Does Jeremy Clarkson perform his own Top Gear stunts? | CarAdvice

Car Advice

Does Jeremy Clarkson perform his own Top Gear stunts?

By Tim Beissmann |
FIND DEALS

Does Jeremy Clarkson do his own stunts on Top Gear?

This is the question that currently has the British tabloids in a spin, after the Daily Mail published comments from unnamed sources suggesting up to 80 per cent of the driving featured on the show is actually the work of professional drivers.

The Mail named Formula 3 driver Aaron Scott as just one of many ghost drivers employed by the BBC to take the place of Clarkson, and fellow presenters Richard Hammond and James May.

“Top Gear rely on professional racing drivers a lot more than the show would suggest,” a source said.

“I would say 80 per cent of the driving on the show is done by pros but it is made to look as if it’s done by Jeremy. When you see the wheels on a car spinning and smoke coming out, that will more than likely be a professional driver.

“It’s been going on for years. The fact is the presenters on Top Gear are presenters. They are not professional drivers, so why would you get them to do a job that an expert can do better, faster and in one take?”

At the centre of the controversy is a clip that aired in 2008, in which Clarkson was shown to hit 207mph (333km/h) in a Lamborghini Murcielago.

Another unnamed source told the Mail:

“That was Aaron getting to 207mph in the wet, not Jeremy.”

Understandably, Clarkson has reacted angrily to the claims and refuted them entirely in a response to the Mirror:

“Any claims that I fake Top Gear road tests are utter rubbish,” Clarkson said.

“When I say I’m driving at 207mph, it’s because I’m driving at 207mph. If the director chooses later in the day to get a shot of the speedo reading 207mph, then good for him.”

The BBC backed up its star presenter in a statement, insisting that Clarkson performed “all of the challenges you see him perform on Top Gear”.

“When Jeremy, James and Richard are seen driving on the show, it is them driving, but on occasion, the crew may need to go back and get pick-up shots.”

What do you think of the claims? And does it bother you that some of the driving footage is not performed by the three presenters? Let us know in the comments section below.


 

  • http://www.formalcars.com.au Tony

    Seems a bit absurd, what motoring Journalist wouldn’t want to do their own stunts? I certainly know I would want to drive a Lamborghini 207mph on a closed track.

  • http://electric-vehicles-cars-bikes.blogspot.com/ Paul

    Coco the clown and the powerslide school of car testing? Who cares!!!!?

    Q: What exactly is Top Gear proving by showing they can light up the rear tires?

    A1: That middle aged presenters can hold a bit of opposite lock on an airfield where there is nothing at the side of the road to hit?

    A2: The car has extremely poor traction/handling?

    • Bangel

      Correct only appeals to bogans .

      • The Spoon

        After these 2 comments I’m thinkin ‘Paul’ is short for Pauline & ‘Bangel’ is named after a fashion accesssory that women wear cause Top Gear is loved by real blokes, bogans or not & it makes me wonder that these 2 people aren’t men.

        Top Gear rocks!!!

        POWEEERRRRRRRR!!!!!

        • Bangel

          Fork i prefer 5th gear , a real car show not a comedy of buffons , who like their audience have low IQ’S .

          • The Spoon

            oh please. It’s entertainment!! So is Fifth Gear.

            Can’t stand folk that start banging on bout the level of intellegence of others.

            Do you drive a Volvo or a Camry?? You certainly seem like someone that does.

            Oh hang on that’s right . . . . . . . . . . Top Gear is now the most watched TV program!! Hmmmmmmm must be doing something right at BBC then.

          • Devil’s Advocate

            ….and Tiff, Jason and VBH don’t powerslide cars when they test them either? I don’t get it, you agree with Paul about Top Gear being for Bogans because of all the “powersliding”, but then say you like 5th Gear who also nearly spend more time going sideways billowing smoke than they do in a straight line…..

          • Bangel

            FORK 5th gear is intelligent car reviews , not comedy mixed with bare facts .

            Oh yes and read jeremy’s car reviews in the weekend australian , see how he cans just about everything he drives , did a good job on FPV , said it was rubbish .

            Read one of his so called books ,man has serious issues .

          • CRS200

            Gotta agree with Bangel.

            5th Gear is a show for “drivers” Top gear is entertainment.

            If I want to know about a Car I will go a see any review with Chris Harris (from EVO Mag) or 5th Gear.

            Top Gear is great I love it and they changed the way we look at cars but it’s no longer a proper review show. It’s purely entertainment, but a great entertainment show it is.

            Tiff Needle and Jason and Chris Harris are by far better drivers than any Top Gear “Jorno.”

            But if Chris Harris says it’s a great car trust the man!

          • Agnu

            Yeah Bangel, because he must have serious issues if he doesn’t like driving a Falcon…

            I’ve seen a lot of people call Clarkson a bogan, but then getting their panties in a knot about their precious Ford tyre-spinners negative review. Seems kind of ironic to me.

            But hey, he sure as hell likes Holden, so perhaps he’s just a secret agent from the Red Lion squad sent in to derail the blue train… Seems about as likely as him not actually driving the cars he reviews, anyway.

          • Richard

            You sound like you may be an accountant or someone who was born without a personality. shame

  • Camski

    How would one define a “professional racing driver”?

    The TG UK hosts may not be the next Schumacher, Hamilton and Webber but they sure as hell can drive a lot better on the track than most of us would know how.

    I’d trust them to hurl me around the track in a supercar, that’s professional enough for me and as far as i’m concerned, that makes them professional drivers, leaving the “racing” aspect for another argument, one that would likely see them classified as professional racing drivers anyway.

    That said, I do believe they do their own stunts/tests and if you deem the hosts as ‘professional racing drivers’ then that 80% BS figure is probably the 80% of the driving done by the hosts, with the other 20% done by other drivers, professional or not, to do the make-up shots.

  • The Specialist

    A certain wheels motoring journalist should use a stunt driver he cant even drive a kluger without rolling it and it apparently was not his first mishap?

  • Willie

    Top Gear isn’t a documentry, it is light entertainment at best. It’s not like it is the end of the world who’s driving the car in some action scenes anyway. Clarkson is paid mainly for comment in my opinion. Maybe it is the tall poppy syndrome again.

  • Uruwhenua

    Actually, if you read the Stig’s book (Man in the White Suit), he talks about the need to do filling shots especially when they’re doing a challenge.

    I don’t have an issue, because the show is all about entertainment; it’s not a documentary.

    • Devil’s Advocate

      Most of the challenges etc use “fill in” shots done later and have for ages.
      For example the “race” from Italy to London between the Veyron and C182 took close to 16 weeks to film due to varying/poor weather conditions etc and it’s limitations on getting good aerial shots etc around the alps and the like. Essentially they do the “challenge” to get the “winner/loser/play out the rigged script” with basic footage/commentary, then they go back later and get the “proper” shots. Cinematography like that doesn’t happen without a lot of planning/setup/right lighting conditions etc. Something you don’t always have when “in a race”. :-)

  • fezman

    The Top Gear Team has said for years that they do their own stunts….

    Alot of the time you can see Jeremy from the inside of the car working hard at the wheel in a powerslide while telling us the price of the car.

    I think the daily mail decided to throw this in the paper to distract from London’s riots.

  • Golfschwein

    So, like, the tabloids have just discovered this? Are they genuinely indignant at this incredible discovery?

    I’ll take Clarkson’s word for it that a producer can go back with a pro driver and record that split second take of the speedo reading 207 mph any time he wants to. It obviously didn’t happen in the moment. Hey, that’s television. Frankly, I don’t care how much footage is recorded with other drivers at the wheel. We just enjoy the end result.

  • Toxic_horse

    yea thats what i find funny. i was watching hammond blasting a mustang because it didn’t do good power slides. I mean seriously. how often does your averyage driver ever do a powerslide.

    • john

      That’s called hooning and they take your car off you for a month or forever.

  • nickdl

    Well I’m happy to believe Clarkson, but it wouldn’t really worry me if he didn’t do all the driving as the show is hilarious and not really a documentary. It seems as though the other papers in the UK such as The Guardian and the Daily Mail have it in for Clarkson, mainly because he writes for The Times.

  • shane

    dont know and dont care

  • Westie

    Next thing, they’ll “discover” Clarkson is an opinionated gobsh!te.
    Oh, hang on…

  • save it for the track

    I would think it was obvious from the recent episode where they raced around Monaco that they’re not professional race drivers, particularly James. Obviously over the years they would pick up some skills. The show is about entertainment and presenting cars in an interesting and entertaining manner, whether some of the driving is done by others to get a better screen shot or whatever, who cares.

    • Des

      Actually, from reliable accounts, James, AKA Captain Slow, is the supposed to be the best driver of the lot, followed by Hammond, then the producer, his mum, sister in law, the bloke next door, a few others then Clarkson.

  • omale

    that sequence of music from 6:06… which movie (or from where) have i heard it?

  • Μr Αρηιγι

    Some say he does not do his own stunts, others see him as arrogant, we all know him as a Μαλλακα

    • Aim

      It’s “Μαλάκα”, and he isn’t one, i enjoy his Comedy even if i may not agree with some aspects. I love the show, a lot, but if i didn’t i could always turn my TV off or switch the channel…

  • Jacob

    The Top Gear boys have the guts to drive through Iraq.

    Richard Hammond nearly died after a 400km/h crash in a jet powered car.

    They do their own stunts.

  • dadar

    Doesn’t really bother me to be honest. I see Top Gear as more of an “entertainment” show, rather than a straight up review / documentary show.. Sooo if that was what they needed to do to make the show more entertaining, then yeah sure why not.. Just my 2 cents there.. =)

  • Al Juraj

    This type of news is created simply to spark controversy and get opinions from others, like what’s happening here now.

    I believe Clarkson does his own stunts, as do Hammond and May. James himself even sustained an injury and taken to hospital in the Iraq episode, and something like that won’t be faked.

  • Rumps

    Ahhh…I see now, it’s all so very clear…that wasn’t Richard Hammond crashing the jet powered drag racer but a professional driver made to look like Hammond at injured himself…very clever :P

  • Commentator

    I can understand Jeremy’s statement exactly.

  • Girl Racer

    Re: JEZZA: I’M NO FAKER

    ’207mph car test really was me’

    How come Jeremy Clarkson is see in a film/video grab driving a left-hand drive car with a seatbelt over his left shoulder, but the photo/grab shows him standing in front of a left-hand drive car!!
    (see raised, rounded instrument panel on right side of dashboard. THE CAMERA DOESN’T LIE!
    JEZZA IS ALL MOUTH AND TROUSERS

    PS Scott can take me for a spin anytime…

  • Girl Racer

    Corrections to:

    JEZZA I’M NO FAKE
    ’207mph car test really was me’

    How come Jeremy Clarkson is seen in a film/video grab driving a LEFT HAND DRIVE car with a seat belt over his left shoulder, but the photo/grab shows him standing in front of a RIGHT HAND DRIVE car!!

  • Mad Max

    Maybe the papers hacked into their phones to get this great sccop? The fact is that Jeremy writes for the Times and has done for at least 10 years. If you read any of his books or weekly newspaper columns, he bags the Guardian and the Daily Mail on a regular basis. This just smacks of a childish attempt at a payback. Whether you like TG or not, its one of thw worlds most popular TV motoring shows and has made a packet of money for all concerned, the presenters included.

  • Tim

    Yet Richard was the one in a near death situation….not a “stunt” driver.

  • Gianni

    I’ve watched top gear for years now. The only stunts I’ve seen where the hosts don’t drive is when James may did a jump and crashed. Pausing you could see he wasn’t in the car. Jeremy Clarkson truly enjoys his job and wouldn’t give anyone else the experience. Whoever thinks he doesn’t do stunts are idiots. Brakingi n the McMerc, The powerslides, when he wrote Viper in the dodge and many others.

  • HJP

    Does not matter to me if Jeremy talks rubbish or not, however Tiff Neddell is a much better driver than Jeremy. I don’t watch Top Gear anyway although I like cars so much, I can’t stand of their garbage comments.