Mazda MX-5 Review | Car Advice

Car Advice

Mazda MX-5 Review

MAZDA MX-5

Pros: Fantastic handling, great sound, brilliant steering, world's fastest folding metal roof

Cons: No standard Bluetooth phone or music streaming

By Anthony Crawford |
Add to shortlist

Price: $44,265 to $49,805

Our Rating:  

Mazda MX-5 Special Edition 2.0-litre four-cylinder six-speed manual transmission, 118kW/188Nm: $47, 200 (Manufacturer’s List Price)

It’s a proper old school roadster with a front-engined, rear-wheel drive setup with a short-throw six-speed manual shifter and near-perfectly weighted steering. It’s also got 50:50 weight distribution for completely neutral handling, and the number beside the redline indicates a race car-like 7500rpm.

You’re looking at the world’s best selling sports car of all time, bar none. The Mazda MX-5 surpassed 900,000 sales across all continents in February 2011. The cost of this open air Mazda masterpiece is less than $50,000, so what’s not to like?

 

It’s a phenomenal success story that only began in 1989 with the unveiling of the first-generation Mazda MX-5 at the Chicago Motor Show. Add to that the Guinness World Record for the ‘World’s best-selling two-seater sports car’.

The Mazda MX-5 has also won a staggering 178 awards over the years and has even attracted unusually high praise from UK television personality, Jeremy Clarkson, who said,

“The fact is that if you want a sports car, the MX-5 is perfect. Nothing on the road will give you better value. Nothing will give you so much fun. The only reason I’m giving it five stars is because I can’t give it 14.”

He’s absolutely right. From the moment you feast your eyes on this proper little open top sports car, which was designed and built in the interest of reviving the wind-in-the-hair driving experience of those classic lightweight English roadsters such as the Lotus Elan and Triumph Spitfire offered, you’ll understand completely why the Mazda MX-5 has been such a runaway success.

It might be two generations on and a few kilos heavier (195 to be precise) compared with the original, but the 2011 Mazda MX-5 offers that same lightweight roadster experience, only better again.

Styling-wise, the latest Mazda MX-5 looks more aggressive than its predecessors with an aggressive all up stance from its deeper front fascia and bulging front and rear wheel arches. It’s a lot more focused too, with even shorter front and rear overhangs than the previous series cars and infinitely more aerodynamic.

Our test car is not your standard MX-5 though. It’s one of only 200 Special Edition models produced, and although the drivetrain and power outputs are identical across the MX-5 model range, this car has a few well-chosen upgrades. It would be hard to improve the superbly comfortable sports leather seats, but these pews are upholstered in unique grey leather that contrasts with the aluminum metallic paint job perfectly. You’ll also like the special bright painted 17-inch alloys, which resemble proper forged wheels.

Few would ever suggest Mazda needed to beef up the suspension on the MX-5 given its well-deserved reputation as one of the best handling sports cars in the world. But that’s exactly what it has done with this Special Edition model, by upgrading the standard suspension package with a more specialised Bilstein-tuned setup. You still get the exceptional road holding and grip levels afforded by the double wishbone front and multilink rear suspension systems, but the Bilstein shock absorbers enhance those attributes further.

The Mazda MX-5 is capable of carrying a lot of speed through the corners and it seems like the harder you push, the better it gets, with very little body lean.

It’s a bit of a treat when you slide down low into the MX-5, especially when a quick glance at the large red zone on the tachometer turns into a fixation as your brain confirms the redline is sitting equally between 7000rpm and 8000rpm.

Firing up the Mazda MX-5 is achieved via the old key in ignition barrel process, and frankly, Mazda would do well to adopt a power/start button as used on the Lotus Elise these days. It’s much more befitting a proper sports car, which the MX-5 truly is.

It may not be the world’s most powerful 2.0-litre engine, which is essentially carried over from 2006 when the first of the third-generation MX-5s rolled off the line. However, there were a few subtle improvements made, such as a forged crankshaft for less vibration at speed and higher rev limits. Overall power and torque outputs remain the same, while fuel economy improved markedly.

Don’t let that perceived lack of power worry you. At 1167kg (37kg less for the soft top) there’s still plenty of punch whenever you prod the accelerator pedal, and it’s pretty much instantaneous. Call that a very good power-to-weight ratio with the resulting characteristic being a rapid throttle response anywhere north of 2500rpm. It’s not that off the line starts are slow by any account, but at around 3000rpm, in-gear acceleration feels quick.

Of equal driving pleasure is the MX-5′s classic old school sports car engine note, which is seemingly on tap whenever you dab the right pedal. That aural note becomes seriously addictive after a while, so that even backing out your driveway will require a few pumps of the throttle just to fuel your newfound MX-5 addiction.

It’s not by chance either. Mazda engineers made sure the MX-5 had a distinctly sporty engine with further development of the ‘Induction Sound Enhancer’ which amplifies and varies the exhaust note depending on the degree of throttle input. The best part is that you don’t need the roof down to enjoy this glorious note (although it does sound better) as it somehow filters into the cabin, rendering the Bose audio system superfluous.

I’m sure the Activematic (read automatic) transmission has its rightful place in the MX-5, especially for those who practice the peak-hour commute each day. But for the love of God, if you are proficient with a manual shift you’ll want the six-speed box with the extra-short-throw shifter for that proper sports car experience. The shifter itself is no longer than your index finger and the clutch is beautifully weighted for fast shifts. It gets better from the very moment you discover the drilled aluminium pedals are perfectly positioned for heel and toe shifting.

With the MX-5 it all comes together perfectly, but just like the six-speed shifter, the steering feel and response is as good as it gets. There is not one millimetre of play either side of the straight ahead and it’s the same all the way through to full lock. There are sports cars four times the price of the Mazda MX-5 that don’t handle as good as this thing.

Grip levels during hard cornering are extreme and that’s despite the MX-5 running on rather narrow 205/45 series tyres. That said, the lower profile rubber clearly helps with traction. So does the standard fit limited slip differential, which practically eliminates grip loss and wheel spin in the Mazda even when trying to do so.

It was the same story in the torrential rain Sydney had a few weeks back – traction and grip on board the MX-5 was exceptional and very confidence-inspiring.

As owners and prospective buyers will appreciate, the ride in the MX-5 skews on the side of firm, but there’s no harshness whatsoever felt inside the cabin.

This third generation is both a stiffer and lighter bodyshell than the second-generation MX-5, so flexural and torsional rigidity is high, but the Bilstein dampers ensure that the ride is always pliant and could never be said to be in any way uncomfortable.

Inside the MX-5 cockpit, space is well managed with plenty of room where it counts – in the footwell. There are more than a few well-known sports cars that lack sufficient room around the pedal box, but the MX-5 isn’t one of them. There’s even an unusually wide driver’s footrest (also drilled aluminium) making long, slow drives on the freeway quite a comfortable experience.

The seats are exceptionally supportive and bolstered, but not to the point of putting the squeeze on anyone larger than a Formula One pilot. They’re just very well designed to hold your torso in place during those more enthusiastic driving moments.

The centre console is neat and the switchgear layout is refreshingly simple, but there are a few disappointments to report. There are few if any soft touch materials employed in the MX-5 (at least I couldn’t find any) although the plastics have a high-grade look about them. I thought at least the dashboard might have been soft touch.

There’s a decent Bose audio system on board but unless you go ahead and purchase a couple of factory options that will enable Bluetooth phone and a direct iPod/iPhone connection, all that you get is the limited functionality of an auxiliary port. That’s a bit of a shame when there are perfectly good remote buttons on the steering wheel to up the volume and change tracks.

No such criticisms of the main instrument cluster though, with a backlit red glow with bight white gauge needles for easy reading at night.

Our Mazda MX-5 Special Edition is essentially a Roadster Coupe, which means exactly that – it’s both a hard top coupe and a roadster, depending on which way you flick the switch. The MX-5 has what must be the world’s fastest electric folding roof, needing just 12 seconds to open or close.

Better still is the fact that, unlike many of these mechanisms, the MX-5′s roof does not impede any of the boot space when lowered and is all but a silent operation when in use. The roof itself weighs a relatively light 37kg and the principle reason why there is no discernible difference to the handling and dynamics of the car when in the lowered position.

It may be a diminutive sports car but the Mazda MX-5 has plenty smart storage space on board including the 150 litres in the boot and a multitude of nooks and crannies throughout the cabin.

Safety is well accounted for in the MX-5 too with front and side airbags for the driver and passenger, brilliant stopping power and the benefit of Dynamic Stability Control and Traction Control as standard fitment.

Fuel consumption is listed as 8.1L/100km combined, but we wouldn’t know. We were in fact way too busy having fun in the MX-5 to give fuel conservation a second thought. The best advice I can offer is that there was still plenty of fuel in the tank (at least 25 per cent) when I handed the car back to Mazda a week later. It’s also fair to say that we were none too conservative in our driving style that week.

The Mazda MX-5 is a thoroughly modern take on a proper lightweight old school front-engined rear-wheel drive sports car. It also offers one of the most exhilarating driving experiences you’ll find in the automotive world today regardless of price and power and it has no peers when considering price point and the overall package.


 

Reader reviews of the MAZDA MX-5

<

Write a review for the MAZDA MX-5

Do you own this car? Share your opinion and add your own review below.

Add a New Review
>
  Variant Body Style Price From
MAZDA MX-5
  • 2.0L MULTI POINT F/INJ
  • 6 SP MANUAL
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D CONVERTIBLE $42,460*
MAZDA MX-5 COUPE
  • 2.0L MULTI POINT F/INJ
  • 6 SP MANUAL
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D CONVERTIBLE $47,200*
MAZDA MX-5 COUPE
  • 2.0L MULTI POINT F/INJ
  • 6 SP AUTO ACTIVEMATIC
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D CONVERTIBLE $49,325*
MAZDA MX-5 COUPE SPECIAL EDITION
  • 2.0L MULTI POINT F/INJ
  • 6 SP MANUAL
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D CONVERTIBLE $47,200*
MAZDA MX-5 COUPE SPORTS
  • 2.0L MULTI POINT F/INJ
  • 6 SP MANUAL
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D CONVERTIBLE $49,805*
MAZDA MX-5 COUPE SPORTS
  • 2.0L MULTI POINT F/INJ
  • 6 SP AUTO ACTIVEMATIC
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D CONVERTIBLE $51,930*
MAZDA MX-5 TOURING
  • 2.0L MULTI POINT F/INJ
  • 6 SP MANUAL
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D CONVERTIBLE $44,265*
MAZDA MX-5 TOURING
  • 2.0L MULTI POINT F/INJ
  • 6 SP AUTO ACTIVEMATIC
  • PREMIUM UNLEADED PETROL
2D CONVERTIBLE $46,390*
powered by
  VEHICLE PRICE
2001 MAZDA MX-5 OTHER NB 8B
  • 85,198 Kms
  • Silver
  • 2d Convertible
  • Manual
  • Petrol
  • NSW
$14,995*
Enquire Now
2000 MAZDA MX-5 OTHER NB
  • 100,221 Kms
  • Blue
  • Convertible
  • Manual
  • Other
  • NSW
$9,800*
Enquire Now
2006 MAZDA MX-5 TOURING NC SERIES 1 MY07
  • 40,281 Kms
  • Blue
  • Softtop
  • Manual
  • Petrol
  • VIC
$24,950*
Enquire Now
Showrooms > Mazda > Mx-5

Mazda MX-5 Review
Mazda
Mx-5
It’s a proper old school roadster with a front-engined, rear-wheel drive setup with a short-throw six-speed manual shifter
JBI11A
http://www.caradvice.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/AC-MX-5-IMG_8155-625x416.jpg

Mazda MX-5 Review
It’s a proper old school roadster with a front-engined, rear-wheel drive setup with a short-throw six-speed manual shifter
3.5 stars
  • Pauly

    Awesome car, good review, although I think you will find the roof is made of plastic, again to save on weight.

    • bangel

      BRILLIANT drivers car , handling that others only dream of .

  • TenFour

    I’m not convinced. We have one of these (an NC, but not this latest update). It’s a good car and all but…

    * A new one is far too expensive for what you actually get. The price these sell for in the US is much more realistic. However, used, they’re a good buy.
    * There’s too much plastic. Everything is scratchy black plastic, and it attracts dust. The interior is nothing like sports cars of old.
    * The whole thing lacks…theatre. The exhaust note is subdued, the engine lacks punch unless you drop it back to second or third…handling aside, it’s rather like driving a roofless Camry.

    Perhaps with a turbo whistle, louder exhaust, a less plasticky interior and a slightly lower cost, this really would be perfect.

    I’m still not convinced on this MX5…

    • bangel

      Why did you buy it then with so many negatives , especially being non turbo.

    • Milsie

      You clearly have not driven a Camry if you think an MX-5 is comparable…

    • Igomi Watabi

      get into the aftermarket for what you’re looking for.

  • Pauly

    I agree the price should be cheaper, as the Aussie dollar is going strong. However with little competiton at that price point, there is no reason for Mazda Australia to change their stance.

    Maybe once VW get that roadster concept into production?

  • Sam 300TD

    I can remember standing outside the Mazda dealer in Colac in 1989 as a 12 year old. I was taken by the new MX-5, it was a red one in their showroom. I recall saying to someone that it was the coolest sports car I had ever seen and when I grow up I want one.

    Well I’m all grown up now (sort of)and I still want one. Kudos to Mazda. Job well done. Now, who can lend me 50k?

    Also how much was the original selling for in ’89 does anyone know?

    • YoLex

      The original sold for $27-29K new.

      • Sam 300TD

        Wow. Would have been money well spent. I guess if you buy a new one now and look after it for 20 years it would be great value at the end too. All that fun motoring for the next 20 years…..

    • davie

      you can check redbook online. They list (by year) the value of the car when originally sold.

  • Douglas9305

    I have had two of the original generation – both fantastic cars and instantly felt affection for them. Wish I had kept the green/tan one I had last – fantastic buying 2nd hand (10-15k gets a great car) but find the $50k price tag for the latest ones a bit of a joke given the age of them now…..come on VW/Porsche with a rival to force the price down…..

    • http://www.ozmazdaclub.com Tien – OzMazdaClub.com

      I must agree with you there

      I have the 2nd generation MX-5 and love it.

      I have looked at getting a brand newie but that 50k price tag is a turn off and not to mention it doesn’t hold its price value very well

  • Matty B

    I don’t know how you could call any car with that face “agressive” It looks like an anime character.

  • Robert LONTIS

    As the acknowledged FIRST person in Australia to ever order an MX5 , on 14 February 1989, and yes, I still have the original order form, price,colour and specifications/options TBA. The dealer did not know what I was on about, we don’t make a convertable, don’t you mean an MX6?, but yes we will take your $1000 deposit.
    Specifications were released and advised on 6th June 1989, production of export RHD models was advised on 28th September 1989, and I took delivery in October, one of 8 to come to SA, VIN JMONA306100100079, red of course.
    Base price was $29,500, Air either $1625 as per the distributor or $1900 according to the dealer. Optional hardtop was again $2100/$2184, and only came in a mottled black, the red and white versions were much later. Total on road price was $33,583, so I consider the ask for a new one at cica $50K not to be unreasonable considering the difference in earning potential from 1989 to 2011.
    A house I bought for $210,000 in 1985 recently sold for $2.35m, not mine any more, but it sort of puts things into perspective for the tightwads out there. said MX5 was heavilly modified and was still the fastest in the land at 1994 NatMeet, won every round of MSCA supersprint series in its class for 5 years straight, and got me A runner-up overall competition champion trophy one year. beaten by 0.01 of a second on corrected averages, damn!
    Drive a new MAZDA 3 Neo hatch 6sp these days,with SP25 17″ wheels of course. Damn thing gets better than 6.9L/100km average, and has good comfort,room, and roadholding, but don’t kid yourself kiddies, nothing this side of a clubman handles like an MX5 of any age, and you really do have to spend upwards of $200,000 to get anything that handles as good.
    The beasta

    • Freddo

      ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

      • Roadtard

        I’ll bet Robert’s a hit with the ladies…

      • Robert LONTIS

        Verbosity aside, I find your comment in reply…um..scintilatingly intellectual!

    • Sambo

      You need a job mate

      • Robert LONTIS

        Had one for 45 years Sambo, now step back off that platform

    • Jonty

      Good stuff Rob, glad to hear some passion on these pages.

      As for you knockers…well you are just that.

    • Jo Blow

      Seriously? ZZZZZZ – Get a life

  • Andy0217

    Are heated seats standard in this thing?

  • Rubes

    You love taking your cars down to long reef don’t you. I don’t blame you either, nice location.

    • http://www.caradvice.com.au Anthony Crawford

      Yes, it’s a great place to shoot cars and it’s relatively quiet late afternoons.

  • UMWHAT

    Even if this is Australia and it’s the norm to get ripped off here, and even if the MX-5 is all about handling not power, I still think it’s too expensive for what you get

  • http://ozmazda.com ozmazda

    awesome report and I’d have one in a heart beat…..if I had the funds…maybe a good 90′s model will surfice.

  • PeterG

    For this price it should handle AND perform .

    Good formula but not enough grunt.

  • pja

    The most biased thread i’ve ever come across on this site…

    45k will buy a 3yro BMW Z4 3.0L convertible with reasonable kilometers. we passed on this to go with a functional car instead.

    slap on extended warranty, and find a non-ripoff service mechanic, the mx5 for similar mooney is downright ridiculous in comparison.

    • Sam 300TD

      I wouldn’t necessarily agree with that. I love z4s and I have shopped for a Z4 recently and you can hardly get a decent 3.0lt ’06 model for 45k. The holding cost of the Beamer would be twice as much as the Mazda. Tyres, rego, pertol and servicing would all cost substantially more with the Beamer and Insurance would be astronomical in comparison I reckon. Beamers have to be serviced at a dealer too don’t they? Special computers or something. If you can find an ’08 3.0 z4 for 45k in great nic, buy it!

      • pja

        the one i saw was a 08 3.0 convertible with 70,000km. advertised for 45k private seller in the eastern burbs.

        is your price estimate for dealers? they’ll be substantially more of course.

        • Jo Blow

          Buying a used Beamer is like a dating an old bird from nursing home with dementia… Live within your means…

        • Sam300TD

          If you have the money to keep it, buy it!

        • KO

          70,000k’s is hardly comparable to a brand new MX-5

          you might as wells buy an MX-5 with 70,000k’s and save even more.

          or better yet buy a used Lotus elise or Porsche Boxter S for 45k

          • http://www.caradvice.com.au Anthony Crawford

            Agreed, 70,000 clicks is over 3 years driving, and while the Boxter at 45K is tempting (a very good one will cost you closer to 60K) the cost of ownership will be considerably higher with insurance, service and tyres alone, not too mention any mechanical problems or replacements. If anything, the MX-5 provides a more exhilarating drive than the Boxter, but it has more space.

            The Lotus Elise is a brilliant drivers car, but it’s no where near as practical for day-to-day commuting as the MX-5 or the Boxter.

            Much less grief with a new MX-5 than either of the other two, and you have the benefit of a new car, which counts for plenty.

    • Old Dog

      for my 50k, a one year old 370z (roadster if thats your thing) is a far better buy, with real sports car performance.

  • http://www.caradvice.com.au Anthony Crawford

    You mean a MY2009 Coupe with 37K on the clock, because that’s the best you’ll do for a dealer car. A roadster will cost you plenty more. It’s still good buying but the MX-5 will be a lot cheaper to own and maintain, and gives nothing up in the handling department.

  • Ash

    Unless you have OWNED an MX-5 you have no idea what you are talking about…

    Comparing a BMW or 370Z (both heavy overweight SLOBS)..

    An MX-5 has NEVER been about POWER..

    You have more fun driving a slow car fast than a fast car slow!…

    That is why I own both the latest RX-8 and MX-5.
    Yes, we are ripped off in Australia for ALL cars…greedy importers are pocketing our High Dollar margins…if only we can import cars from OS on-line!!