Grandparents safer drivers than parents: study | Car Advice

Car Advice

Grandparents safer drivers than parents: study

By Tim Beissmann |

Children are 33 per cent less likely to be injured in a car crash when their grandparents are driving rather than the children’s parents.

New research by the University of Pennsylvania and the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia revealed the surprising findings, which seemingly defy other crash statistics.

The researchers looked at insurance data from car crashes in 15 US states between 2003 and 2007. The data involved almost 12,000 children aged below 15.

Overall, 0.70 per cent of children were injured when riding with their grandparents, compared with 1.05 per cent who were injured when one of their parents was behind the wheel.

Even though only 10 per cent of children were driven by their grandparents, the report showed they suffered proportionally fewer injuries.

The report’s lead author, Dr Fred Henretig, said he was surprised at the study’s conclusion.

Older drivers are known to be involved in a higher percentage of car crashes. They are also more likely to drive older cars and are less likely to fit child car seats properly.

Researchers believe the circumstances of the car trips made by grandparents could have an impact on the results. They suggested grandparents could be less distracted and less busy than parents, and that driving might be a form of relaxed ‘quality time’ with the grandchildren.

The locations of trips – busy cities versus quiet roads – could also influence the results, but was not included in the study.

The average age of the grandparents in the survey was 58 – quite young as grandparents go – so most did not fit the stereotype of a frail old battler limping to their car on a walking frame.

What do you think of the findings? Are grandparents really safer drivers, or are there too many other factors at play here to draw a conclusion? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below.


 
  • save it for the track

    Average age of 58??? I’d say that not a large enough number or ‘pool’ of subjects were used, along with the age obviously being too low. Obviously in the story the pictures have been cobbled together from somewhere, look at the first picture, i would not like my children to be in the car worth that woman, look at the stiff outstretched arms, very poor technique.
    .
    Not enough parameters and not a great enough number of subjects with a high enough age.
    .
    Aferall there would be certain areas in the UK and even Sydney where ‘grandparents’ would be the ripe old age of under 40.
    .
    too many factors to draw a conclusion.

  • SAM

    Agree with ‘save it for the track’, there are definitely not enough parameters in their studies to come to such a rubbish conclusion. Think about it:

    Kids are in the car with their parents more often than theyre grandparents so obviously the more time one spends on the road, the more likely you are to be in an accident.
    Doesnt mean they are any safer.

    Secondly it is a fact that grandparents tend to steer away from high speed roads and are more likely to pop up to the shops with grandkids rather than taking a trip to the beach or go for a spirited drive in the country.

    Who makes the call to release these studies?????

  • rentakeyboard

    Beware the Toyota with the invisible driver!

    • Brayden Cresswell

      I see more people in Getz these days compared to Toyotas

      • Brayden Cresswell

        old*

  • Riguez

    Apart from the avg age of 58 problem, another big issue is using an “injury to crashes ratio” to draw the conclusion. “injuries per kilometre traveled” is waaaayyyy better as it takes into account big missing variable – propensity to crash.
    If he can’t get his hands on the data for injuries per kilometre, then the only conclusion he can make is that the crashes grandparents are involved in are at lower speeds.
    …Dimwit

  • D Is For Drive

    I discovered the other day while riding in the passenger seat of my grandmothers car, she drives an automatic, accelerates with her right foot and brakes with her left…