Mahindra XUV500 earns four-star ANCAP safety rating | CarAdvice

Car Advice

Mahindra XUV500 earns four-star ANCAP safety rating

By Tim Beissmann
FIND DEALS

The all-new Mahindra XUV500 seven-seater has earned a four-star safety rating from the Australasian New Car Assessment Program (ANCAP) despite a number of disappointing measurements in the local crash test.

The Indian-built mid-sized SUV scored 26 points out of 37 in the crash test, including 10 out of 16 in the frontal offset crash test and the default 16 out of 16 that is awarded to all SUVs in the side impact component.

ANCAP’s report explains the XUV500’s passenger compartment “lost structural integrity” in the frontal test, and says “protection from serious leg injury was poor for the driver due to excessive rearward movement of the brake pedal”.

The crash test caused a rupture in the fuel line – apparently caused by contact with the driveshaft – while the exhaust pipe contacted the fuel tank but did not cause a puncture.

The test also caused the tailgate to open, although Mahindra has since developed a software upgrade to eliminate the problem.

The Mahindra XUV500 will be fitted with six airbags and electronic stability control as standard when it goes on sale in Australia later this month.

The four-star result puts Mahindra Australia’s first passenger vehicle on par with a number of other SUVs from better-established brands, including the Jeep Compass and Grand Cherokee and the Mini Countryman.

The rating also matches that awarded to the Chinese-built Great Wall X200/X240, which is destined to be one of the XUV500’s key competitors.

The four-star ANCAP rating is the best crash test score achieved by the Indian manufacturer, previously earning two stars for the Pik-Up dual-cab ute in 2008 and 2011 and three stars for the upgraded model earlier this year.

The Mahindra XUV500 remains long way off the pace of the safest medium SUVs in the country, however, with the Volvo XC60 (36.53 points), Audi Q5 (35.21) and the Kia Sportage (35.1) achieving the most impressive scores to date.

ANCAP also announced the Mazda CX-5, BMW 3-Series and Honda Civic hatch have been awarded the maximum five-star safety rating on the back of strong performances in crash tests conducted by overseas affiliate Euro NCAP.


 

  • Ima_Hogg

    Well thats a plus for Mahindra somthing to try and sell this car with. Should be a 5 though.

    • Smart US

       great news… i dont care how many idian stars this car have for
      safety… i carry cross and lucky stone with me and garlic to repel
      vampires among holy water from local church… i believe this car has
      lucky Karma – (Car-ma if you wish)… this car protects every simple
      soul and bring it to heaven…

      • Ima_Hogg

        Learn some grammar and spelling please.

        • Smart US

           too exited… put my deposit down for nice mild-hot mahindra w basmati rice… and also got free booking w local clairvoyant to check my car-ma… she was talking a lot about reincarnation… cant see why??? the car has all the Bollywood stars…

          • Ima_Hogg

            Defiantly one of the weirdest comments on this site for a while. It isn’t even funny. 

          • Grammar_Police

            Learn some spelling please. Defiantly? 

      • Shak

        What?

      • Captain Nemo

         Stop drinking your bong water champ. I can’t understand your posts

        • Smart US

           start drinking your water champ… and dont mess up with my mahindra car-ma

      • Johaan

        u r nugging coz  its an Indian car!!! purely thats the reason! if this peice stickered made in germany u wont even ask for the star!!!!

        • Smart US

           i think this car is as good as any bollywood movie star – and its got 4 so whats the problem mate… lets drive nice mahindra

          • aus

            here copy paste from ANCAP website ………………..Crash test results for All 4 star rated vehicles (155 results).. ….and you copy paste same comment on another website .stop looking mahindra everywhere to comment on net

  • turboooo679

    still pretty good seing as a jeep grand cherokee and the RR evoque got 4 stars

    • Smart US

       they got 4 stars but different reasons… jeep for poor pedestrian safety… having ruptured fuel lines and exhaust pipe is asking for explosion… IMHO

  • TG

    Should be less than 4 stars if this nasty thing causes your tibia and fibula to explode through your patella while you’re holding the brake pedal down in a frontal stack.

  • Shak

    This is one of those rating that is a bit confusing, and will be sure to confuse the general public. How can it achieve four starts if the passenger cell lost structural integrity or if the brake pedal has the potential to cause serious injury to the driver?

    • Smart US

       exactly…

      • figo

        dude relaxxx,we get it,u dont like mahindra and ur not buying it…..calm the @#$% down.its like ur trying to make up other peoples mind.

        • Johaan

          Thats true! he hate any thing about Indians!!!!!

  • Ghill

    10 out of 16 for the frontal impact is pretty poor. good for the 1990s 

    • jethro

      great wall is 9.48 out of 16

  • SM

    “The passenger compartment held itsshape reasonably well in the offset crash test however the structuresupporting the trans-fascia tube had partially separated from the A-pillarresulting in a structural modifier. The brake pedal moved rearwards by 258mm and upwards 135 mm. The steering wheel hub moved 45 mmrearward, 135 mm upward and 8 mm sideways. The A-pillar moved 18 mmrearwards.”shape reasonably well in the offset crash test however the structuresupporting the trans-fascia tube had partially separated from the A-pillarresulting in a structural modifier. The brake pedal moved rearwards by 258mm and upwards 135 mm. The steering wheel hub moved 45 mmrearward, 135 mm upward and 8 mm sideways. The A-pillar moved 18 mmrearwards.”Cut and pasted directly from the ANCAP full report, and this is good enough for 4 stars apparently??Seems that as long as you make a car with enough airbags that somehow negates the need for designing proper structural integrity. I recall that when the Q7 was fist tested and exhibited deformation of the floor and minor seperation of one the the welding seams and awarded only 4 stars there was shouting from the galleries that it was a failure and boo hoo for German engineering.So if I understand this correctly a Q7 is no safer than a car whose passenger compartment holds its shape “reasonably well”. Provided you “reasonably” love your family then its all good. 

    • Golfschwein

      I remember reading something even more horrific about a Nissan Patrol many years ago. Don’t know the series name, but it was the old square-cut one from the early or mid nineties. The floor ruptured, the brake pedal came up to crotch height, the A-pillar went all vertical and so much more. Thank God everyone’s come a long way since then.

  • save it for the track

    And there be the problem with the current ‘star’ ratings. One needs to look closer at the detail to see the truth.

    • SM

      Absolutely spot on. People will see cars such as this in the delear yards with 4 stars plasted across the windscreen and potentially think, “hey that’s pretty good” and not necessarily understand nor appreciate the devil in the detail so to speak. There is a real fundamental problem when cars achieving high 35′s and 36′s in the overall ratings are apparently only one star higher up the safety order.

  • MM

    You won’t see too many of these in Dandenong.

  • Travis_2445

    not bad result for Mahindra, 4 stars are as good as Jeep GC

  • Covert

    You know what, I dont agree with this 4 Star Rating if its still unsafe for me and my family.
    Accidents will happen, whether its your fault or someone else’s error.. so when we are on the roads, choose the safest you can afford and do drive carefully.

  • Johaan

    dont buy it !  go for a prado!! there are people goin to try this car!!!! shouting just BECOZ.. its Indian!!! curry good but cant accept an Indian!!!!! no good!!!! xo.. xo.. kool!

  • Johaan

    Ozzi s proud of their holden (GM) .but purely american! we need to start make our own cars!! see indian, korean, chinese all making their own cars!  why cant we???

    • Shak

      We do. Falcon, Commodore, Territory, Cruze, Camry and the Aurion.

      • Johaan

        Falcon – ford America , Commadore ! It’s Chevrolet lumina! Territory! Again ford! Mate do some research!!!!

        • Smart US

           you had a spicy curry in the morning… what are you talking about??? stop using indian google!!!

          • figo

            watttttt,indian google?i thought google was google.ur soo goddamn passionate about hating this car,i like it.

          • JooberJCW

            Could be a man traumatised from a visit to India…

          • Johaan

            mate, I just said a fact that our holden is an international asembler! i just wanted to say we need to produce (not assemble) our own car (Aussi)!!! See captiva! a korean daewoo suv! cruz! again korean, astra .. opel germany, barina.. agin opel, we made barina from suzuki swift once!! u probs hit by an Indian thats made u so against of this indian entry!!!! kool mate!!!

        • Golfschwein

          Johaan, you simply must do some research before posting. Commodore was a Holden first and a Chevrolet second. It was designed here, as is Falcon. I shouldn’t even be writing this stuff, as this is kindergarten car knowledge.

  • Isis

    Judging by the above. Photo that impact looks pretty bad..

  • Chubbs

    Agree this is a poor result and points out what is wrong with the star system. The thing that annoys me is that everyone is quick to slap this car down but the reviews of jeep cherokee are glowing.  The jeep scores 9.95/16 in its frontal test.  The drivers seat essentially broke off! And this from a car that starts with the advantage of a merc platform.  To me the difference is the jeep looks good and has some towing/off road cred vs an ugly car from an emerging manufacturer, so we interpret their crash results to suit our biases.