Car Advice

Toyota claims Prius will be Australia’s greenest car

By David Twomey |

Toyota has stretched the latest fuel efficiency tests of its new Prius a little to claim, “It’s official. The new-generation Prius will be Australia’s greenest car when it is launched in July this year.”.

The claim is based on figures released by Toyota Europe were local testing has shown that the third-generation Prius will emit just 89 grams of CO2 per kilometre and can travel 100km using only 3.9 litres of petrol.

That fuel consumption figure may only stand until Ford hits the market with its extremely frugal ECOnetic version of the new Fiesta.

Using a combination of the latest generation common rail diesel engine, together with a carefully selected list of features that have been engineered to reduce fuel economy and CO2 emissions, Fiesta ECOnetic has achieved a fuel consumption rating of 3.7L/100km however the CO2 output is higher at 98g/km.

fiesta-econetic

The Toyota figures, revealed at the Geneva motor show, are from the European combined cycle, which, Toyota Australia says, is extremely close to the Australian standard.

Local Toyota officials are confident the new Prius will have the lowest greenhouse and air pollution emissions of any car sold in Australia, making it the highest-ranking car on the Federal Government’s Green Vehicle Guide.

09toymims-15hr

Current-generation Prius was the top-ranked vehicle for more than four years with fuel economy of 4.4 litres/100km and CO2 of 106g/km.

Early this year, its CO2 count was pipped by one gram by the Smart ForTwo, a two-seat car with a three-cylinder and a 1.0-litre petrol engine, albeit one that uses premium unleaded fuel.

image52201_b

Toyota defends the current Prius, by saying it is a full-size five-seat car that uses regular unleaded fuel for its 1.5-litre, four-cylinder engine.

The petrol engine in the next-generation Prius grows to 1.8-litres, helping to boost power from the combined petrol-electric Hybrid Synergy Drive system by more than 20 per cent to around 100kW.

090109pr005hr

Despite the increased output, the European figures represent a 14 per cent improvement in CO2 emissions with fuel consumption lowered by 10 per cent.

The only other petrol car under 100 g/km sold in Europe is another Toyota, the diminutive four-seat iQ.

Cabrio and coupe models of the Smart ForTwo achieve 88g/km with a tiny 800cc diesel engine, but those versions are not sold in Australia.

Toyota Australia’s senior executive director sales and marketing David Buttner said the European figures confirm the strong environmental credentials for the next-generation Prius.

“Current Prius customers already know they can drive an environmentally sound car without sacrificing space, comfort or performance,” Mr Buttner said.

08toymims-36hr

“The next-generation car takes a further leap forward with an improved Hybrid Synergy Drive system that increases performance at the same time as cutting emissions to levels never before seen in Australia.

In a swipe at the current popularity of diesel cars in Australia, Mr Buttner said it was important to note that none of the five-star top performers in the Green Vehicle Guide are diesel vehicles, even where their fuel consumption is relatively good.

He said the Guide made it clear that the contribution to air pollution by diesel vehicles is generally higher than that of comparative petrol or LPG vehicles.


 
  • Robin Graves

    Green? What about the knock-on effects of producing, storing and disposing of the batteries? Mining Lithium etc? I’m no expert, but I bet its a lot harsher on the environment long term than a econo diesel.

  • Sam

    Im a bit confused about the increase in the size of the petrol engine. I was convinced the way hybrids should evolve is by having more powerful and efficient electric engines and batteries whist sizing down the petrol engine. Also, Toyota, why build a Camtry Hybrid whe you already sell a 5 seat sedan in the Prius? What about a Hybrid Rav4 or HiLux ute? I dream of the day that a Hybrid car is the object of my affection. I cant help but think I will be dreaming for a while.

  • NotTheStig

    Nothing mentioned about the carbon footprint of a Prius then ?
    (all those batteries…)

  • Stephen

    Gents,

    I’m wondering what sort of fuel economy the Prius would get, say, from Sydney to Melbourne? What’s Toyota’s claim?

    Cheers,

    Stephen

  • Simon

    I’d like to see a fully laden prius vs a similar diesel also fully laden. Not only would the prius be extremely slow in comparison, it’s fuel consumption would jump dramatically. Then the emissions would also level out.

  • S

    I agree realcars, Hydrogen seems the best way forward. But even then its apparently very energy exhaustive to produce. Especially in a country like Australia where coal is the main energy source.

    The less we depend on fossil fuels the better, Diesel and Hybrid allow us to do this. Both petrol and diesel have their downfalls. Petrol in CO2 and fuel economy and diesel in the amount of particulate matter and nitrogen oxide they produce (which have raised quite a lot of health concerns), even with the filters that the europeans and japanese manufacturers use Pete (yes the Japanese do make clean diesels too, we just don’t see them in Australia as much). Hyundai in fact has a very good range of ‘clean’ diesels in Australia (and Toyota, Honda, Mazda, Nissan etc in Europe).

  • Pauly

    HANG ON!!! What about the Mini Cooper Diesel that’s launching in Australia around the same time as the new prius? That was going to be the most fuel efficent car in Australia and Its actually a damn good car to drive and own too!

  • Pauly

    Forgot to mention the Mini Cooper Diesel is going to be ALOT cheaper to buy then a prius too. The money you save can go towards filling it up, and your still coming out ontop over a prius.

  • S

    NotTheStig – The article talks about emissions, not the cost. That’s what I was talking about. Both are good cars for their intended purpose.

  • RoFlmaTiC

    Predominately city driving: take a hybrid;
    Predominately highway driving: take a diesel.

    That is all.

  • Glen

    Ive always said Fuel Cells are the way to go for an eco friendly car. Hybrids are a stop gap solution which in reality doesn’t work as advertised. Yes they may better in fuel economy but environmental impact, pah-lease.

    Hydrogen is not that hard to get, its called electrolysis. You do it in high school chemistry where you put electrodes in water which separate the oxygen and hydrogen molecules. And before anyone complains about the lack of water in this country, it can be done with salt water too. Even then the only byproduct produce from fuel cells is water. 100 years ago it was thought to produce petrolium products took a lot of energy and time but over the years the process has been refined. The same will happen with hydrogen.

  • Frontman

    I’d really love to see Ford do a hybrid Mondeo, along the lines of the Hybrid Fusion released in the States. Looks like a normal car, can carry a full size family and isas econimical as the Prius.
    Still agree with most though that Hydrogen is the only real green alternative. We need a stronger push from companies like BMW (7 series), Mecedes Benz (E Class), Ford (Edge) Honda (HFV) and Hyundai (can’t remember the name of theirs) to get the goevernments to sort out the infrastructure and get their cars to the market.

  • boc

    People shouldn’t be knocking others as fools for purchasing a Prius. Purchasing a Prius is helping the environment.

    It’s not because it’s somehow greener (probably a wash when you include all factors), it’s because a Prius is the strongest way to tell the market that we want greener cars.

    How many more years longer would it have taken for us to get all these emission standards and targets if a car like the Prius (along with it’s marketing) didn’t exist?

    Prius was the first viable alternative and got the ball rolling for greener cars.

  • Dan

    Agreed, they’re definately the leaders in green cars. It’s only a matter of time until the rest will copy toyota, as usual.

  • Falcodore

    I know for a fact that Mazda will not follow Toyota down the garden pa… i mean hybrid path, as Mazdas president has stated they see hybrids,along with anyone else with half a brain, as a stop-gap solution. Which is why they are going the hydrogen route.

    And they have the perfect engine for the application, the rotary.

  • RoFlmaTiC

    Regarding the comments above about the mini cooper D…

    In the UK this car does not even come with a/c as standard, it is a 600 pound option which brings the price of the diesel cooper to almost as much as a cooper s.

    Now in Australia the cooper s cars start from 39990 (excluding govt charges etc)… compared to the prius which is 37400 excluding govt charges.

    So I highly doubt the cooper d will be “alot cheaper” than the prius.

  • Jimbo

    Agreed the Mini is a terrible comparison.

    The Mini Cooper D is just a tarted up, overpriced smaller version of a Peugeot 207 Diesel. Sure the 207 is a little less economical but it will still be on par with a Prius and it only costs $27K compared to the others. Plus the 207 comes as a wagon that is almost on par with a Prius for space at $29k!

  • Frontman

    It is interesting to compare the Prius with other Hybrids available (whilst admitting they are not in Asutralia) but when doing comparisons it shows how far behind Toyota technology is getting. Okay by now we all know that I am Blue Oval biased, so I’ll use two of their vehicles as comparisons. The Fusion Hybrid is quoted by Ford as being a 38mpg family sized vehicle, yet several respected publications have returned far better in general driving. Figures of 41 > 43mpg combined with a usefull amount of space and proper driving dynamics are being quoted regularly. One Newspaper even quoted that they returned 51mpg in a weeks worth of LA traffic driving!! All this in a vehicle that does it’s job without screeming out to the rest of the world (in way of looking different) about it’s credentials. Also Fords Hybrid Escape has been voted best Hybrid SUV in the states in terms of economy and driving etc.
    But, and it’s a major one as I see it, Ford are like a lot of other companies in this sector. They are not content to rest on their laurels, they are actively seeking new drive systems. They, like BMW, M/Benz, VWAG, Honda & Hyundai / Kia have active road going versions of Hydrogen powered vehicles undergoing tests in Germany where (although extremely small) there is supporting infrastructure.
    I am not against Toyota and their efforts, it is the marketing rhetoric that surrounds them that I find abrassive. On the “allaboutprius” site they are even quoting the “World First” fitment of Photvolcaic (spelling sorry) cells to the 2010 Prius sunroof to run the a/cond fans whilst parked. Bzzz Sorry, Mazda had them in the really good looking 929 of the 90′s and even then Mazda didn’t claim them as a first so I’d reckon that someone else was first.
    The next five years will be very intersting with the development of smaller more efficient and greener Petrol, Diesel and LPG engines as well as the Hybrid and plug and play brigades, and hydrogen is still comming.
    I think we will find, particularly for Australia where we tend to drive greater distances, that hybrid will remain the vocal one but the alternatives will outsell and out perform for a very long time.

  • http://internode.on.net Pete

    I think the problem with diesels not getting into the top of the Government’s Green Guide is because the scores for these vehicles are penalised (handicapped) for their particulates and nitrogen oxide output but there is no such penalty applied to the whole of life of hybrids.

    People keep talking about hybrids being “best” for city driving – as I mentioned above either carsguide.com or drive.com had a Jetta diesel long term (6 months), driving predominantly in the city, and they said it returned around 5L/100km – better than the “hybrid” they had for a similar time and driving experience.

    Give me a Golf diesel over a Prius anyday – cheaper, faster, better to drive and not as damaging.

  • Neo Utopia

    Australia’s green vehicle guide is internaly flawed, Germany’s Fraunhofer Institute is the world’s best whole of life-cycle analysis accreditor. I would like to see a comparison between the next generation volkswagen polo blue and the next generation prius. I know the polo or a Eco fiesta would have a dramaticaly less impact on both the environment and ECOLOGY!

  • Daniel

    It is amazing how people keep repeating the same myths over and over again, especially things like the Range Rover having a lower carbon footprint than a Hybrid.
    I attended the AutoCRC conference on Thursday and there was a lot of discussion around Environmentally friendly vehicles. A lot of the discussion in the serious sectors of the industry are focusing on the “Well to Wheel” analysis of Carbon footprint. As mentioned, hydrogen does not score well when non renewable electricity is used to produce it. You also have to consider the construction of the infrastructure for the distribution network. Hydrogen is not an easy substance to store or transport either. I worry that the main people promoting hydrogen as the answer to all our problems are using it as a smoke screen to keep the status quo for as long as possible.
    Renewable Hydrocarbon Fuels don’t seem to get the attention that they deserve either, as they have the possibility of carbon sinks during production to help offset the carbon emissions in use. They can also use the current distribution and transportation infrastructure.
    Of the current fuels and vehicles available currently, Hybrids produce the least carbon emissions in their class. When considering “green” vehicles, this is surely the most important measure (and not fuel economy).

  • http://skyline The Salesman

    Did i hear a rumor that the Australian government might start charging stamp duty based on emissions?

  • http://skyline The Salesman

    Bret,
    “Sorry don’t care. It’s not a vehicle that suits my needs or wants.”

    Exactly, why can Toyota not roll out hybrid for all models in Australia? And yes i know they are already available O/S. Surely the hybrid Kluger can tow?

  • http://skyline The Salesman

    Dan,
    Lexus does Hybrids for all models other than IS and SC. And those Hybrids can definitely tow!

    True, but the affordability of a Lexus is out of reach for most. Can you tow with a Hydrogen car?

  • Dan

    Like I said, it makes no difference whether the engine is petrol, diesel, hybrid, hydrogen, or electric. If it makes enough power, and has the appropriate weight to tow, type of engine makes no difference.

  • Bavarian Missile (.)(.)

    From what I found out these are the reasons.

    1 – the drivetrain\’s electric motor slip control will shut down the drivetrain when the HSD computer detects an overload.

    2- the Prius rear suspension and chassis is not designed to support the tongue weight of a trailer.

  • Simon

    Torque is the key factor in towing and this is where diesels shine.
    Engine type does matter because, for example, you would not be likely to use a rotary engined car for towing. They can generate lots of power but not much torque relative to their displacement and mass.