blog counter
Auto Route: Driving NZ’s South Island : Car Advice | News Blog

Auto Route: Driving NZ’s South Island

August 17, 2008 by Matt Brogan  




- by Josh McKenzie

The fly-drive holiday is an increasingly popular option for visitors to New Zealand. It affords a flexibility for those who wish to explore the impressive landscape that NZ’s rather lacklustre public transport system just can’t offer. More importantly a driving holiday in NZ gives you a chance to drive on some of the most entertaining and scenic roads the other side of the ditch.

 

nz_001.jpg

This particular drive is over five days and starts and ends in Christchurch. Traveling west from Christchurch, my route passes through Arthur’s Pass before heading south down the west coast to Queenstown. A short break in Queenstown is taken before heading north back to Christchurch directly through the guts of the South Island – driving through Lindis Pass and past some notable places such as Lake Tekapo.

It’s a route that flows through a variety of different road types, from flat open roads through to mountain passes and coastal highways. Being winter, conditions will also be variable with the possibility of closed roads and unexpected detours. Any car nut would be positively slathering with excitement.

Day 1: Christchurch – Franz Josef

The journey begins, but not without its disappointments. While I had reserved a Peugeot 307 2.0 litre HDi from Thrifty Car Rentals, I ended up with a base model Toyota Corolla from Avis. While whitegoods on wheels might be perfectly acceptable for some, any driving enthusiast is going to be disappointed with a car that’s engine, transmission and handling can only be best described as mediocre.

day-1-route.jpg

The aim of the day is to reach the west coast before heading south until a decent town to stay in is found. The initial drive out of Christchurch is along W Coast Rd and isn’t all that exciting. Views include sheep, numerous police cars and a spectacular mountain range that fills the horizon out all front windows. We’ll be climbing that.

day-1-001.jpg

Road leading into Korowai Torlesse Tussocklands Park

The transition into tight bends and steep mountains roads is quite quick as we enter the Korowai Torlesse Tussocklands Park (try reading that on a sign). A stop at the top of the climb where Lake Lyndon lies allows us a chance to enjoy our first journey above the snow line, and a glimpse into Arthur’s Pass. The Corolla’s performance so far is acceptable. Although the engine lacks the torque to quietly climb the hills, the ergonomic positioning of the auto’s controls allows us to manually keep the four-speed box in second gear.

day-1-002.jpg

Looking towards Arthur’s Pass from Lake Lyndon

The drive beyond Lake Lyndon takes us back below the snow line and snaking along the valley through Arthur’s Pass. Whilst we initially get a chance to absorb the impressive views, the weather quickly changes, bringing strong winds, heavy rain and poor visibility. Not great for driving through a mountain pass. This quick change in conditions becomes a common trend of the trip.

Day 2: Franz Josef – Wanaka

After a night spent in Franz Josef, the drive continues south along State Highway 6. The rain continues to fall for the good part of the morning as friend and I visit the usual tourist attractions of Franz Josef Glacier and Fox Glacier. Both can be recommended as nice detours from the main highway, however if time is a limiting factor – Franz Josef Glacier is the pick of the two for the lush surrounding forests leading up to the glacier.

day-2-route.jpg

Further south along the highway as we head into Haast Pass, our Corolla’s flaws become more apparent. Excessive road noise on long stretches of coarse chip bitumen wears away at our energy, making any bend look enticing. The catch here is that any bend highlights the Corolla’s lack of dynamic ability; excessive body roll, a twitchy rear end and lack of grip all have us wanting for smoother, straighter roads.

day-2-002.jpg

Snow capped mountains surrounding Lake Wanaka

Our wants aren’t met. Although the roads do smooth out as we enter the run along Lake Wanaka, the corners continue. Just as well the windscreen’s big, because the view is amazing. The jagged mountains still have their snow-capped tops lit up by the now out of view sun, providing just the smallest amount of light to allow the lake to glow.

Day 3: Wanaka – Queenstown

The temperature hovers around the freezing mark as we head out of our overnight stop over in Wanaka. Today’s destination of Queenstown is just a little over an hour away. The drive takes us through a fruit-growing region with plenty of stalls to stop at for a quick snack, and then on through Kawarau gorge, famous for having the first commercial bungee jumping site, off the Kawarau bridge. Traffic between Wanaka and Queenstown is heavy, keeping driving enjoyment down and frustration high.

day-3-route.jpg

After arriving in picturesque Queenstown and not being able to find parking to go for lunch, an executive decision’s made to go on yet another mini road trip. We pick a road and follow it. A few kilometres along, light rain turns to sleet… and then to snow. As we’re enjoying the moment of our first snowfalls, a sight many hope to see on a trip to New Zealand approaches us: sheep on the road.

day-3-collage.jpg

Glenorchy – Queenstown Rd

The road to Glenorchy, aptly named Glenorchy-Queenstown Rd, is reminiscent of parts of Victoria’s Great Ocean Road. The only difference is that this particular route is now covered in a thin layer of snow. Not to worry, the view more than makes up for the inability to exploit a few corners. And when you get to Glenorchy? … well, the cold weather was great for a soup at the Glenorchy Café (GYC, on Wills St).

Day 4: Around Queenstown

Today was meant to be a day trip down to Milford Sound. Mother nature didn’t like that idea though and instead decided to snow us into Queenstown for the better part of the morning. That’s okay though, because it mean we were able to enjoy Queenstown at its best.

day-4-route.jpg

Mid morning allowed us the courage to don our jackets, jump into the car and see what we could find. We followed another route along Lake Wakatipu, this time heading south. The snow prevented speeds much above 50-60km/h, which along roads like this, is a real disappointment. We were lucky enough to have the skies clear up for us though, and with that – stopped in Kingston for some lunch.

day-4-collage.jpg

Between Queenstown and Kingston

And here was the surprise of the day, the Corolla handled the snow brilliantly. Its skinny tires, lack of excess torque and insensitive throttle mapping all came together to make smooth progress on the snow and ice. Just as well, since the chains provided by the rental company were tangled and rusted in their container.

Day 5: Queenstown – Christchurch

Our final day on the South Island meant a drive back to Christchurch from Queenstown. Based on opinions from friends and family, we were expecting the drive to be close to 8 hours long. Reality proved it to be closer to 6 ½, including stops. The route back to Christchurch is just under 500km long and provides the most eclectic mix of road types and scenery of all the drives taken so far.

day-5-route.jpg

We exit Queenstown back through the Kawarau Gorge. At just after 7am, traffic is almost non-existent and the chance to enjoy the road’s corners is relished after Day 3’s not so involving drive along this road. The Corollas brakes hold up well as the road descends through tight corners to come out at Lake Dunstan, leading into the Lindis Valley. The Lindis Valley provides higher speed sweeping corners along the flat valley floor as we make progress towards the Lindis Pass.

day-5-001.jpg

Looking towards Omarama

The transition into the Lindis Pass is quite quick and dramatic. Clear roads turn to ice and the flat roads start climb. Although the roads are covered in ice, grit has been laid and safe progress is made without chains at speeds that the local constabulary would be happy with in school zones. It takes almost an hour to progress through the pass due to the conditions, but once again – the Corolla has impressed in conditions that are less than ideal.

day-5-collage.jpg

Clockwise from top left: Looking to Lindis Pass, Icy Lindis Pass, Lake Tekapo.

As we exit Lindis Pass, we enter the flat Mackenzie’s basin. Extending about 100km, the vast, flat spaces of the basin are surrounded by mountains that tower thousands of metres above. The higher speeds along the straight roads take us past the turquoise coloured waters of Lake Pukaki, with its views of Mt Cook, and Lake Tekapo.

day-5-002.jpg

Exiting Mackenzie’s basin is through Burke’s Pass, the final challenge before the long stretches of country highway along the Canterbury plains take us back to Christchurch. Despite the frequent changes in elevation and mid-speed corners, Burkes Pass just doesn’t have the grandeur of Lindis Pass and proves a little disappointing. None the less, it’s our final good bye to the Southern Alps as we’re soon back in Christchurch.

Final Impressions: The Corolla

I have to give credit to the Corolla, it never let us down. It’s that impression of reliability on which this car’s reputation is built. Despite some obvious deficiencies in comparison to the competition; lack of ESP, lack of power, cumbersome gear box, uninspired handling (and I’m only naming those that immediately come to mind), it seems to reassert itself as fit for purpose in the simplest of ways.

img_0546.jpg

Whilst it lacked grunt (100kW @ 6000rpm / 175Nm @ 4400rpm) and the four-speed auto was unwilling to down shift unless forced to, which was often, the 1.8 litre still managed to return a respectable 7.4 litres per 100km over the entire trip. No easy feat considering the mountains we climbed, and rather slow average speeds through snow and ice. The elevated ergonomic positioning of the shift gate also meant that manual control of the auto box wasn’t as much of an inconvenience as it could’ve been.

The handling could also be more entertaining. Varying degrees of understeer, lack of steering feel, body roll and slow turn in aren’t exactly fun. But these are things that can at least partially be attributed to the base model’s skinny tires. It’s those skinny tires though that cut through the snow in Queenstown and didn’t slip over the icy Lindis Pass.

p7051824.jpg

Quality seems to be there in most places frequented by your hands. All stalk controls, HVAC, audio and gear controls feel solid and precise. However, large areas of dashboard and console were covered in hard, cheap plastic – causing very obvious rattles between two glove box lids that were rubbing against each other.

Conclusion? I can see why it’s popular. When faced with reality, most people do just want cheap and reliable transport, which the Corolla provides. For the rest of us that don’t enjoy trade-offs, I recommend shopping around.

Next time in Auto Route Josh tackles the USA’s Route 66 in a legendary Mustang

Share this article:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • MySpace
  • del.icio.us
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Digg



Related Articles:

Suzuki Alto completes 3400km NZ economy drive
Two NZ motoring journalists have disproved the illusion that Suzuki's Alto is purely a city car tackling a 3,400 kilometre

Ford Falcon XR8 vs Holden Commodore SS AFM fuel economy challenge
Dyno testing Performance testing Economy testing Final results and conclusion Leaving Melbourne on an early, and slightly chilly autumn morning, our destination is Tarcutta,

YouTube or HoonTube?
Car fans from all over the world are more than familiar with YouTube. Millions of car fans post their own

Suzuki Kizashi US pricing announced, local launch due mid-2010
Suzuki has released US pricing for its new Kizashi sedan. To be made available in both front- and all-wheel drive, the

South African exports of Holden Ute to continue
Holden announced yesterday that it will export the VE ute to South Africa which continues a five year trend of

Comments

17 Responses to “Auto Route: Driving NZ’s South Island”
  1. Casey says:

    Good read! Hope this is a regular feature? The US Mustang adventure should be exciting.

  2. Minnow says:

    Wow, NZ is truly gorgeous

  3. Paul says:

    The south island of New Zealand is so amazing I have driven round it 5 times and its still amazing.

  4. Anthony says:

    Nice photography Josh and an excellent read.

  5. Bob says:

    Great review about the country and the drive itself, top effort.

    But onto the car… You say the following:

    “have to give credit to the Corolla, it never let us down. It’s that impression of reliability on which this car’s reputation is built.” Find me a renter in any brand that would have broken down or let you down on that trip. Had it been a holden Astra would you have said the same thing? Probably not.

    “Despite some obvious deficiencies in comparison to the competition; lack of ESP, lack of power, cumbersome gear box, uninspired handling (and I’m only naming those that immediately come to mind), it seems to reassert itself as fit for purpose in the simplest of ways.” Fit for what purpose? Not safety, ergonomics, comfort or driving enjoyment. Slightly important to people.

    “Whilst it lacked grunt (100kW @ 6000rpm / 175Nm @ 4400rpm) and the four-speed auto was unwilling to down shift unless forced to, which was often, the 1.8 litre still managed to return a respectable 7.4 litres per 100km over the entire trip. No easy feat considering the mountains we climbed, and rather slow average speeds through snow and ice. The elevated ergonomic positioning of the shift gate also meant that manual control of the auto box wasn’t as much of an inconvenience as it could’ve been.” So gutless, unhelpful, unintuitive and not overly economical… gets better.

    “The handling could also be more entertaining. Varying degrees of understeer, lack of steering feel, body roll and slow turn in aren’t exactly fun. But these are things that can at least partially be attributed to the base model’s skinny tires. It’s those skinny tires though that cut through the snow in Queenstown and didn’t slip over the icy Lindis Pass.” Yet another glowing endorsement. More entertaining. I can think of few cars that are less entertaining. Maybe Toyota should push the Corolla as a Subaru Impreza competitor, genuinely good in the snow.

    “Quality seems to be there in most places frequented by your hands. All stalk controls, HVAC, audio and gear controls feel solid and precise. However, large areas of dashboard and console were covered in hard, cheap plastic – causing very obvious rattles between two glove box lids that were rubbing against each other.” So mostly quality, but not all. Rattles and cheapness thrown in for free.

    Conclusion? Where do I sign up? Pardon me while I rush to my local Toyota dealer.

    Kind of a sad indictment that due to the cars almost total lack of any rational reasons for purchase/driving enjoyment, the “it didn’t let us down” is the highlight. There are 40 year old cars out on the road that won’t let you down either… pretty sad that Toyota haven’t really pushed this over what any roadworthy car probably would have done in the same trip.

  6. Reckless1 says:

    Nice read, nice journey.

    Pity the Toyota advertorial had to appear

    “Final Impressions: The Corolla

    I have to give credit to the Corolla, it never let us down. It’s that impression of reliability on which this car’s reputation is built.”

    Yes, folks, the Corolla did some 1250ks over an extensive 5 day period, without breaking down once. That’s clearly the stuff of which reliability legends are born and maintained.

    Damn, I wish my cars could do that………

  7. Simon says:

    A couple of comments

    – Let’s face it the Corrola was never designed to be a dymanic driving machine. Most of it’s many owners are just happy getting from A to B (around town)

    – Don’t think you mentioned the countless number of single lane bridges which sort of spoil some of the drive IMO

    – South Island and then Route 66 can I have your job…please

  8. David Twomey says:

    Auto Route will be a regular, infrequent future feature of CarAdvice.
    We’re glad you are all enjoying this innovation

  9. Reckless1 says:

    Yes, we are enjoying the innovation, but please in future make the advertorial for a very ordinary car a separate article.

    Then we might not “twig” that Toyota paid for the trip.

  10. Lloyd says:

    Great write-up and I agree 100% the comments about the Corolla. I wish the weather had been a bit better for you but winter this year has thrown everything at us.
    We hired an identical car while we were in Australia and as much as I recommend Corollas to people if they need a small car, I do not like this model as much as our 99 – 01 model (hatch) here in NZ. Our 99 – 01 model here in NZ at least was a ripper. This one feels less of a quality and to me looks like a bread van in comparison.

  11. Karl Peskett says:

    Reckless, this trip was self-funded by Josh. This is a car site, and so he made comments about the car. Big deal.

    Funny how if we write something good about a car, the article was paid for by the manufacturer in question, yet if we bag a car we get slammed for being too harsh.

    You can’t have it both ways, you know.

  12. Josh McKenzie says:

    Thanks for the comments guys, it truly is an amazing place to drive. Highly recommend it to all!

    I’m not quite understanding how people can consider me calling the Corolla merely adequate as praise though. I certainly wouldn’t consider my opinions on the car to be worth any sort of money to Toyota. I’d be quite worried if Toyota was happy with producing mediocre cars, paying me for pointing out that fact and then telling people to “shop around”.

  13. Captain Mainwaring says:

    You missed one of the best roads – the shorter and quicker route from Wanaka to Queenstown via the Crown Range, from where there are views to die for. Was it closed by snow that day?

  14. Mike says:

    Great story. I’ve travelled the South Island twice, although we went right around since we came in through Picton and have not done Arthur’s Pass. The second time was much better in a Focus instead of an ancient Capella, averaging 7.7l/100km. We also noticed loud road noise, and agree that the one-lane bridges slow you down, but then NZ roads are remarkable (it’s remarkable that they have such little-travelled quality roads in amazing and difficult country!). My wife wants to do the trip again, but in the colder months so she would enjoy this story.

  15. dave says:

    i did pretty much the same trip (in reverse) last november with my father and sister, except we went south from Christchurch.
    our first night was in Teanau before heading to Milford Sound then to Queenstown for a night, then to Wanaka for a night, Franz-Josef for a night then up the west coast and across through Arthurs pass and then down to Ashburton to stay with friends.

    while we were in NZ we caught the NZ v8’s @ Ruapuna, they are more entertaining than our aussie v8’s.

    im going back in march 09′ to do the east coast, Dunedin, Timaru to catch some NZ Ute, pre 65 and OSCA Racing, Omaru & it’s motor museum and up to Picton, Nelson and through Marlborough country.

  16. Shaun says:

    I’ve had problems with not getting what I ordered through NZ car hires Co.s – seems they want you to end up with some dodgy car which costs them next to nothing when you are prepared to pay for a nice car.

    The roads are that good but not sure I’d risk the cost of a return flight, accommodation and car hire on being stuck with a crap car for the duration.

    It would be an eternal disappointment

  17. James says:

    hi,
    good information on traveling through NZ south island.
    thanks.

Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word