Car Advice

Holden Cruze cheap to repair says RCAR report

By Matt Brogan |

The Research Council for Automotive Repairs (RCAR) tested the Holden Cruze in an internationally accredited series of low speed bumper tests designed to simulate a minor collision at 10km per hour.

Holden Cruze recorded the best overall results with the ability of the car’s bumper to absorb minor impacts with the ability to calculate the costs of repair.

Robert McDonald is the head of NRMA Insurance Research Centre and is a long time member of RCAR, said the result of the Cruze’s bumper test was a good example of how bumper design can minimise damage in low speed collisions.

“The Cruze is likely to be driveable and easier to repair after many common low speed
collisions that would result in other vehicles being towed away,” Mr McDonald said.
“Following on from the Cruze’s good performance in the ANCAP safety crash tests, where it
earned a maximum five star rating, this result demonstrates crash safety and bumper
protection don’t have to be mutually exclusive.”

Mr McDonald said the test caused less than $3,000 of damage to the Cruze which is 12.9 per cent of the vehicle’s purchase price, less than a third of the repair cost of the worst car tested.

Holden Cruze

Holden Vehicle Integration and Performance Manager, Scott Heywood said the Cruze was designed with affordability and safety as the main focus of the global development program.

“While of course we hope our customers are never in an accident, if they are it’s comforting
to know that repairing a Cruze is extremely affordable,” Mr Heywood said.
“This is a great result and one that goes to prove you don’t have to sacrifice safety for great
“The result should also help to reduce the long-term insurance costs for Cruze owners.
“The equation with Cruze is pretty simple – it’s a vehicle with a high level of specification, a
five star safety rating and low operating costs.
“In the case of Cruze you really can have your cake and eat it too.”

Cruze is one of the safest cars in its class with a five star safety rating and a host of active and passive safety systems. Active and passive safety systems that are standard across the Cruze range are Electronic Stability Control; Traction control; Anti-Lock Brakes; Brake Assist; Electronic Brakeforce Distribution; Six airbags including driver, front passenger, front side and curtain airbags; and, Seat belt reminders, retractor and lap pretensioners with seatbelt load limiters.

2009_Holden_Cruze-111

Holden launched Cruze in June 2009 and sold 2,183 in October making it the sixth best selling passenger car in Australia.


 
  • Car Fanatic

    More information on the other cars please so we can see just how good this figure is, cause if I’m not mistaken, NRMA did this in 2007 for small and Medium cars and found the Corolla, Focus, Astra and Mazda 3 all came in under 3,000 dollars and less than 12.6% of their purchase price. Infact Corolla and Focus were under 2500 dollars to repair. More information please!

    • Safety Frist

      NRMA January 24th 2008
      [Extract news latter bad bumper designs]
      “We are however really pleased with the performance of the Toyota Corolla, as the repair cost of this vehicle after a low speed collision, was just $1,019 or 4.4 per cent as a percentage of its purchase price,” Mr McDonald said [end Quote]

      Seems the Cruze isn’t that advanced after all…. Admittedly the Cruze is 5* rated so maybe the above line about safety and repair costs is incorrect…? (Just a thought)

  • jon

    Its because they are cheap, well it is a GM product

  • matt

    we recently took one of these on a work trip from canberra to sydney and it was one of the most gutless drives any of us have had in quite a while. the auto was super slow and the cruise control refused to do as it was told. Add these issues with the poor visibility from the front pillars and we got a really poor experience.

    • Dank

      Should have paid the extra to get the commodore…4 cylinders are like that mate

      • Frenchie

        When you say us, do you mean there was 3-4 of you in a four cylinder car?

        • matt

          There were three of us and we were on a budget, we didn’t have much have much of a load either. I understand that 4 cyls dont’ compare to a good 6 cyl but surely such a “modern” car should be able to handle that.

  • Robin Graves

    Its a Daewoo, cheap to build = cheap to repair. This article smells a bit of advertising from what the other comments are saying about Corolla. Maybe Holden’s WBT division (Wheels Buttering Division) has increased its market share?

  • Daewoo driver

    Not true, I have a 2000 Daewoo Matiz and the performance and automatic gearbox are nothing but superb.

    • toxic_horse

      Lol
      My GF has a manual Matiz, and while it is a great city runabout car, the 900cc 3 cyl engine is hardly what i would call superb. I can’t imagine what it would be like with a auto!!

      • Car Fanatic

        You mean your boyfriend has a Matiz, could just see you two in it, peep peep!!! out of our way, we just must get to the shops for carrot cake!!!!

        • toxic_horse

          Yea and after that ill grab my 5ltr HZ and do a burnout in your front yard.

          • Car Fanatic

            Yes you and your boyfriend burning rubber. Your proud to own a hot pink HZ??

          • PSImonkey

            My HR holden has a blown 186 that does standing 12 second quarters and I remember crashing that once, cost me $50 for a new bumper at the wreckers, reckon thats about 3% of it’s price so that makes the cruze look pretty crap. I fitted air bags out of a VR berlina to it to, so it’s probably safer as well!!

          • Car Fanatic

            You two Holden boys should get together and talk about all things scum.
            Might be hard to get together, who’s gunna mind the Pizza shop for ya.

            HR and HZ, two men at there car ownership peaks, puff those hairy chests out boys

  • http://www.bidmyservices.com Elise Walker

    Really? I didn’t know that. Thanks for this post! We’re actually car-shopping and since I have a one-year-old, safety is the greatest concern.

  • Safety Frist

    Before you buy then see if you can get a vehicle set up for ISOFIX child seats… Not available in Australia yet but I believe they will be complied next year. Far safer having a seat properly fixed into a vehicle rather than rellying on webbing straps to secure it…..
    And make sure you sit your child as far away as possible from the side curtain airbags…. Center of the rear seat only!!!!

    • Robin Graves

      i30 has isofix child restraints in the rear seat. Dont know if any others do – probably all the Euros?

  • Shak

    An indeoendent body says something good about Holden and people still bag Holden. When will you ever be happy.

  • Frenchie

    The Cruze has isofix anchor points. Regarding curtain airbags a child seat with wide wing sides should protect a child. Look up Euroncap as they may have some videos on this.

    • Clive

      Can anyone tell me where the rear anchor points are located? Are they on the roof or in the boot? Because if they are located in the boot, that would take up boot space and decrease space for things like prams. Thank you.