MINI Cooper D Countryman Review | CarAdvice

Car Advice

MINI Cooper D Countryman Review

MINI COOPER

Pros: Great engine and gearbox, good economy, practical, handling, steering, something different to the norm

Cons: It's a bit expensive, as are the options

By Karl Peskett |
FIND DEALS

Price: $24,310 to $30,030

Our Rating:  

So, you want a MINI, but don’t want it to be mini? Then the MINI Cooper Countryman is for you.

It takes all the good aspects of the MINI – fun handling, funky looks, curvy interior, economical engine – and transplants them into a bigger package. By bigger, we mean a lot bigger. The Countryman variant has four doors, so not only does it give you more interior space (as in adults can actually get in and not suffer DVT) but it’s also a lot more practical.

No more climbing over a forward-folded seat, no more waiting for the driver to get out before you do. And as a driver, you don’t have to exit the car just because someone behind you wants to. Yes, the Countryman’s liveability makes it extremely appealing. But there’s more to a car than practicality. If that’s the only quality you were after, then we’d all be driving Kia Grand Carnivals.

Let’s chat about the elephant in the design studio – the Countryman’s styling. Okay, so it’s not as pretty as a regular MINI. I think I’ve worked out what the issue is, too. It’s the headlights.

Compared with a normal MINI, the Countryman’s headlights are no longer round, but have a bit of a wobbly look to them. The grille has thankfully been revised though, doing away with the downturned-mouth appearance  of the first model. It makes it a much happier looking car, which is exactly how a keen driver will feel when they’ve hopped behind the wheel.

The MINI Countryman is still a brilliant drive – no change there, then. But the biggest change is under the bonnet. This is the MINI Cooper D Countryman, meaning a diesel engine powering the car. It’s the same 1.6-litre, four-cylinder turbo-diesel as in the regular MINI Cooper D (incidentally, the automatic version gets a 2.0-litre four), running through a six-speed manual, and depending on your model, it’s either front- or all-wheel drive.

We’ve had both versions before under CarAdvice road test scrutiny, and we like them both, however the one reason you’d buy a diesel MINI is for its economy.

With the MINI Cooper D getting a staggering 3.8 litres/100km, it’s the most fun you’ll have in an econobox, period. So, how does the Cooper D Countryman fare? Not too bad, as it turns out. Officially, the fuel use is 4.4L/100km. We ran around the suburbs of Melbourne and finished up with 6.1 litres/100km. When you consider that’s city only, and for longer runs you’ll easily take a litre-and-a-half off that, it’s still a very economical car.

The engine is a very good example of a modern turbo-diesel, with a small amount of noise at idle, but perfectly quiet while on the roll. It’s smooth and punchy, making its best torque (270Nm) at around 2000rpm when you can feel it really pulling along. Of course, being a manual, you need to keep it in its sweet spot by rowing the gears a bit, but with the fantastically positive change, that’s no real effort.

It also has automatic stop/start like the other MINI diesels, so when you put it into neutral and let out the clutch at a set of lights, it will stop the engine, saving fuel. To restart it just push in the clutch and it cranks to life before you’ve even engaged first gear. Yes, it really does start that quick.

You’ll notice that in our review of the Cooper D, we criticised the cramped rear seats and the tiny boot. Well, that’s all been taken care of by this car. Yes, the boot isn’t huge, but it’s still bigger, and there’s good headroom and legroom for rear seat passengers. Oh yes, opt for the five seat version – the four seat car with the rail down the centre entirely defeats the purpose of this MINI, which is practicality.

The driving controls are all typical MINI, meaning excellent steering feel, a great driving position, good brakes and chuckable handling. It still has the raised suspension of the Countryman, meaning easier entry and exit for people coming along for the ride.

Speaking of which, the ride is an excellent balance of firmness for handling and bump absorption. Really, it’s a great compromise. The seats are also very comfortable.

So, what’s not to like? Well, the price. At $40,950 plus options and plus onroads, it may seem a bit steep. Especially when cars like the Mitsubishi ASX are around $31,990 in diesel form. But what you’re getting is a whole lot nicer to drive and something a bit more interesting than the lacklustre ASX. Plus, you can get an automatic in the Cooper D Countryman whereas the in ASX you can’t.

But you have to put it into perspective. The Cooper D (two-door hatch) is $33,750, a difference of $7200 to add extra doors and a slightly bigger boot. Is it worth it? Well, that depends on how often you’ll be carrying passengers.

If it’s all the time, then you may consider it money well spent. But if it’s only occasionally, then it may be a big ask for something that doesn’t handle as well as the Cooper D, uses more fuel, and is a little bit dopey-looking.

The MINI Cooper D Countryman is a good car and it is very practical. As a front-wheel drive diesel with four doors though, there are plenty of cheaper options out there.

At least you’ll have something that’s a bit different.


 

Owner reviews of the MINI COOPER Add a New Review

  • Hung Low

    This is the absolute bastardisation of the iconic original Mini by BMW!

    • test drive

      I saw one yesterday, it looks like the mini’s ugly sister which the family is ashamed of. My first reaction was who would buy one? I can imagine the drivers always feeling like they needed to justify why they parted with the cash.

  • Jake Williams

    If you want something ‘a bit different’ but a lot better, a Skoda Yeti would be a infinitely better option! Cheaper, faster, more powerful, better equipped, more room, same high quality and it’s much, much, much better value for money.

    • Bangel

      Better looking than a skoda .

      • Able

        No it’s not, the Countryman is absolutely shocking to look at, particularly from the rear. At least the Yeti is immensely practical

      • Pro346

        Agreed!

  • Henry F

    I saw one of these on the road yesterday. IMO, this is one of those few cars that looks better in photos than real life…

    • Don Quay

      Agree 100%, I saw one this morning and the front just looks wrong. What really surprised me was how large it looked which is so out of character for a Mini.

  • Alex

    The Skoda may be cheaper but we pay a premium for it here. Skodas are much cheaper than VWs in Europe but here they are almost the same price. We are being seriously ripped off in Australia.

    • Jerrycan

      I agree but you have to consider that some of the Volkswagen range are made in places like South Africa and Mexico. These have often been blamed for some of the poorer experiences here in Australia.

      The Skoda range are currently made in Europe and tend to have better results in reliability and satisfaction reviews than the Volkswagen equivalent.

      So in manufacturing costs terms, in Europe Czech undercuts Germany, and in Australia, South Africa undercuts Czech

      Of course all that may change when they import the Skodas that will be made in India.

      • Davo

        They will charge the same & just pocket the difference.
        Have seen the prices for Skoda at a local dealer.
        Expensive for something pretty ordinary.
        It isn’t about what it cost to build rather what the plebs are willing to pay.

      • Golfschwein

        Our Skodas will not come from India, according to the Skoda boss yesterday. Czech Republic will remain our source.

  • victor

    Here we go again with the Skoda yeti.Let bygones be bygones.That is a topic we exhausted already.Common consensus was that it was unforgivably ugly..
    Now back to the topic at hand,I quite like the countryman but $41k is outrageous and I wouldn’t even think about the hatch.overpriced

    • Davo

      Any one notice the fabric on the seats starting to ripple
      in the photos?
      Drivers seat & rear passenger seat.Not a good look for something with only 4000K’s.

  • Westie

    As BMC proved years ago, Mini styling doesn’t scale up. Think Nomad, 1800, Maxi, Allegro et al.
    Hatfulls, all of them. Now BMW seems to have missed their history lessons!

  • Crummydore

    Love the individuality of this car.
    Yeh, looks a little different, but for pete’s sake… ya all wanna be driving Corolla’s.
    I for one will have a good look at this car as soon as I can.

  • Robbo

    I agree with the bastardisation of MINI (should have remained just the Cooper), well it’s what BMW have wanted all along just to make it that way as a volume sell (well, low volume), but what still gets me is the asking price for the ‘S’ version with some options. I mean really, how nowadays can it be justified with other brands (esp. Korean) making these features standard? And you really are earning too much income to actually warrant buying one over other choices. And we all whinge we have no money, more like spending it on stupid choices of cars. Just sayin’ is all…

  • http://aol paulalou

    all jealous….!! bet all of you slating it can’t afford one!! I have one and its brilliant,its my 3rd mini and they keep getting better and better,you can keep your yeti etc

    • Thrillhouse

      I don’t mind this, but if there’s anything worse than a riled-up Apple fan, it’s a riled-up Mini fan. I wouldn’t buy one for that fact alone.

  • Douglas9305

    I think I’ll take the ASX – on looks also!

  • Ristonacevski

    Please make a test drive before you give your comment - you will be surprised ! Yeti is good but no body turns head on you when you pass by and after 1 year you want to change it – , if you drive MINI COUNRYMAN – after one year you would like to put stripes or additional head lights :)