Car Advice

BMW 118d Review

BMW 1

Pros: Great handling; firm but acceptable ride; torquey engine; excellent 8-speed auto; fuel efficiency

Cons: Styling is still not pretty; centre-stack still not premium enough; a Golf is cheaper

By Anthony Crawford |
Add to shortlist

Price: $43,500 to $46,200

Our Rating:  

It’s doubtful whether even those inside BMW’s HQ in Germany who gave the green light to the 1-Series ever thought it would be such a global hit when it originally launched in 2004.

After all, there were more than a few detractors, including long-time BMW aficionados and enthusiasts who didn’t see the car as a ‘proper’ BMW, and questioned the need for anything smaller than the benchmark 3-Series model. (They’ll go through it again no doubt with the forthcoming front-wheel-drive BMW being twinned with the third-generation new Mini, but that’s another story.)

History has well and truly proved the sceptics wrong, with the first-generation 1-Series notching up a not-too-shabby 1,219,365 global sales over its eight-year model life.

And while that might be a tad longer than the average life-cycle these days, the all-new, second-generation 1-Series has been well worth the wait – with a raft of improvements that should ensure this latest iteration should prove just as successful.

For starters, BMW’s latest 1-Series maintains its distinct advantage over its closest competitors in the luxury compact segment: it’s a front engine/rear-wheel-drive set-up with a near 50:50 weight balance and low centre of gravity, and as such, offers exceptional driving dynamics.

There are two engines used across the three variants that make up the 1-Series hatch range that includes two variations of BMW’s new 1.6-litre four-cylinder turbocharged petrol engine, and the 2.0-litre turbo-diesel that sits in our 118d test car.For now, the 118d is the only diesel variant in a three-model hatchback range that launched last October (the coupe 1-Series isn’t replaced for a little while yet).

Inevitably, its miserly official rate of 4.5L/100km (combined) betters the 116i (5.7L/100km) and 118i (5.8L/100km) petrol models, though it doesn’t lose any satisfaction in the driving stakes.

Although there’s only 105kW of power – not much more than a Toyota Corolla – 320Nm of torque guarantees plenty of punch out of the gate and even more impressive in-gear acceleration – thanks to that peak torque of 320Nm kicking in from as low as 1750rpm. Like many of the new-generation diesels, the 118d feels a lot punchier than its 0-100km/h time of 8.9 seconds might otherwise suggest.

Jump on the throttle (something you’ll want to do quite often in this car) and there’s minimal turbo lag and enough grunt on tap to produce what feels more like a hot-hatch than a super-efficient oil-burner. And with CO2 emissions of 118g/km you won’t have to feel too guilty about driving enthusiastically.

The smooth-revving four-cylinder turbo diesel is happy, in a petrol-like way, to spin out to its 5400rpm redline, though the meaty mid-range means there’s never really any great need to maintain full throttle in the 118d unless overtaking a B-Double on the freeway.

Equal to the task of shifting our 118d test car is the rapid-shifting eight-speed automatic transmission, which is another first for the category. With so many gear ratios on offer, there’s always plenty of ‘go’ without the need for the transmission to continuously  ‘hunt’ for the correct gear ratio. The downside is that it’s a $2695 option over the standard fit six-speed manual transmission, but it’s a option well worth having.

Stop/start technology is also standard to help improve consumption, though while it’s fine for short periods, but best left deactivated, if you face long periods in stop/start traffic, otherwise you may find it overly intrusive and downright annoying.

Of course, how fuel efficient you truly want to be depends on your driving.

More than likely, you’ll find yourself switching between ‘Eco Pro’, ‘Comfort’ and ‘Sport’ driving modes, depending on traffic and road conditions at the time. Choosing ‘Eco Pro’ will retard throttle response, as well as more time spent in the higher gear ratios for lower fuel consumption. In ‘Sport’ mode, throttle response is understandably more aggressive, and shift points are extended before changing up.

You can also choose to shift manually using the sequential shift lever, but we found the ‘Sport’ mode to be the best option when outright performance is a priority.

BMW doesn’t refer to the 118d as a performance variant in the same way it would, say, a 135i, or even the 123d. But when it comes to chassis dynamics and the way this thing handles corners, the 118d is every bit the consummate performer.

The steering is beautifully weighted and quick to respond, without being overly sensitive. That allows for a great deal of driver involvement whenever the opportunity allows drivers to press on a little. The car feels balanced and stable under moderate to high loads, while the brakes offer a level of composure under load that few other cars in this class enjoy.

Ride quality is excellent, like with most BMW’s; it never feels rigid, or uncomfortable. This is a very supple chassis that offers a decent level of comfort over almost all surfaces. That’s especially so when it comes to potholes; small or large, they are completely absorbed by the strut front and multi-link rear suspension combination. The only irritation is with the Run Flat tyres on this car; while we accept the benefits of being able to drive on a flat, they compromise what is otherwise a superb ride.

From a styling perspective, the 1-Series has never been considered BMW’s most aesthetically pleasing work. While the new generation car is certainly more contemporary in design, it’s still no Cinderella.

It’s a larger car all round (85mm longer) on a 30mm longer wheelbase and slightly wider for improved comfort.

Rear seat legroom, an issue with the original 1-Series, remains nothing special despite that wheelbase increase, while the rear-wheel-drive architecture also means a large transmission tunnel eliminates any foot space for the middle passenger.

On the plus side, there’s 10 per cent more luggage space with good height and depth for larger boxed items. Fold the 40/20/40 split rear seats flat and the 118d’s 360-litre cargo capacity grows to a sizeable 1200-litres stowage area. That means longer objects such as surfboards, skis and snowboards can be easily swallowed through the rear hatch.

The front track has been widened by 5.1cm and the rear track by 7.2 centimetres, so apart from the contribution of those slightly larger dimensions to the 118d’s excellent dynamics, it also has a more masculine profile.

The new front-end treatment, including larger grille, more pronounced bonnet and deeper front apron certainly have more road presence than the first-generation car, while the rear end styling remains relatively similar.

The side view looks better, too, with a distinct character line running from the taillight assembly through to the front wheel arch, which again increases the car’s masculinity and visual appeal over the previous model.

Our test car was optioned with what BMW calls the Urban Line, which includes various design accents such as the white kidney bars in the grille and a white trim bar at the bottom of the centre air intake and on the rear bumper trim. Other standout features in this option pack include a superb sports leather steering wheel and gloss white alloy wheels.

Inside, there are plenty of metallic accents and piano black trim to at least make the cabin interesting, but it still doesn’t feel quite as premium as it should.

Once behind the wheel though and it’s very easy to forget any such shortfalls in the look and feel department. The sports leather seats are some of the best in the business and position the driver deep into the car. They’re also superbly bolstered and hold your torso firmly in place whenever enthusiasm gets the better of you.

Yes, there are typically loads of options you can choose from for your 1-Series, but the standard kit inventory isn’t lacking in any way. Highlights include a 6.5-inch colour monitor linked to iDrive, Bluetooth phone and music streaming with additional USB interface, Automatic climate control with microfilter, park distance control – rear, automatic headlights and wipers, anti-dazzle rear vision mirror and 17-inch BMW light alloy wheels with run flat tyres.

Occupant safety is well catered for, too, with a full suite of active and passive safety features.

It’s difficult to think of a better combination when it comes to luxury, performance, ride and handling and fuel economy in the luxury compact segment than what BMW’s 118d delivers.

Rear seat space will be an issue for those buyers looking for good rear-seat space, however, while it’s worth noting you could buy the quite brilliant VW Golf GTI for similar money.

Until the new Audi A3 and Mercedes-Benz A-Class come along in the next 12 months or so, however, the BMW 1-Series is the best bet for those looking for an affordable hatchback with a premium badge on the rump.

 


 

Reader reviews of the BMW 1

<

Write a review for the BMW 1

Do you own this car? Share your opinion and add your own review below.

Add a New Review
>

The competition

  • Anonymous

    5800 RPM! I thought my 123d 5000 rpm was exceptional for an oil burner…

    You know what that means dont you? As the diesel power brands get wider, the gear ratios get shorter, the real world/daily driven performance goes through the roof, and the normally aspirated petrol powered cars start to feel even more like old asthmatic donkeys!

    I remember being told over ten years ago that diesels would never get over 4000 rpm, it was a technical limit of the combustion processes, having a slower flame front, how wrong they were…

    • Al

      good points, although they’ll never sound as good as a naturally aspirated petrol…

    • Gg

      I have and Aurion which i got for 15k and I will thrash this car..

      • Ima Hogg

        Yes and what Gg does that have to with this review? And yes the centre stack doesn’t look very premium!

      • Anth

        Yeh but people still think your a loser…

  • Anonymous

    5800 RPM! I thought my 123d 5000 rpm was exceptional for an oil burner…

    You know what that means dont you? As the diesel power brands get wider, the gear ratios get shorter, the real world/daily driven performance goes through the roof, and the normally aspirated petrol powered cars start to feel even more like old asthmatic donkeys!

    I remember being told over ten years ago that diesels would never get over 4000 rpm, it was a technical limit of the combustion processes, having a slower flame front, how wrong they were…

  • Devil’s Advocate

    Interesting Anthony. You say in the text it has a 5800rpm red line yet in the photo gallery there is a photo of the dash as clear as day that shows a 5400rpm red line with what looks like something similar to a “yellow line” at 5,000rpm. I presume you mean a 5800rpm rev limiter? Still fairly high revs for a diesel though. Does it “fall off the trough” like most diesels at around 4000rpm or does it keep pulling?

  • Anthony

    You’re right Devil, allow me to correct that error. The 118d goes better than the numbers suggest, and it pulls well above 4000rpm, better than other diesels of similar size, at least.

    • Devil’s Advocate

       Diesels sure have come a long way over the last few years. I would also imagine with that 8 speed auto it would hardly ever be caught out at the wrong rpm to give it’s best when you out your foot down making it quicker in the “real world” than the petrol in all else but a standing start sprint.

  • Philthy

    Can’t wait for a test drive of the 125i when it comes out… 160 kw, rear wheel drive, light weight 2.0l turbo hatchback :)

    • Philthy

      And it will be $45,700. 

  • Lbrinsmead

    This car should be compared to the VW Golf GTD, not the GTI. Still similar money though. It would be good to read a comparison between this and the GTD and Lexus CT 200h.

  • Marcuspetraska

    one of the issues cropping up with the fantastic new high-pressure common-rail diesels is their inability to tolerate ANY water in the fuel. with injection systems running up around the 20000bar mark, any fuel-borne water becomes a very effective cutting tool.

    with the price premium on diesels, i wonder if people who are buying them and expecting a pay back over a hundred thousand km will end up spending a fortune on replacing injectors before they get there…

  • Anonymous

    I hate the standard lights, My option would be the xenons.

  • Lavs

    Really can’t see why someone would buy this over the GTI

    • Karl

      rear wheel drive

  • Nasim

                       ADVICE

    1. The World market is capturing those countries, which are

    manufacturing and supplying cheap rate product in the market, Like

    China. Recently China fully captures the market of Bangladesh and

    exports one kind of small vehicle, which called Easy Bike in

    Bangladesh. People ride Easy Bike for go one place to another and they

    like this bike very much because it has no sound and air pollution and

    spend only 3 taka  for per kilometer. There are 6 sit in this vicheal.

    The main energy source of this vicheal is Battery and an electrical

    motor run the vicheal. The electrical motor takes energy from the

    battery. There are 5/6 Battery in a vicheal which charged by

    electricity and spend near about 10 unit electricity in a day. By once

    full charge the bike run only 80 to 100 kilometers. After 1 year the

    battery are damaged. After all battery need to replace. Although Easy

    Bike is an Economy and Environmental Bike but there are much battery

    and charge coast.

    2. Tata Motors Ltd. of India manufacture World’s cheapest car we know

    which name is Tata Nano. Although the mileage of Nano is 33 kilometers

    per liter but it is also true that, after 50,000 kilometers the total

    fuel coast will cross the prize money of the car.

    3. If we able to manufacture a car/ vehicle that will low/medium

    manufacture coast and the car/ vehicle shall no sound, no smoke and do

    not need any fuel or energy coast then what will be the situation? Yes

    we may able to capture the World market and remove the environment

    pollution. It is Possible To Made No Carbon & No Energy Coast Vehicle

    if we think about the procedure, which given below: -

    4. As example it can say that, a Dynamo and a Battery is connected

    with an Electrical Motor. The Electrical Motor started by taking

    energy from the Battery and self start system. When the Electrical

    Motor started the Dynamo also is started because Dynamo is connected

    with Electrical Motor. The Dynamo makes 10 Kilowatt Electricity and

    Electrical Motor take 3 kilowatt Electricity when it fully started.

    After fully start of Electrical Motor the electricity line of Motor

    shall connected with the electricity line of the Dynamo and the

    electricity line of the Battery will be disconnected. So the motor and

    Dynamo makes 10 kilowatt electricity from which the motor spend 3

    kilowatt electricity itself and 10-3=7 kilowatt electricity is extra.

    When the Motor and Dynamo is run the Battery will re-charge. By this

    procedure we are getting 7 kilowatt electricity without any fuel or

    electricity making coast. There is only machine establishment coast

    but there is no making coast of electricity. Then we will establish an

    another Electrical Engine which will run by 6 kilowatt electricity

    from that 7 kilowatt and this Engine will run the vicheal which will

    more powerful. Another 1 kilowatt electricity will maintain the

    electrical function of the vehicle and charge the battery. If

    necessary it is possible to manufacture more electricity.

    5. From my childhood I interested about mechanical and technical works

    and see that, there are huge crises of fuel in the world and

    day-by-day the prize of fuel is increasing. Then I think how the

    Vicheals in the road shall run without any fuel? After a long thought

    I decide that by above procedure it will possible. But in the

    Circumstance of Bangladesh it is not possible for me to try and made a

    new machine where is no car company and not possible to take a license

    easily. Here is not also enough facilities for made a new thing. After

    all I am a student and JOB SEEKER in Bangladesh decide to tell my

    thought to your company as an advice. I know that your company is a

    big, reputed, well-established, famous company and very much popular

    in the World. Your company made high quality and high-speed car but if

    you think about the matter and make my dream real then I will be

    happy. If you want I can work for your company. My information is

    given below: -

                                                        Curriculum Vitae

    Mailing Address:

    MD.Nasim Sarfaraz

    46/1 M.T.Road Khulna,Bangladesh.

    Email: advocate.nasim@gmail.com

    Mobile : +8801715-712515

    PERSONAL INFORMATION :

    Name                                 :       MD.Nasim Sarfaraz

    Nick Name                          :      Nasim

    Father’s Name                    :       S.M.Rezaul Karim

    Mother’s Name                   :       Mrs.Nadira Begume

    Permanent Address             :      46/1 Municipal Tank Road,Khulna,Bangladesh

    Present Address                 :      Same As above

    Date of Birth                       :      12-05-1990

    Nationality                          :      Bangladeshi (by birth)

    Marital Status                     :      Married

    Gender                              :       Male

    Blood Group                       :       B+

    EDUCATIONAL QUALIFICATION:

    Name of Exam.                         :       S.S.C (Voc.)

    Group                                       :       Humanities

    Passing Year                             :       2006

    Result                                       :       GPA-3.00 (Out of 5.00)

    Board                                        :       Jessore

    Name of Exam.                          :       H.S.C (Voc.)

    Group                                        :       Humanities

    Passing Year                              :       2008

    Result                                        :      GPA-3.40 (Out of 5.00)

    Board                                         :      Jessore

    Name of Exam.                          :       LLB Hon’s (4 Year)

    Department                                :       Law

    Institution                                   :      Northern University Bangladesh (NUB)

    Result                                        :      Appeared

    ______________________________
    ________________
    Nasim Sarfaraz
    Date : 28.01.2012
    Date : 21/01/2012

    • Snowman

      What are you on about?

      You might get a job at McDonalds if you come over to Australia.

  • Tom

    U.G.L.Y.

  • Nick2012

    Anthony, can you please advise if the “6.5-inch colour monitor” has any significant glare issues considering that it does not have any shrouding?