety rating is for the first generation with no passenger airbag, and abs as option.
    this new model would fair better and would be 3 stars if not more.

    people need to take the price into account, for money you can’t do better, it has poor fit and finish because its built with work in mind not comfort/looks.

    and people saying a gw is better are you serious a small petrol engine pulling 1 ton payload and trailer?? do the math it will barely last the warranty period. the mahindra diesel is low tech and old school but it is a proven peugeot design and will do alot of hard k’s with no drama. the suspension is designed for indian conditions where the manufacturer payload recomendation is ignored and overloading is normal operation.

    i haven’t drivin the pik up but have owned some mahindra tractors back in my farming days and they are bullet proof.

  • Realcars

    The prob is this is 5k overpriced.Talking safety ratings, performance etc this thing takes a Hilux workmate head on especially considering cost saving.

    Reckon ot would have to be super tough to survive in India hence the low stress engine etc.

    Must keep in mind that this is designed as a beast of burden.

  • ohreally

    so 0-100 kmh in just under 19 seconds?
    was this fully loaded or empty?

    a car this slow is a serious driving hazard
    How can you enter a freeway at 45 kmh?

    • http://www.caradvice.com.au/65137/mahindra-pik-up-review-road-test/#comment-213929 Sandy

      Dude you need a ferrari ..Take it outback and break 0-100 speed record… If you need a speed go pay for it .

  • Stevo the Devo

    The first thing you would notice as you drive down the street in one of these is that homeless people will come up to you and give you money.

    • The Oracle

      LOL! I liked that one.

    • Kamahal

      I thought they might come up and accuse you of stealing their overnight accomodation that they picked at the local tip.

  • ron

    since when homeless people started to own brand new trucks. some people like stupid jokes.

  • DieselFan

    jinsei: Stop peddling half truths. Great Wall’s soft roader got the 4-star rating. Both their pickup trucks still have 2-star ANCAP rating. Mahindra 2-star rating is for their previous model without Airbags and ABS. Current model should fare much better. In fact, the previous model in spite of not having Airbags and ABS fared better than Great Wall trucks with them. Mahindra’s cabin held its shape whereas Great Wall’s cabin crumbled slightly due to impact.

  • Mahindra new owner

    I bought a new Mahindra Dual Cab S5 4wd pickup and it is the first time i drive with a 5 gear box . when i drive on the hight way around 100km/hr i use the 5 gear. I am wondering if that is OK? Regards.

  • Troy Stevenson

    Well said DieselFan I have owned a Mahindra Dual Cab 4wd for just on 12 months and it has a 4 star crash rating it was indeed the older models before abs and airbags with the 2 star rating. I am a tradesman so my mahindra is constantly full of tools and whatever else and whilst i admit not the quickest ute around still cruises on 100 to 115kms/h easily and only need to go back to 4th gear on hills. im not in a mad hurry anyway, will get there when i get there but still going to put in a dp chip to give it a bit more oomph. In my 12 mnths of ownership i have done 40,000kms and not an issue has arisen. Goes exceptionally well off road and has oodles of cabin space for 5 large adults. More than anything i liked that it was $28,990 drive away with alloy tradesman tray, towbar and heavyduty bullbar. great value! I also like that its different and not just a run of the mill hilux that every second person has with a $20,000 price difference.

    • Alex

      Well said Troy,have one my self and cant be happier,have had no trouble with over 60k on clock and it just eats all others in the bush.At least this vehicle is built in one country not having parts from all over the world and assembled in one place.As for not having experience in manufacturing ,Mahindra has built and supplied Jeeps for the USA army for over 60years.Must have done something right.

  • jackTrue

    I am not sure why, these guys didn’t introduce the 2.2 CRDI in Australia. I have seen this and drove in KL. This 2.2 is one hell of an engine, which just feels like a petrol engine. So responsive, but still the refinement could be better. I heard from an Indian co worker, this can go on and on for 200k kms with just regular service and spares alone. a quick google also showed they have a new model called, funny though…XUV5oo…

  • sue

    Interesting comments everyone.I havent owned a mahindra but have been thinking about it.Funny to read all the negative posts from people who have never owned one.Bit like saying you hate beans but youve never eaten them.!!!
    !Makes you all sound quiet stupid.

  • Gone fishing

    Have owned 4×4 dual cab for about 18 months. Just under 80k on it. I have the ser2 with air bags, bonnet scoop and so on Returns 9.4lt per 100km and is swift in the city traffic. It’s pretty quiet to drive and comfy on long runs (600km). Tows 2 ton no probs and stops well too with abs and slotted discs standard. Why would you spend $30k on a used hilux with no warranty when $30k gets you brand new + 6 years warranty????? I’m happy.

  • Not Happy Jan

    I have two and the diff has just blown up in one and because the diff oil wasn’t changed every 15000k’s they won’t warrant it. Shit company, shit ute.

  • Daniel Connolly

    I must have gotten the lemon then. Brought the dual cab 4×4 back in May 2011 only to get hit with a plethora of problems.  For a shopping list:

    Was delivered dirty & Muddy with 1/4 tank of fuel driven down from Benalla to Bendigo (was to be truck delivered with full tank of fuel).
    Less than 24 hrs later had to send back due to water in fuel tank, which resulted in a rusty fuel tank that had to be replaced.
    Rear mud flaps rest on back tyres wearing them out.
    Front passenger door seal allows wind & water through.
    1st & 3rd gear crunch when clutch fully engaged.
    Stereo volume auto turns up and down when phones connected via usb (even when phones switched off).
    Speedo gauge fails randomly.
    Rattles behind dash.

    …and all this before the 1st 5000k service. Have had repeated dealings having some of the above repaired more than once (gears, speed, stereo). Had a bunch of service issues with the dealer too (basically sales dept doesn’t talk to the mechanics and vice versa), with the added quip “You get what you pay for” to explain the ongoing issues (WTF?).

    I still now have the odd issue with the stereo & speedo. But I’m so over dealing with it and the dealer (still waiting on a dash part 8 months later) I just want to get rid of it.

    I’ve obviously renamed my Mahindra the Mahindrance.

    Do yourself a favour and buy a Navara instead.

  • Mr_atuln

    READ STOPWINGING COMMENT 
    V8, BINLADEN…..LOL WHAT A STUPID NAME AND ROCKET_V6
    MAHINDRA IS TOP… GREATEST TRACTOR MANUFACTURER IN THE WORLD….

  • Chiren1

    well all this has made everything as clear as mud fpr me

  • Anneshadlow

    Best 4×4 I’ve ever owned, great on and off road. Better than the Toyota I had

  • Odins_run1

    Have own a 2012 model duel cab ute in north Qld, for 12 Months now ,it has done 56,000 ks and the only problems I have with it was the ABS light come on and that was due to a faulty sensor,
    I take the vehicle down to the beach and it goes well in the sand I even Pulled out a Land Cruiser which was Bogged at the beach, He was not impressed that an India 4×4 pulled he out of the sand, but in the end he was happy that I was there, On the road I seat on 110kph and get about 10.5 on a trip and about 9.8 around town, it is the best I have owned for the price I paid,