Mercedes-Benz E-Class Review: farewell long-term report | CarAdvice

Car Advice

Mercedes-Benz E-Class Review: farewell long-term report

MERCEDES-BENZ E250
By David Zalstein and David Holmes
FIND DEALS

December Update
David Zalstein

With our long-termer Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI doing the vast majority of its kilometres nestled within Sydney’s notorious traffic, our editor asked if I would kindly mind putting some kays on it over the weekend and stretch its legs in an attempt to get a more balanced fuel consumption figure than the 10.2 litres per 100km currently displayed on the trip computer.

In kind, I respond the way any normal Melbourne boy living in Sydney who had just been handed the keys to a $114,405 Mercedes-Benz would; I pack a bag and get ready to drive to Melbourne.

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - 12

Clocking up hundreds of kilometres in a dirty Mercedes-Benz simply isn’t right – particularly a black one – so a wash is the first port of call. Having the Obsidian Black metallic finish looking its best, the second box to tick is the tyres.

Tyre pressure is a vital detail often overlooked by most road users, yet can have a profound affect on tyre performance as well as wear and fuel economy. According to the Mercedes-Benz E250’s door panel tyre information, the German manufacturer recommends 33psi for the front tyres and 35psi for the rear (with three occupants and a small amount of luggage).

Our car had dropped only slightly to 32psi front and 34psi rear. Given the long highway drive ahead, and based on the sworn oath of some very experienced and well-trusted tyre fitters, we decide on an even 38psi for all four Pirelli P Zero tyres fitted to the Merc’s optional 18-inch five-spoke alloy wheels.

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - 13

With these necessities completed we are ready to head south. The trip is a great opportunity to not only spend a fair chunk of time in the car over a few days, but also to drive the diesel-powered Mercedes-Benz E250 in its element, throwing out hundreds of kilometres across major highways.

As the big Merc’s impressive attention to detail, features list, and technology have all been mentioned in the updates proceeding this one, this report, although they may be touched on, is more about the drive.

Leaving Sydney with a full tank of diesel, the trip computer for Trip A is zeroed, giving us a clean slate for the trek ahead. The starting stats read as follows: 3142km travelled, 124.43 hours of driving, an average speed of 25km/h, and the previously mentioned 10.2L/100km average fuel consumption.

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - 1

Once you get past the E250′s long start-up procedure – push the start button with your foot on the brake pedal; select drive from the column shifter; release the foot brake; then go – the diesel Benz is a damn good place to be and a properly good drive.

The super-comfortable ride is compliant over small and large road imperfections, but the engineers at Mercedes have excelled by not allowing this supple feeling to ever get in the way of driver feedback. Be it on highways or around suburban streets, the Mercedes-Benz E250 never feels sloppy or disconnected. The brakes can feel a little doughy but this is mostly forgivable as being part and parcel of driving a luxury four-door, five-seat baby limousine, where smoothness and comfort are the priority.

The E250′s 150kW/500Nm 2.1-litre four-cylinder turbo diesel is torquey down low and is happy trundling along on the light side of 2000rpm, even up slight inclines and over crests. Despite the small capacity engine having to shove along 1735kg, power is delivered supremely easily and without fuss – particularly at highway cruising speeds or when overtaking proves necessary.

A quick stop 5hrs 42min in for a drink and an ‘un-drink’ sees 636km gone for the net result of 5.9L/100km and an average speed of 112km/h – far better numbers already. We keep on truckin’ towards Melbourne with a renewed sense of environmentalism and a significantly lighter bladder.

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - 4

There’s a lot to like when sitting at the helm of the Mercedes. The look, feel and smell of the leather seats, the wall-to-wall (or door-to-door) wizz-bang techno-gadgetry that fills the car, the safety features, and that truly spectacular (albeit optional) Harman/Kardon audio system. But one thing that impresses even more is the car’s visibility.

The Mercedes-Benz E250 is not a small car, and yet the vision while driving is excellent. Even without relying on the optional lane keeping systems and reversing camera, and standard parking sensors, blind spots are limited and being aware of your place on the road is a doddle.

Up front the apparent space gives the impression of steering the car from a lounge room. It’s got ample head, shoulder and leg room for two girthy executives in the rear – or three slightly slimmer civilians – and its boot is deep enough that if something slid to the back, a miners hat with attached light would prove useful.

At 7hrs 57min we arrive at my Melbourne destination: 871km, 110km/h average speed, and 6.0L/100km average fuel consumption. Leg one is done leaving us with dead-on a quarter of a tank of fuel still on board.

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - 2

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - 3

After two days driving around Melbourne it’s time to return back to the land of the bridge and the Opera House. Another refuel to the brim and we are away. Figures: 4210km travelled, 136.27 hours, 31km/h average speed, and average fuel consumption has already dropped a full litre from when we left Sydney to 9.2L/100km.

A slightly slower, more conservative run back – with more vehicles to contend with – nets us a return trip equalling 862km over 8hrs 23min with an average speed of 103km/h for a very impressive fuel consumption figure of 5.1L/100km.

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - 6

This second trip also leaves us with more than a quarter of a tank worth of fuel left, leaving us pondering the idea of not only Melbourne to Sydney on one tank of fuel, but there and back on one tank – a challenge no doubt.

Final figures for the Benz: 5072km travelled, 144.51 hours, 35km/h average speed, and average fuel consumption almost dropping another litre finishing on 8.5L/100km.

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - 8

For a comfortable long-haul vehicle packed with entertainment, safety and technology, that’s easy to drive and easy to live with, the $114k-plus Mercedes-Benz E250 is a terrific example of why the Germans have been dominating this market for so many years.

July Update
David Holmes

It’s more than two months since I first became acquainted with our Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI long-termer, so it’s time for an update on how the driving experience is going. And just a reminder that, as the CEO of CarAdvice, I’m reviewing this from an executive’s perspective rather than a road tester’s.

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - Front Side

I have to admit I was sceptical when my editor told me this rather sizeable luxury car was powered firstly by a diesel, and secondly by one only 2.1 litres in size. Yet there’s plenty of torque that will get you out of the blocks briskly when needed and allow for easy cruising.

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - Driving

The handling is precise but is a little heavy if cornering hard and best suited to a more relaxed steer than an aggressive line. If you enjoy driving more enthusiastically then this is probably not the car for you. If on the other hand you like to feel safe, even at highway speeds, this car should be on your shortlist.

At 110km/h it feels like you are driving to the local shops, there is virtually no road noise, the suspension is perfectly tuned for highway cruising and all the interior functions are easily accessible from the steering wheel controls.

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - Steering Wheel

For me, the cruise control function could replace the shift paddles as changing cruise control settings is a little laboured due to the position of the control lever and the diesel automatic gearbox, in my view, doesn’t need a sports paddle option.

While the diesel configuration in this E-Class isn’t the most powerful in its segment, it does mean you can feel you are doing your part for the environment. The Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI has a 4-star Green Rating (8.0/10 Green House), which is not common in the large luxury car segment.

Daily commutes aren’t helping fuel consumption, however, with the E250 CDI’s trip computer revealing that our average 10.2L/100km is exactly double the model’s official rating of 5.1L/100km. I must point, however, that I have had the engine stop/start system disengaged as, while it can save some fuel, I’m not yet convinced by such systems. There are many times in traffic when you are stationary for only a moment or two, and it seems pointless for the engine to switch off for those occasions.

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - Engine

The key feeling for me while driving this car is the sense of safety. That’s helped by the intelligent headlights, that adjust when you are turning corners to illuminate the peripheral field of vision, and the lane change warning indicators. These combine with the not so obvious safety features to provide an exceptional command of the road.

The driving visibility is also very good with no really evident blind spots.

As you would (and should) expect these days, this Mercedes-Benz has many safety features including ABS (anti-lock braking), Brake Assist, Emergency Braking Display, and electronic stability control to help stabilise the vehicle under critical handling situations. There are even headrests that adjust in the case of an accident to reduce head and neck injury.

That attention to safety detail can be found throughout the E-Class line-up that ranges from $80,000 all the way to $250,000 for the top-of-the-range E63 AMG. So there are multiple configurations within the E-series to suit all driving styles.

Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI Long-termer - Driveway

The E250 CDI is one of the more sedate models, but after 2296km I’m still appreciating its blend of luxurious interior and pleasant road manners.

May Update
David Holmes

Having read Alborz’s Mercedes-Benz E250 review I jumped at the chance when our editor asked if I would like to cover this E-Class diesel from an executive perspective. The brief: to look at what it is actually like to own a Mercedes-Benz luxury car that’s powered by a small, four-cylinder engine.

Mercedes-Benz_E250_Front

Over the next few months I will be providing a different perspective on this $101,005 luxury car rather than our usual expert-based review. This is deliberately less technical as I am not an expert motoring journalist like the rest of the CarAdvice team; I am an average driver and will review this car from a potential owners’ perspective.

Mercedes-Benz_E250_Rear

First Impressions
Me: This is a big car, much larger than my regular car and its familiar Mercedes shape is a little intimidating at first glance. You can trace the E-Class origins back nearly a century to the 1930s so this famous German manufacturer has had plenty of time to refine this car with the engineering excellence you would expect. I can remember driving in my grandfather’s W123 Diesel (240D, I think it was) when I was a kid, and while the exterior design on this E250 is definitely modern, the family resemblance is still evident.

After a few days in the car all the technology that is jammed in changes from being daunting to being part of the driver’s DNA. How did I ever live without parking sensors, lane change alerts, a pristine sound system and automated everything. It’s the little things, the attention to detail, that makes this car special.

For example, the lighting system, from the Intelligent headlight system that senses your environment (country, city, cornering, parking) and adjusts the beam angle and width accordingly through to the subtle low light accents in the cabin and right down to the sidesteps to make it easy to find your way around the car in the dark.

The kids: This is a massive car. The boys struggle to reach the seat in front (awesome news for dad – no more kicks in the back), but they love the space. In fact, my eldest has told everyone about the new car and seems to know more about the technology than I do. Dad, use the voice assist to call mum. (Me: the voice-a-what?). The little button on the wheel, he tells me.

The wife: There’s so much room! Love the grey leather interior, reversing camera and how quiet it is.

The in-laws: Who did you kill to get this?

Well, if you were that way inclined you could fit three full-size adults in the boot, or four golf bags which is more likely in my case.

Once inside the E250 you are in motoring heaven. I expected everything that opens and shuts, and I wasn’t disappointed. The shopping list of features was well and truly covered off: sat-nav, Bluetooth phone and music integration, reversing camera, Parktronic system, Proximity Control (advanced braking in dangerous situations) plus lane change warning, sunroof, leather (heated and cooled) seats, Attention Assist (detects drowsy drivers) and the amazing Harman Kardon surround sound system.

This is a German luxury car, so of course many of the aforementioned features are optional. The Harman Kardon audio, glass electric sunroof and keyless start are part of a $6200 ‘Vision’ package, while the reverse-view camera costs $1100, the lane keep system $2100, and the 18-inch alloy wheels add $1800. With $2100 for our long-term car’s ‘Obsidian Black’ metallic paint, the total cost of our E250 CDI is $114,405 before on-road costs are added.

In a past life I was a professional musician so I am always overly focused on the sound system. So in my first installment I’m going to focus on the optional audio system.

Mercedes-Benz_E250_Entertainment_Console

Entertainment (Multimedia) System
For me, the sound system can either make or break the experience of driving a car. The test is when your favourite song is playing and you pull up at work you sit and listen until the end of the song. The Harman Kardon® Logic 7® surround sound system with Dolby Digital 5.1 and an output of 610 watts actually makes you want to stay for the entire album. Simply put, this is the best car audio system I’ve heard in years.
Whether it’s Usher, U2 or Ultimate Symphony, this Entertainment System provides a similar level of clarity as a world class recording studio.

Aside from the sound, the system has every conceivable input;

  • Aux-In socket and USB port
  • Bluetooth interface with hands-free function (worked seamlessly with my iPhone 4.0)
  • DVD drive, MP3-compatible, for video and audio DVDs/CDs
  • Colour display with TFT technology and 17.8 cm screen
  • Hard-drive navigation with topographic and 3D map display (city models, tourist attractions)
  • Hard-drive with 10 GB storage for compressed audio files (MP3, WMA, AAC)
  • Radio with equaliser and speed-sensitive volume control
  • Voice-operated control system
  • Automatic traffic alerts (TMC Pro)
  • Slot for SD memory cards

With all this tech crammed in the challenge is how to create a user-friendly interface that a four-year-old can navigate. Well, I have a four-year-old, so I put it to the test. He found everything with very little prompting. This is very important as the driver has more important things to do than navigating to the next song. Such as paying attention to the road.

For me, the E250 is definitely five stars in terms of multimedia technology and features.

On the road, the drive is refined and extremely comfortable, but I will leave this component of my review until I’ve had more time behind the wheel.


 

  • John

    could you please also provide costs for this pleasure ie comprehensive insurance and service costs, any repairs as you go. As well as economy true city v true country. It would be nice to know what happens when we trade up from tiger/jetstar to qantas. Good start so far.

  • Smart US

    love this review – great write up… maybe we end up knowing that even a normal under $40k can do what this over $100k Merc does  -without being bashed that this car has better cornering than Falcon ;-) its all about the journey but honestly its mainly about getting safely from A – B… 

    • ABCDEFG

      It’s only a $100k car because the car distributor (Merc Aus) says so :)

    • Zahmad

       Exactly, if a Merc can, so can the Falcon Ecoboost!

      • Rterterttyrtuy

        but the merc is desirable the ford is not

        • Smart US

           desirable – please explain… how many chick would you get a day owning this car??? how many marriages would destroy as a proud driver of this car??? how many more friends would you make??? would your wife have less arguments with you by owning this car (i doubt this point a lot)… or is it all mental weakness to satisfy inner craving on toys you always wanted but never could really get??? however i agree once you are CEO or dictator you better drive Merc

          • Dominique Vøn Hütch

            I think the Benz looks better than the Falcon, oh and women are more impressed by Mercedes than by Fords.  Fact.

          • ABCDEFG

            If you go to Germany, women are more impressed by Ford Falcons than by Mercedes.  Fact.

          • Smart US

            ABCDEFG summed it well… however E class does not look too good in any opinion… its a gentlemen car over 60+… the question still stands… are you driving your ego or a car… and yes… when u CEO or Dictator (of any country) u r granted Merc as a status thing compensating thinggie…sort of

          • Kampfer

            “I think the Benz looks better than the Falcon” Not the current E Class. Park E-Class next to a G6E without badges I’d bet most ppl pick Falcon is the better looking one.

          • Claude_defraud

            ‘desirable’ is not hard to explain.
            It means that many people are happy to pay 100k for this Benz but not for a Ford. These cars have a depth of engineering integrity & all round competence that Fords, Holdens, Toyotas simply don’t.
            Let’s not pretend that they’re all equal and that MB is ripping everyone off coz they’re either badge snobs or morons.

  • John

    Hey great review,

    I have been reading car advice for about 3 years but have never posted once. This is such an amazing and down to earth review that I just had to post. It’s simple and to the point and actually has information that informs me to what this car is really like. Thanks and keep up the great work.

    • Smart US

       …welcome to posting fraternity then… feel free to post anytime there is something on your mind… we love to learn from opinions ;-)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Karl-Sass/100000921334936 Karl Sass

    Very refreshing, well done : )

  • Tristan_jon_podger

    can you believe Mercedes charges 1100 dollars for a reverse camera on a 100000 dollar car, standard on many cars in the 30k price range.

    • Phil

      can you believe that some people are perfectly capable of reversing properly without a reverse camera?

      • Joe

        Its more with safety buddy. Don’t be a smart a&swhen a simple thing like a camera can prevent something tragic happening in someones driveway

        • Phil

          You still have to LOOK at the camera. You might as well just look where your reversing. If you want it, pay the $1100 – if I’m buying a car, I don’t want it and I don’t want it as standard as it forces up the base price..

          • Joe

            Of course you have to look at the camera you twit. The point is the camera can see in places you cant, ie the rear bumper. You can look around all you want you will never see whats behind you. Should be standard in a car like this.

      • Paul

        Yeah, being reliant on all this tech is really dumbing down humanity.
        I’ve been driving for 30 yrs without a camera or sensors and have never reversed into anything. 
        Feel a bit sorry for the younger generation, having all this stuff shoved down their throats until they can’t function with out it.

    • Zuk

      Can you believe a $ 500, 000 Ferrari hasn’t even got a reverse camera or even satnav?

  • ABCDEFG

    “Apple co-founder Steve ‘Woz’ Wozniak has sided with Australian consumers on the contentious topic of price discrimination, saying we shouldn’t have to pay more for technology goods that cost much less in the United States.
    His comments, made on ABC radio this morning ahead of a sponsored speaking tour of Australia, come as the federal government readies for an inquiry that will ask tech giants like Apple to explain why Australians pay more for goods such as music, TV and game downloads from iTunes than overseas customers.” TA

    • Bill Hatossy

      That is the sad part. We pay through the nose for everything here.
      all purely because the wholesale distributors can get away with it.

      The price discrimination in this country with most purchases but particularly cars and electronics is nothing short of scandalous.

    • Smart US

      …agreed… the thing is… since there are no physical border to get it from cheaper country – or short travel – they can rip u off… similar in UK – but since u can get stuff cheaper they are nice on goods… however car are more expensive due to rest of EU driving LHD… so its predatory politics of not having choice

    • Acfsambo7

      I find this funny, as Apple products seem to be priced higher than equivalent spec competitors. Also, companies selling Apple products can only mark up Apple products by a small margin.  

  • D987

    I’m not really a fan of the rims– they look a bit cheap.

  • D987

    I’m not really a fan of the rims– they look a bit cheap.

  • Infraboy

    What a vehicle..

    I really cannot see a single attribute that deems desirable

    -The exterior styling is terrible

    -The interior looks like it belongs in a Great Wall

    -It’s not a fast car

    -It’s expensive

    • Infraboy

      GS350 FTW

  • Peterson

    Very nice car, especially for a family.
    Love that secure feeling of driving a Benz…they feel so well engineered, poised & solid & unbreakable, & the build quality is great if they’re made in Germany.
    The 2.1 litre diesel is probably a bit small for this size car though.
    Nice review.

  • nugsdad

     ”Daily commutes aren’t helping fuel consumption, however, with the E250
    CDI’s trip computer revealing that our average 10.2L/100km is exactly
    double the model’s official rating of 5.1L/100km.”

    When will the government legislate to stop this false advertising. Who cares what it gets off a cliff with a tail wind. Official consumption is impossible to replicate in real world and should be changed.

    • Jerrycan

      Presuming that the test driving is around Sysdney or Melbourne during rush hours then the achieved consumption for this size of vehicle is reasonable.
      Be good if the tester also reset the odometer and went for a drive in the country and reported on the results. Maybe next edition?

      I don’t have a problem with the the current fuel test as such I just don’t like the fact that the manufacturers are trusted to give accurate and truthful results. They are not trusted to assess safety car ratings on their own vehicles, so why isn’t there an independant arbiter for for fuel consumption claims.
      It would not be too expensive to set up a test laboratory, it would be paid for initially by  the industry (and importers) and big fines on manufacturers whose cars don’t get within 10% of claims.

    • sam123

       Ok, so there is something terribly wrong going on there with the fuel consumption figures.  Firslty, the trip computer cant be trusted.   You need to fill it up and do the calculation.  Secondly, if it really is getting 10l/100km, that is terrible.  Truly awful.  My 1981 300TD gets 11.3 on the dot around the town, and my 1977 240D gets 10.   So (IMHO), either youre driving it like a maniac, sitting in stop/start traffic for ages, or the 10.2 figure is simply incorrect. 

    • Julian123

      Interesting fuel consumption figures.
      I drive an fg xr6 turbo in Melbourne peak hour and achieve 11.8 l/100km. But that’s ok because my car is a dinosaur that is not as technically advanced as this Mercedes. Diesel at the moment cost more than the priemium I put in my car so the difference is bugger all in regard to that running cost. Something must be wrong with this Mercedes for it to be using so much diesel.

    • Acfsambo7

      What people need to realise is that the Official fuel consumption is an average of city and country figures. If you sit in traffic a lot look at the city figures when buying a car, if you do long commutes with a higher average speed look at the country. They are only really guides anyway.

  • nugsdad

    Oh and Mr CEO I posted a comment in the toyota 200 million story you might like to read

  • MisterZed

    This would have to be one of the worst looking sedans on the market today.  The design is just a total mess.  If this car were an apartment block it would be one of those boring grey steel towers down in the Docklands of Melbourne (any of them, they’re all the same).

    • nugsdad

       Agreed I don’t think it has aged well

    • Golfschwein

      I don’t think it’s boring, as there’s far too much going on. Less Docklands, more Federation Square (a daring suggestion with me being in Perth and all), perhaps. Thing is, do people like it? Many say no, but underneath it seems to be a brilliant car.

      • Neutral Observer

        Well, that’s only half the package, unfortunately. People will starting turning to 5 Series, GS and A6 looking for the whole package. Just my neutral opinion…

  • auto

    why all the fuss about Merc being the ducks guts? They are used as taxis in Europe.

  • Guest

    Nothing to do with the car but why is every manufacturer and car review sites going to Larkin St in Waverton to take photos of their car???

  • brabus

    beautiful car, anybody who compares Ford to a Mercedes has no idea. The build quality and features on this car are 1st class. 4 cylinder engines are the future, however you are probabaly better off with a E350 petrol for true refinement and effortlessness.

    They are used as taxis in europe as they are big and reliable. they are actually similar money there too.
    In Australia we mostly use Falcon’s so does that mean if you have a GTP or whatever its a “taxi”? well yes

  • Josephshin

    That is correct.
    Who ever compares the Mercedes with Ford or Toyota or any other companies except BMW, Audi, Lexus have truly have never driven one.
    The current E class is truly a beautiful car and none to say one of the most technologically advanced car.
    The safety features that’s incorporated into these vehicles are quite amazing. The safety features comparison to other cars are one of them.

  • Sledge

    I agree that a G6E Turbo is a much more attractive car than the E class with its hyundai taillights, awkward  rear flares and messy front fascia. It does not mean that the Falcon is a superior motor vehicle even if it handles better, is much faster, costs half as much and you only take half a bath after 3 years.

    Yes I know they are aimed at different thickness wallets.

  • khpage

    If you really want better fuel mileage, install one of the Carlsson motor chip upgrades…

  • F1orce

    Oil guzzler!!

  • The Real Wile E

    If 110kph was the average from Sydney to Melbourne you must have been travelling well in excess of the speed limit for a major part of the time.And I note the first stop was 112kph average being in excess of the legal limit. I am no speed angel and I am sure the car was driven safely and could easily handle the speed but it may be not such a good policy to publish those numbers for trips on public roads.

    • notatoy

       I also noticed the 112kph straight away.

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Karl-Sass/100000921334936 Karl Sass

        So did I, but why ruin the fun? At least he’s being honest. 
        I would be concerned if he was doing something dangerous, but that’s not an unsafe speed for that vehicle or the Hume. That shouldn’t be illegal to begin with.

        • The Real Wile E

          Fun?

          • http://www.facebook.com/people/Karl-Sass/100000921334936 Karl Sass

            Speed.

          • The Real Wile E

            110kph is well…. yawn and hardly fun.

            And probably felt like 80kph with the driver battling to stay awake km after km of boring Hume highway.

          • http://www.facebook.com/people/Karl-Sass/100000921334936 Karl Sass

            True.

  • MangeRover

    Mercedes will not be happy with those consumption figures. Still the official position is that the computer numbers have an undefined degree of uncertainty, so it could have used much less. Then again it could have used more. Anyway it is nice to see that you are so trusting.

  • Zahmad

    Im more concerned with why he didnt take a break every 3 hours….

  • http://www.ooyyo.com.au/ Brian L. Gilman

    Good one Mercedes Benz… Really hit the nail on the head with this beauty… Good with or without the rear parking camera that should be standard on a $100,000 plus car…;)